Need cheap katana , Under $170

Joined
Oct 13, 2000
Messages
17
I have wanted a straight katana as seen in the anime movie Ninja Scroll
I have saved up $170 , only to find out a good working katana might cost me $400 AND UP
I am 15 years old , and cannot afford that much
I have seen katana's for $ 50 on ebay
Are those ripoffs or are they realy a normal product?
 
Hey there...
Not having a good enough memory to remember the swords from Ninja Scroll, I don't really know for absolute sure what you're looking for.

If you are looking for something more decorative and not intended to be used in a proper fashion, there are likely a number of options out there. Beware of seemingly great deals though...if it seems too good to be true, it usually is. Among the scrap heap you will find pieces of stainless steel that are awfully wobbly, not heat treated at all, have piss-poor handle-tang construction to the point where you would not want to even hold it upright, and badly made aluminum scabbards.

Also among these are nice decorative swords that are still not suitable for consistent proper use, but have a reasonably nice fit and finish to them that could make an owner proud.

I'm unsure of the exact price but Hanwei's Practical katana is probably sub-$200 still, and judging from varying testimonies, is good for the money. It's reasonably traditional styled, and the blade can do some realistic cutting. I have not handled the newer models of Practicals, so I cannot give you definitive answers on it. It appears to be decent for the money.

Another pair of options is from Kris Cutlery, whom makes a "ninja sword" design blade, as well as a Korean sword model of theirs which appears to be generally lighter and less "bashable" but still capable of being used.

As for these prices, I'm not terribly sure. I'm sure someone can help with that, and if not, I could help look them up for you. I believe they're sub-200 range as well.

For this price range, you have some options that you will have to decide upon. It is a game of trade-offs, you just have to pick the trade-offs you can live with.

If there's anything I can do to help, let me know.

Shinryû.
 
alkonost1,
You can get what you want with the money you have, but it's a good idea to become an educated consumer before spending your hard-earned cash. Avoid eBay! You can get a better deal from a number of online dealers than you will find on eBay when it comes to production swords.
First, here's a link to a good basic article on the type of sword you want. Look around that site, there's lots of other good info there as well. I'm not familiar with anime, but Paul Chen makes a straight-bladed Practical Ninja for CAS/Iberia (scroll to the bottom of the page). The Ninja, however, unlike the Practical Katana, does not have a differentially hardened blade. I just got one of the new Practical Katanas with a brass habaki (read this to see why that is important, as well as learning about the main competiton to the Chen swords). You can find a PK online for less than $160. It isn't a collector's item, it isn't a masterpiece, but it's a great value for the money, and it's not a piece of **** like most of the overpriced stainless-steel, plastic-handled junk on eBay.
Hope this helps,
Berk
 
The practical Ninja looks VERY GOOD
Is it a useful katana , which can cut through things , or is it a showcase one , that can maybe cut through a piece of paper with ease?
 
I've never handled the Practical Ninja, or even read a review, so I'll have to assume it has similar edge geometry to the Practical Katana from the same maker. I have read that some people find the straight "Ninja" blades less efficient than the curved traditional katana. Also remember that swords are designed to cut soft targets (specifically flesh, cloth), not tree trunks or gun barrels. Also, the Chen blades have very hard edges which are likely to chip if used on targets like 1/4" plywood, or subjected to any twisting of the edge. With all those caveats, I think the PK cuts well.
BTW, in view of your age and location, you should be aware that any internet seller is going to require the purchaser of a sword to sign a statement like this:
"I certify that I am at least 18 years of age and that possession of the item I am ordering does not violate any of my state or local laws."
So even though it's your money, it's important to consult with a parent or other responsible adult in making your purchase. Not being condescending, just realistic. (Yeah, unscrupulous sellers on eBay will sell anything to anybody, but I've already warned you about their merchandise anyway).
Good luck and have fun
smile.gif
.


[This message has been edited by Berkley (edited 10-14-2000).]
 
Swordforum.com is a great place to learn about swords and the differences to sword-shaped objects
smile.gif

A thing you might look at are the swords from Kris Cutlery www.kriscutlery.com - butt-ugly compared to more traditional examples, but they take a beating and then some. Very good value for your money.

------------------
"Peace is not without conflict; it is the ability to cope with conflict" - Leo Giron
www.messerforum.net - the premier German language knife-related web board
 
I would recommend the same advice as Robert.Check out sub-$200.00 dollar offerings in Paul Chen (Hanwei Forge) and Kris Cutlery offerings.Stay away from the stainless steel wallhanger swords,if you want to have a realistic "real" sword that can do cutting.Best Regards,Ralph
 
the age thing is no problem , my mom is going to buy me the katana
I was the one who saved up the money so shes ok with it

i only around 200$ , is it a good decision to buy a katana , or is there better knives or swords that i could buy?
I need something sturdy , with a great look of power and sleekness
 
im sorry to all kris cutlery fans , but i dont realy like the look of the swords

and by the way , where can i purchase other japanese weapons? , such as shuriken , for a low price?
 
I know a lot of people who aren't very fond of the KC's aesthetics. Being picky is not necessarily a bad thing, I mean look at me...I represent the tiny tiny minority of extreme pickiness.

One of the main reasons I don't like the Chen line very much is the distributors they went through (CAS Iberia for example). And even though the vast majority of the advertising BS has been cleared, that had put it into a negative light for me.

Nothing personal against the product or Hanwei in general, apart from it being "not my style" just that I think they made a very profitable mistake in choosing their distributors.

I did like the look of the KC Korean sword, but I'm not such a big fan of the "overall" package...I am looking forward to their higher end stuff though...

Also I would suggest even if you buy a POS sword, take a lot of precaution in handling and using. A lot of people think that they are "good enough" that they won't hurt themselves...and some people are fortunate enough not to hurt themselves, but I know a few who have, with anything from United Cutlery "decorative pizza cutters" to antique Nihonto. They are swords, they demand and deserve a very high level of respect.

As for the practical ninja (hah...what a name!), make sure you get one with a metal habaki...one of the newer ones as the older ones had habaki made of plastic. I'm unsure of the balancing and comfort of the "ninja" model, but I would not expect too much. I would also suggest doing cleanup of the blade's finish, which I can show you how to do. As I recall, the finish is rather wobbly in the lines, but you can make up for that a bit with the cleanup...

And as for eBay, if you're not bidding on crap...usually there will be other bids. On eBay, things tend to sell for a bit more than what they're worth, including the higher end stuff. I would suggest going through a good vendor and having them hand-inspect a sword for you if you choose to get the Hanwei "practical."

The key elements are...
To get what you want
To know what you got
And to not give up if you feel disappointed.

There's a number of options out there, and they aren't the best, but regardless of price bracket, we want ya to get whatever will make you happiest.

Shinryû.

Oh and by the way, if you want to make stars or spikes for throwing, I can show you how to make your own and how to customize them for yourself. It's not real hard but it does take some patience and elbow grease generally.

But the result is worthwhile and cheaper than just buying them.

Otherwise I don't know too many places to get real nice ones apart from semi-custom.

[This message has been edited by Robert Marotz (edited 10-14-2000).]
 
SURE THATS A GREAT HELP , i wanted to buy throwing stars for 40$ for 3 stars , but if you can teach me how to make them , that would BE A GREAT HELP

I want a katana that lookes effective and IS effective so im probably going to buy the Practical Ninja for 165$
what is a good online retailer of that brand of swords?
 
SURE THATS A GREAT HELP , i wanted to buy throwing stars for 40$ for 3 stars , but if you can teach me how to make them , that would BE A GREAT HELP

I want a katana that lookes effective and IS effective so im probably going to buy the Practical Ninja for 165$
what is a good online retailer of that brand of swords?
 
Try Tuscany Trading...
http://www.tuscanytrading.com

I think they have the Practical model "ninja-style" sword there for that price range.

I'd suggest looking at the katana version too, would probably serve you better...but buy whatever you like.

As for making stars and spikes and stuff, drop me an email.

Shinryû.
 
I highly recommend our very own Louis aka- TheMartialWay
whom just happens to sell Cas Iberia's Chen swords.I bought my Shinto Katana from him and he gave me an excellent price.He checks over the sword thoroughly before shipping.He also happens to be just upstate from you in Monroe,N.Y. Shoot him an e-mail for a quote. http://ww.themartialway.com
Good luck,Ralph

[This message has been edited by TOMBSTONE (edited 10-14-2000).]

[This message has been edited by TOMBSTONE (edited 10-14-2000).]
 
One more thing,when you go to his website just click on the asian world of martial arts link.It appears that he is able to get reasonably priced shuriken.Chow,Ralph
 
Back
Top