Need help choosing from three

[JTR357]

Well I have a few bucks in my paypal acct. & I want to get a new knife.I've been looking at three in particular.I'm having a hard time choosing.Any help from you guys would be much appreciated.I really like an EDC blade to be between 3.5" & 4"(no serrations) & I really like the axis lock.I really like a knife to have some heft to it(solid).I also would like to have a knife in D2,since I don't have one.I'm looking to spend no more than $140.Here are the three I've been looking at.Thanks in advance for all your help.:thumbup:

1.Benchmade M.Williams Large Axis Folder D2 Blade Plain
Specifications:
Overall Length (inches): 8.80

Blade Length (inches): 3.90

Blade Material: D2

Blade Detail: Plain

Handle Material: G10, Black

Lock Style: Axis Lock

Carry System: Pocket Clip

Special Features: N/A

Packaging: Benchmade Blue Box

Class: Blue Class

2.SPYDERCO C63GP3 JAME KEATING CHINOOK III KNIFE
features a 3 3/4" upswept blade

CPMS30V stainless steel

notched thumb ramp

Spyderco hole for ambidextrous one hand opening

The black G10 handle

4 7/8" closed

has dual stainless steel liners

full back spacer

lockback and a lanyard hole

A side to side and end to end reversible metal pocket clip is included with this Spyderco knife

The Spyderco Chinook 3 Knife has an overall open length of 8 1/2"

3. Benchmade Knives 14200 H&K Drop Point
Blade Length: 3.40"
Blade Thickness: 0.150"
Blade Material: 154CM
Blade Hardness: 58-60HRC
Blade Style: Drop-Point
Weight: 5.60oz.
Clip: Black, Reversible, Tip-Up
Lock Mechanism: Axis
Overall Length: 8.19"
Closed Length: 4.79"
Sheath Material: Sold Separately
Class: Heckler & Koch

I'm kind of leaning toward the 1st one,because of the size,axis lock & D2.On the other hand,I really like the 4 way pocket clip option,the S30V & the solidness of the Chinook III.I've always liked the style of the H&K's,but was turned off by the under 3.5" blade.

 

[dniice87]

The chinook is a great knife...but if your leaning toward the 710 then get it you'll love it

 

[jlfletcher83]

The 710 is the superb general EDC knife of the 3. It is very easy to carry and for it's size does not take up much pocket room. I prefer the S30V of the chinook but I very much prefer the handle, blade shape and lock of the 710. D2 is always better than the 154CM of the HK IMO. Really any of these knives would be excellent choices, but for all around use the 710 is like benchmade's icon.

 

[JTR357]

The 710 is the superb general EDC knife of the 3. It is very easy to carry and for it's size does not take up much pocket room. I prefer the S30V of the chinook but I very much prefer the handle, blade shape and lock of the 710. D2 is always better than the 154CM of the HK IMO. Really any of these knives would be excellent choices, but for all around use the 710 is like benchmade's icon.

Thanks for the input.Yeah,I forgot to mention,I really like the handle on the Chinook III,but I'm a sucker for axis locks.That's what I wanted to hear about the 710(full size,but not too bulky in yer pocket):thumbup:.I'm off to work now....see ya'll in 12-13hrs

 

[JTR357]

Quick question about D2.Is it stainless?Do you have to keep it coated with oil,like 3V?

 

[Kaizen1]

My favorite design out of the 3 is the 14200. I was never able to get myself to like the 710. And I've never really liked the looks of the Chinook, but holding a Spyderco in the hand generally turns that around for me. I personally wouldn't pick based on steel, unless you're one of the rare individuals who actually notices enough of a difference where it matters in practical usage.

 

[Kaizen1]

I've owned a 710, but not for a long time. However, based on the couple of years that I've been reading reviews of the 710 and other D2 blades, I don't think it's going to be an issue unless you're in a highly humid area or if you skin animals and things like that.

 

[lotus1972]

The Chinook is a true blood fighter designed from the ground up to cut people not stuff but any of those knives are good. The H&K is uber tactical, comfy from what I hear and most likey the most sheeple friendly. D2 is awesome though.

 

[knifenerd]

Quick question about D2.Is it stainless?Do you have to keep it coated with oil,like 3V?

D2 is not technically a "stainless" steel, but is very close to it. Just reasonable care is all it needs. It has excellent overall "knife" use characteristics.

 

[JTR357]

Thanks a lot for the feedback guys.:thumbup:I'm going with the BM710 D2.It'll be a little while till my next knife,but the next one will definately be the Chinook.