Need help with recurve on Barlow

Joined
May 15, 2014
Messages
284
Long story short, I had what was once a great looking clip point GEC #15 soup bone Barlow. I took this knife and a few others to the local knife sharpening store. Big mistake. This is the before and after and I'm not sure what to do with the blade to make it look better. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated. RIP soup bone barlow.

Before Barlow

Before PM2

After
 
I saw your thread in Traditional, about these knives. I HATE to see such bad things done to them by so-called 'professional' sharpeners; it makes me cringe.

If wanting to straighten the edge on the Barlow, the only way to do it is to remove even more steel forward of the recurve, reducing the belly in a pretty big way. Considering what's already been done to it, I'd have reservations about doing that. With blades like this, I've usually just laid the blade much lower in angle and thinned the grind, which will at least make the recurved portion cut more efficiently. A longer-term approach would be to do most of your maintenance sharpening in the belly portion forward of the recurve, just a bit at a time as needed. The end result will still be a reduction in the belly's profile, but you'll at least get good use out of the blade until then.

Another thought, I'd almost consider it worthwhile to contact GEC and ask them what it'd cost to just replace the blade. Should've never had to even consider this, but if the alternative means having to cringe every time you look at the knife you once loved (the reminder would make me angry), it may be worthwhile to see if you & GEC can make it 'new' again, and put it all behind you.

(Looking again at your Traditional thread, it appears you've gotten some encouragement from GEC, in their willingness to take a look at it; I'll hope they can make it right again, for you. :thumbup: )


David
 
Last edited:
(Looking again at your Traditional thread, it appears you've gotten some encouragement from GEC, in their willingness to take a look at it; I'll hope they can make it right again, for you. :thumbup: )


David

Thanks for the support. I'm going to send the Barlow in to GEC tomorrow and Bill over there told me to mention to Christine that I spoke to him and to let her know what's going on in writing and to leave my phone number. If nothing can be done as far as replacing the blade, life goes on but it sure would be sweet if they could replace the blade. I need a beer.
 
I am unsure if they can replace the blade, but it is definitely worth it to check. I just went through the process recently of removing a slight recurve. Before you can sharpen or then the edge you need to "true it". Meaning removing the recurve and making the edge straight. Given how large the recurve I would recommend not to sharpen it out as you would have to grind a lot of steel and life away leaving you with a sliver of its former profile. The other alternative being sharpening just the upper belly portion as mentioned above is an option but only the upper portion would get sharp.
 
Back
Top