New BK2 Kydex Sheaths

daizee

Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Dec 30, 2009
Messages
11,115
Courtesy of BF's own Marion David Poff.

One in desert tan and the other in safety orange (color reproduction may be off in the pictures) with matching paracord for each. Both are Kabar knives. The orange one is to be a gift for a friend.

These are clamshell-style sheaths, using flex in the opening for retention. The flex could be adjusted by adding a bolt to the top-most holes, or moving the clip up if necessary. There are drain holes at the tips, and the rivets are very nicely done. They are pretty consistent between the two, and they both work perfectly. Mr. Poff provided the clips at my request. Also, I asked him to shorten the reach up the handle compared to his reference sheath to accommodate my inner-tube handle liner, and he absolutely nailed the size, as you can see from the picture. Retention is excellent, and there is no rattle. However draw is smoother and easier than the factory sheaths as the force is spread over a longer lever-arm than the factory design. There is a slight pop-release and then a firm glide out, compared to the factory sheath that requires a lot of force up front that releases all in a rush. You must take some care with your thumb, as the mouth can nip it if you push against it - I softened the inside corners a smidge with a knife. However since less force is required, you actually don't need to launch the knife out with your thumb as with the factory sheath.

I'm very pleased with the results and recommend Marion's work.

At the bottom are a couple pics of the Izula-II sheath at as well. Note it's made to handle either the Izula or the II, with or without handles. The lady of the house dyed her micarta handles a bit, so they're actually pretty close in color to the sheath. Also nice work.

-Daizee


IMG_20110526_141912-small.jpg


IMG_20110526_141952-small.jpg


IMG_20110526_142004-small.jpg


IMG_20110526_142110-small.jpg


IMG_20110526_142031-small.jpg


IMG_20110526_144905-small.jpg

IMG_20110526_144924-small.jpg
 
Man, those look great. I still can't decide what I like more for sheaths, kydex or leather. Have made one sheath out of each one, I think I like them both :)
 
Those do look great. I don't think I've ever had a proper kydex sheath before. Only reason I don't get one is because I think it would dull the edge on a blade.

I like those though. Looks like some really nice workmanship on those. :thumbup:
 
I've always preferred the 2 piece kydex sheaths over the one piece. Gives more tie down/mounting options. Here's the two types using a mora: (not my photo)

sheath-clipper-1and2piece.jpg


I REALLY wouldn't mind having one of these for my BK9. Again, not my photo:

sheath-2p-BK9-forest.jpg
 
Only reason I don't get one is because I think it would dull the edge on a blade.

I don't think the edge touches the kydex at all in these sheaths. injection-molded sheaths with a square face against the blade are a different story, but hand-made ones typically are folded or molded around the blade and don't have that problem, in my limited examination.
Also, I don't think that genuine kydex contains glass fibers the way fiberglass products do.

Leather ain't bad, tho. :-)

-Daizee
 
The Kydex material is not hard enough to dull a blade. Plus, good kydex sheaths are molded so the edge is "floating", the knife is held by the spine and the edge touches nothing but air :)
 
You had me hyped up for a few minutes there. Are we EVER gonna see our knives?

Was it Warrior's pic that got ya going? I hope so. It would really suck if the lost 'em.

I don't think the edge touches the kydex at all in these sheaths. injection-molded sheaths with a square face against the blade are a different story, but hand-made ones typically are folded or molded around the blade and don't have that problem, in my limited examination.
Also, I don't think that genuine kydex contains glass fibers the way fiberglass products do.

Leather ain't bad, tho. :-)

-Daizee

The Kydex material is not hard enough to dull a blade. Plus, good kydex sheaths are molded so the edge is "floating", the knife is held by the spine and the edge touches nothing but air :)



I didn't know what about Kydex sheaths. I thought the edge touched in the sheaths. And I never thought about the glass in the injection molded sheaths being an issue in the dulling of the BK11/14's. Maybe I'll have to see if I can do some trading.
 
You can actually strop your knives on the standard GFN (Glass-filled Nylon) Becker sheaths.
 
the knife is held by the spine and the edge touches nothing but air

The key is in the draw, of course - if the edge is clear when inside, but you have to drag the edge across the sheath as it comes out, then yuck. In the case of these clamshell style sheaths, the edge is sandwiched from the sides. The spine is so thick that it doesn't let the edge slide close to much, tho I suppose you could catch the handle-clamping sides on the way out. In either case, the situation seems much more favorable than my gen-1 sheath.

-Daizee
 
Courtesy of BF's own Marion David Poff.

I'm very pleased with the results and recommend Marion's work.

Thank you!


Man, those look great.

Thank you!


Those do look great. I don't think I've ever had a proper kydex sheath before. Only reason I don't get one is because I think it would dull the edge on a blade.

I like those though. Looks like some really nice workmanship on those. :thumbup:

Thank you, and as is mentioned later in the thread, a well designed sheath will not even touch the edge of the knife.


I've always preferred the 2 piece kydex sheaths over the one piece. Gives more tie down/mounting options. Here's the two types using a mora: (not my photo)

sheath-clipper-1and2piece.jpg

I too have usually preferred the 2Piece style, but a good number of people like the 1Piece (fold-over). And, I am starting to appreciate it more, I quite like that 1 Piece I built for the Clipper, so much so that I just built a 1Piece for my Mora Sloyd. Especially for smaller knives, or knives carried from the neck, the smaller the sheath, the more convenient.

sheath-1p-morasloyd.jpg




Same here, those shealths look great............all of them

Thank you.


I don't think the edge touches the kydex at all in these sheaths.

This has been my experience.


good kydex sheaths are molded so the edge is "floating", the knife is held by the spine and the edge touches nothing but air :)

Ditto.


He made me the greatest Mora 511 Bushcrafter neck sheath ever....

226842_1353874822342_1695575791_597773_2697533_n.jpg

Nice image, I am glad you are enjoying it!


The key is in the draw, of course - if the edge is clear when inside, but you have to drag the edge across the sheath as it comes out, then yuck. In the case of these clamshell style sheaths, the edge is sandwiched from the sides. The spine is so thick that it doesn't let the edge slide close to much, tho I suppose you could catch the handle-clamping sides on the way out. In either case, the situation seems much more favorable than my gen-1 sheath.

-Daizee

As to the handle-clamping portion of the sheath, usually the handle going in spreads those lips apart, which moves them clear of the edge, even if they would be in the way in their static position.


Kind Regards,
Marion
 
Back
Top