New BM Crooked River review, custom scales

Joined
Mar 24, 2016
Messages
234
Hello all! I have been wanting a Benchmade Crooked River ever since I first saw pictures of them. Specifically, I wanted the 15080-2, with the wood handle scales. Then, a buddy got a 15080-1 with the G10 scales. The second he showed it to me, I knew I had to get one. Man, it's one sexy knife.

If you're familiar with the Crooked River, skip this paragraph. If not, let me tell you about it. It's BIG, which I love, with a 4.00" blade. The blade is 0.124" thick, which combined with the length, makes it a SOLID feeling blade and knife. The stainless liners are thick, the bolsters are steel (I believe), it has an AXIS Lock, S30V steel, etc. Anyway, besides all the aforementioned awesomeness, it's a throwback to the Buck 110, but with the AXIS Lock. At 5.41oz, it's hardly light, but still lighter than a Buck 110. To me, it's a modern Buck 110 with a better lock, more blade, better steel, and a better, easier to use lock.

All that being said, before I had a chance to get one, my friend decided to offer me his in a trade. Basically, if I would buy the materials and make him a knife out of a Helle blade and some dyed maple burl, he would give me his Crooked River. Done! I ordered the materials, and he went ahead and gave me the Crooked River. I've had it for a few days now, and it's so sweet. It reminds me of a super-sized BM 940. Sure, it's twice the weight, but the slimness of the knife, the long blade, and the AXIS Lock just give it that feel.

To sum it up, I'm really impressed with this knife. It feels great in the hand. The long blade gives a lot of cutting edge in a folder. The heavy blade makes the AXIS design even sweeter than in other BM knives. The blade just drops shut like it's on ball bearings when the lock is opened. The fit and finish on this example are great.

There was just one problem: the G10 handles. I just really liked the look of the wood handles better. So, having a big block of dyed, stabilized maple sitting around waiting for the Helle blade to arrive, I decided to make some scales for it. The block was exactly twice the size of what I needed for the Helle, so I figured I could shave 1/2" off the side of it. It was not easy making scales for this thing. If you've ever taken one apart, you'll know what I mean. There are these super thin little tongues and relief cuts that have to be made in the scales to interlock with the bolster, and they are not ideal for wood. However, I made it work, and it turned out ok. I used the side of the burl, not the face, as using the face would have not left enough for the Helle knife, and that one is the priority. Therefore, the grain looks odd, but it's unique. I'll probably make another more subtle set for it in the future, but it will do for now.

Let me know what you think.

IMG_0590.jpg


IMG_0591.jpg


IMG_0592.jpg


IMG_0595.jpg


BY the way, I have HUGE hands. It's much bigger than it looks in my hand. :eek:
IMG_0596.jpg
 
I like the grey better myself. Better than the stock wood, too. It goes with the dark metal on the knife a lot better, imo.

2uqyf6o.jpg
 
I'm glad you posted that picture. I didn't take any before the swap, and didn't feel like changing them back just for a picture. I'm honestly not thrilled with the dyed maple scales. That's just what I had. Although, now I realize I have some nice ironwood and cocobolo in the shop. I will probably make some ironwood scales for it when I have time.
 
That wood looks amazing to me anyway! Great job. Did you frehanded the machining of the scales or used some kind of mill?
 
I like the way it looks! Nice job!
I have the G10 version for a couple months and love the beast!!
Joe
 
I'm glad you posted that picture. I didn't take any before the swap, and didn't feel like changing them back just for a picture. I'm honestly not thrilled with the dyed maple scales. That's just what I had. Although, now I realize I have some nice ironwood and cocobolo in the shop. I will probably make some ironwood scales for it when I have time.

I think the maple scales look great. I'd just get rid of the orange - polish the pivot and dye the backspacer black (or use standoff's). Maybe polish the bolsters too. :thumbup:
 
I think it looks great!
Nice job. :thumbup:
Looks like you're good to go....to me.
Yes, you are correct there are a few tricks to creating duplicate scales for this model.

Here's one of the 3 Ironwood burls I have done thus far .
I have changed the scales mounting positions on mine.
The two screws normally used/seen are underneath the scale.
I tapped the already present hole in the center of the liners so that I could mount the scales with one screw in the center of each scale and then utilized the lower bolster mounting screw to anchor down the top of the scales



I prefer my personal Crooked River to be bolster-less with a full length back spacer....

ec8fdbc53f469a2c888f9a98cb375406.jpg
 
That wood looks amazing to me anyway! Great job. Did you frehanded the machining of the scales or used some kind of mill?

I wish I had a mill! I did all the fine work freehand with a Dremel.

I think it looks great!
Nice job. :thumbup:
Looks like you're good to go....to me.
Yes, you are correct there are a few tricks to creating duplicate scales for this model.

Here's one of the 3 Ironwood burls I have done thus far .
I have changed the scales mounting positions on mine.
The two screws normally used/seen are underneath the scale.
I tapped the already present hole in the center of the liners so that I could mount the scales with one screw in the center of each scale and then utilized the lower bolster mounting screw to anchor down the top of the scales


I prefer my personal Crooked River to be bolster-less with a full length back spacer....

Those are awesome ideas! I might use your tricks on a future set. Do you have a picture of the other side? I'd like to see what the two visible screws down the centerline look like. Did you have to use one of the longer screws for that front scale screw? That thing is short as hell. I'm surprised it fit with the added thickness of the scale.

By the way, that ironwood burl is beautiful! I have some ironwood in the shop that I may use to make a second set. It's not that light or as pretty (no figure to it), but I think the dark brown color would look good.
 
Dude, great job! It looks a lot better than stock.

You've got some skills, man. Enjoy the knife!
 
Great review mate, thoroughly enjoyed it. I've been lusting after one since they were released.
 
I think it looks great!
Nice job. :thumbup:
Looks like you're good to go....to me.
Yes, you are correct there are a few tricks to creating duplicate scales for this model.

Here's one of the 3 Ironwood burls I have done thus far .
I have changed the scales mounting positions on mine.
The two screws normally used/seen are underneath the scale.
I tapped the already present hole in the center of the liners so that I could mount the scales with one screw in the center of each scale and then utilized the lower bolster mounting screw to anchor down the top of the scales



I prefer my personal Crooked River to be bolster-less with a full length back spacer....

ec8fdbc53f469a2c888f9a98cb375406.jpg
Love to gwt that real wood scales for benchmade crooked river love the knife but need some real wood
 
I REALLY like the scales in the OP. Those lines of yellow look like tiger stripes almost. I'm actually kinda blown away, I think its gorgeous.
 
Keyman. I tried making own scales by hand didnt work your far superior had to out old ones back on love to chat get a set from.you if you have the time. Scott
 
Back
Top