New Knife Quandry

Accelerator

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2010
Messages
1,001
I have been bitten by the new knife bug again, and after looking at quite a few knives, I'm still undecided. My current EDC (for the last 2 years) is a very well used ZT 0350. I removed the pocket clip the very first day and it rides in my right front pocket always. About 1 month ago I picked up a new ZT 0550 to mix things up, but I just haven't been able to bond with the knife. Since then, I realized that I've fallen in love with the flipper on the 0350, so I have decided to get rid of the 0550 and upgrade to the 0560, problem solved.

However, the recent purchase of the 0550 and the subsequent decision to buy the 0560 has given me new knife fever in the worst way. I've always kept a SOG Flash 1 as a small pocket knife that I could carry when going out with the wife or otherwise in a situation where I needed a smaller, more discreet knife when the situation arises. Unfortunately, I seemed to have lost/misplaced the SOG over Halloween, so now I find myself looking for a replacement. While in my "research" phase, I have come to the conclusion that I would like something more upscale than another Flash 1, something that is a borderline gentleman's knife, but still solid and with good steel. With the 0350 and the pending 0560, I feel like I have those sizes covered quite well. By the way, I own a gun shop so EDC'ing a large, scary, tactical knife is almost expected of me and 90% of the time, I'm around people that wouldn't blink twice with either of those knives. I say that because the knife that I am now looking to find does not have to be "sheeple" sensitive if you know what I mean.

I am looking for a knife smaller than the 0350, but it doesn't have to be too small, 2" - 3" is prefereable. I want some type of locking mechanism as it will get plenty of solid use when carried, but it doesn't have to be a flipper or even assisted for that matter. I've deided that it must have good steel, and scales that approach the gentleman class of knives in appearance. Basically I'm looking for solid gentleman's knife that has some tactical capability, holds a very sharp edge, and locks up tight. Last but not least, I would like to keep it under $200 if possible.

I've narrowed my search down to a few options and looking for anyone who can contribute some that I have overlooked.

Benchmade (have never owned one, and am unsure if I like the company or not but willing to give it a shot)
480 Shoki with winewood scales or CF
482 Megumi
Osborne Opportunist

Spyderco (never owned one of these either, but warming up to the company quickly)
Caly 3 Carbon Fiber
Sage Carbon Fiber
Chaparal Carbon Fiber
(I love the carbon fiber for this particular application)

Bradley Alias II

Lion Steel (don't know anything about the company)

Mcusta (don't know anything about these guys either)

To be honest, based on the above list, I'm really leaning towards the Caly 3, based on size, clean classy looks and the rave reviews everyone seems to give it. So BladeForum members, please help me out, I need solid options and the fever is eating me up!
 
It sounds like you have already made up your mind....

Do you want us to try and convince you of something different?

If so, the Lionsteel is 180 degrees around from the Caly.

Lionsteel is quality. Just search the forum, you'll see.
 
A Benchmade 707 Sequel might be worth a look...

707comp03.jpg

BM 710, BM 940, BM 707

707comp04.jpg


Good luck, OP! :)
 
It sounds like you have already made up your mind....

Do you want us to try and convince you of something different?

If so, the Lionsteel is 180 degrees around from the Caly.

Lionsteel is quality. Just search the forum, you'll see.

Yes, that is a pretty accurate statement. Everything about the Caly 3 appeals to me, I just want to be certain before I pull the trigger, there's nothing that I hate more than buyer's remorse. That being said, out of the options that I listed above, none of them have me drooling or laying awake in bed yet.
 
I can guarantee you will be happy with any of the three Spydercos you listed:
Caly 3 Carbon Fiber
Sage Carbon Fiber
Chaparal Carbon Fiber

I can't help with your decision, as all three are equally great knives. In fact, I can make your decision harder. The Caly 3.5 Carbon Fiber is almost the exact same size as the Caly 3 Carbon Fiber when folded, but has a 3.5" blade when opened. That's my personal favorite.
 
I looked at the 3.5, but that seems to be a little close to the 0350 in size, not to mention, on the rare occasion that I need to pull it out in public, I would prefer a blade length 3" or shorter.
 
if you were satisfied with a sog, you will be more than happy with either of the other two companies as they are a step above in quality these days... pick what you like man. we aren't the guy who has to carry the knife and feel crummy about our decision. maybe you will "bond" with the next one you pick... the only way to know is to buy it. we've all bought knives that looked good on paper or screen and either been amazed or dissapointed, so take the plunge.
 
Given your tendency to carry clipless I am going to go ahead and suggest you take a good hard look t the spyderco air by gayle bradley. It is the definition of a modern gentleman's folder in my mind and features better materials and fit and finish than pretty much everything in its price range.
 
Benchmade 470 Emissary. Has a 3" S30V blade and aluminum handles, and that modern gentleman look:thumbup:
 
After taking all of these suggestions into consideration, I was a bit overwhelmed, so i decided on another plan of attack. Since I was looking to replace my SOG Flash 1 for clipless pocket carry, I decided to go with the smallest of the choices/suggestions, and work my way up if I wasn't satisfied. I purchased the chaparral and on Xmas eve, it showed up. Upon unboxing, I was a little disappointed with the knife overall. Not sure why, I guess I expected the heavens to open up or something. I removed the clip, slipped it into my pocket and took the family to church for the Xmas service. While sitting there, I couldn't stop thinking about the chaparral in my pocket...I was intrigued and wasn't sure why, but I started to get excited. The next morning when the kids got up to open presents, I reached for the chap and slipped it into my pajamas pocket. In the interest of not getting anymore wordy here, the size, slicing ability and overall ergonomics blew me away! I was in love with this little knife. I have carried it nonstop since that point and couldn't be happier. It's my first Spyderco, and by God, it won't be my last. This knife turned out to be everything I expected and so much more. In fact, I believe I am going to start collecting all of the future chap releases from here on out. Actually, I am looking hard at the Caly 3 as my next purchase since it is so similar to the chap. I figure I can rotate it with my 0350 when I want a slightly longer blade for the day. I absolutely love the chaparral.

chaparral2_zps99319200.jpg
[/IMG]
 
^^ Excellent choice! The Chaparral is a wonderful knife. The fit and finish is amazing, the materials are great, it looks awesome, feels good in the hand, and disappears in the pocket. It's a great knife.

Next I would check out the Titanium Chaparral. Has titanium handles with a nice grip, same solid lock, and a better steel. It's just gorgeous as well.

Another one to check out under $200 would be the Spyderco Gayle Bradley Air(taking over as my favorite "pretty" knife). It has beautiful Silver Twill Glass Fiber scales with enough grip to get a good hold but not be too aggressive. Milled Titanium Liners to make it lighter and give it a nice and solid liner lock. Locks up rock solid and dead center. Has CPM-M4 blade steel that slices like a champ and holds an amazing edge. Easy to sharpen up as well. Doesn't come with a pocket clip and slides into the pocket with ease. You can't even tell it's there. It's an awesome knife.
 
I was looking for male gifts for a son-in-law and also picked the Chaparral. Had to return several others in the meantime that were too big, too heavy, or whatever. I think I have it right ...now.
 
I would say the chaparral is quite a gift. I cannot imagine anyone who appreciates a good knife wouldn't absolutely love this one. Even in my case, when it wasn't intially love at first sight, it only took a day before I was head over heels. Great choice.
 
Back
Top