New neck Knife

Joined
Sep 2, 2012
Messages
281
So I need a new quality neck knife and have been looking at getting an Esee. I have decided to get either the Izula or Candiru, the Izula looks more ergonomic but regardless of which I get I will get scales for it. So which between these two should I get? Any other recommendations are welcome.
 
ESEE is good stuff. The question is really a matter of size: yours, not the knife's.

I'm not a tall guy, and I would find it easier to carry the Candiru without attracting attention. Likewise, if it is going to be your EDC, you are sooner or later going to use it around someone of the non-knife persuasion. When that happens, a smaller knife will help your case that knives can do good things, too.

Trust me. My Mini-Grip got me an "Oh my God, he's got a knife!".
 
The Candiru would be more comfortable around the neck. I don't like most of TOPS knives, but they have some pretty rad little neck knives you might want to check out.
 
Since the same company makes both of them, all you are comparing is size, ergonomics/design and price. So just pick the one that works for you and run with it. Personally, I have an Izula-II. I have big hands.
 
ESEE is good stuff. The question is really a matter of size: yours, not the knife's.

I'm not a tall guy, and I would find it easier to carry the Candiru without attracting attention. Likewise, if it is going to be your EDC, you are sooner or later going to use it around someone of the non-knife persuasion. When that happens, a smaller knife will help your case that knives can do good things, too.

Trust me. My Mini-Grip got me an "Oh my God, he's got a knife!".

I got a, "that knife is huge!" when using my mini-grip. But I can assure you that sort of comment has absolutely nothing to do with what I decide to carry or use. In fact, I no longer own the mini-grip but own and carry several full-size grips.
 
Ontario DPx HEST Original? Fantastic knife I think it could function as a neck knife. Handles might need a little sanding down its a bit thick.
 
The Candiru is SMALL, but very functional. It fits my 7yr olds hand, but for me, I see it more as a small work knife.

Can't go wrong with an Izula, I have 3 and man, I love them things. Mike Perrin gave my oldest a Pink Izula for Christmas 3 yrs ago, and its still her favorite blade.

If you get one, get the Izula Kit. It comes with some neat stuff, that works real well, and makes a solid backup, bare bones system for the Izzy.

Get you one, you won't regret it.

If you are looking for a different blade shape, BKT/Kabar makes the EsKabar, a BK11 drop point blade, with an Izula handle, and starting next year, we will offer one in D2, the BK24 D'EsKabar.

I do love my Izula's.

Moose
 
I would choose the Izula based on its size, however I have found a few TOPS knives that I like too.
 
Take a quick look at the Swamp Rat Swampwarden. It's similar in size to an Izula, but sports SR101 AKA 52100. It's not an ESEE, but Swamp Rat is a grand company that'll stand behind their product with the best on them. I've got an Izula as well and it's very nice and a good representation of 1095.
 
I recently bought an Esee Izula II with the kit. Its a great little knife and very handy. I have a fairly large hand and it fits pretty well with the scales.
 
There have been a pretty good number of neck knives from makers on this forum, so there's probably something that can fit your needs. I just picked up a great knife made by jawilder (would post a pic of the exchange pic if I knew how) and it is fantastic, pretty much sealing the deal on steering away from production knives. Haven't gotten serious about a custom yet, but also something to think about...
 
I like the design of the TOPS Tibo better than that of the Izula. It doesn't have scales as an accessory, though.

... for further reading: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...a=X&ei=xoatUIP3MqqVygGBhYHABQ&ved=0CGEQrQIwCA

For even more further reading: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...ry-Neck-Pocket-EDC-Fixed-Blade-Currently-Made

I know the guy that desidnex the Tibo. He's a tool, probably better to steer clear of that one. :D

I'm kidding, its a great little knife.

But Mistwalker is still a tool.:D

Moose
 
I don´t own a Candiru - but an Izula. I like it, ok.

For a smaller neck knife - I would recommend the Böker Plus Gnome with micarta scales. Just to think about ... and my .02 Cent
 
^^^ Yeah don't discount Boker plus. Their 440C is right on the money. I'm also quite fond of the Tom Krein Pocket Bowie, for a minimalist fixed blade.
 
I tried the Camillus and Stiff Kiss a few years back, what threw me off was the weight. Hard plastic sheaths with square corners weren't any fun either. I used them with dog tag chains and they are actually too long for my torso - given that the knife handle is pushed out at the lower rib cage where my mature physique is no longer as buff as I want. I guess.

Been wearing a CRKT Folts Minimalist lately, with the tanto grind, and it's working well. I looped the chain thru an extra set of grommets to shorten it up, and it fits. No noticeable printing. Access is, of course, poor under a shirt. If your work situation is highly social or you're in the public eye, then neck knives are largely back up, not daily users. In that regard, getting one that stays hidden without peeking out or printing is the key, especially if it's an active job.

That, to me, are the first features in a neck knife - it has to be comfortable in carry, and the suspension short enough to conceal it, not create a print. After that, it needs to be secure in the sheath no matter what - which means a stiff extraction. Then the normal stuff is considered - edge thickness, blade grind, heat treat, material, grip, etc. But, if its not that much a daily user, then some compromises can be accepted. A knife for backup can be cheaper steel, as long as it's got an appropriately thin edge and grind. Since it's just riding along 99% of the time, it'll stay sharp. If it's a user, then ramp up accordingly.

That's the differentiation in the products offered - some are backup designs oriented for LEO/Mil and aren't daily users, others are. Hence, take a long look at the product and determine who it's best intended for (not necessarily who it's marketed for. ) Every feature, notch, and shape on a knife has a distinct purpose in use. Learn the language and you understand them better, and make more productive choices. The stinkers don't pile up in your sock drawer as fast.
 
The Izula and Candiru imo are very, very different neck knives (I have both). Choosing between them depends entirely on your usage pattern. The Iz punches way above it's weight class, imo. I consider it a completely capable "everything" knife, frequently rely only on it for camping and hiking and other outdoors activities, keep one in my emergency kit, and feel every human should own at least five. The Candiru is small. It's nimble, tiny, and serves as a razor sharp extension of your hand. For simple cutting chores, it's one-and-done. I love them both, they both have great sheaths, but the reality is that when I'm in the field it's the Izula that's within reach and the Candiru that's riding backup in my boot.

I've got a Becker BK11 that I'm afraid to admit has been replaced by my Izula. I did get good use out of it, admire it as a well-designed and incredibly well-made tool, and do miss the BK11 bottle opener frequently.

I've got a KA-BAR LDK that I keep as a hideout in my truck. I need to mod it because if I ever try to snatch and use it for real I just know I'm going to cut the hell out of myself. I'd never use it as a neck knife (not that it was designed as such, but I've seen it included in lists of neckers before).

I've got a Mark Wohlwend custom neck knife that I prefer over all of the above. I also have a PSK tin knife from Mark that's kinda like a Candiru that is really cool (but not as good as the Candiru for sustained use imo, which of course means it's fine as a tin knife).

Don't forget that knives are a very individual thing, and what works for me may in no way work for you. Plus your tastes may change as you experiment and learn your own use patterns and preferences better. Therefore I recommend that you be prepared for the neck knife you get to not be the last neck knife you get, but rather plan on experimenting... that's what I'm doing. KA-BAR makes a few really inexpensive ones (the BOGA, the piggyback, and the archeron) that are next on my to-try list, and I've seen a lot of mention of some of the other ones in this thread and want to check them out too.
 
Durn, I forgot the Becker BK-13 Remora. I actually use that a fair bit and bought each of my kids one as their first knife, and they used the bejingles out of them.
 
Back
Top