Nitecore EX11 or Fenix PD20 Flashlight???

[brasileiro]

Hi you all. well, im trying make EDC kit. I just have one Spyderco Bug in my keychain and one Spyderco Manix 2 or Spyderco Ambitous. Howevwer i feel that in need a flashlight and my option are a Nitecore EX11 or a Fenix PD20. Why not another model or brand. Its cause i need it with a little urgency, and its what i can get with $140 in Brazil. Also by design og both.
I need it for camping, and general use.
I would like to know about brightness, batery life and uniform light projection. Isaw some videos on youtube, but couldnt find a comparison between both.
Any suggestion help are wellcome.

Thanks.

 

[Noctis3880]

Fenix PD20:

Utilizes a Premium (R2) Cree XP-E LED with a life of 50,000 hours
Two modes of output, selecting 6 levels by turning the bezel
General Mode: 9 lumens (35 hrs) -> 48 lumens (7 hrs) -> 96 lumens (2.8 hrs) -> SOS
Turbo Mode: 190 lumens (1hrs) -> Strobe
Max beam length: 135 meters
Digitally Regulated for Constant Brightness
Uses one 3.0V CR123A battery (not included)
78.5mm (L) x 21.5 mm (D)
Made of durable aircraft grade aluminum
Durable Type III hard anodized finish
39-gram weight (excluding batteries)
Waterproof to IPX-8 Standards
Toughened ultra clear glass lens with AR coating
Push-button tail cap switch
Capable of standing up securely on a flat surface to serve as a candle
Anti-roll, anti-slip body design
Batteries not included
Includes a lanyard, two spare o-rings, body clip, and a rubber switch boot

Nitecore EX11:
Unique electronically controlled "Smart PD" switch - designed for reliability
'Infinitely Variable' digitally controlled brightness system
Intuitive and simple user interface
Strobe and SOS functionality
Military frade aluminum alloy construction for strength and durability
Compact and lightweight - suitable for EDC (every day carry)
Mil-spec type III hard-anodized
Impact resistant in accordance with US Mil-STD-810F
Waterproof to IPX-8 standard, underwater 2m
Broad voltage fully regulated circuit - compatible with numerous battery
chemistries such as Li-ion and NiMH
High intensity Cree XP-G R5 LED with 50,000 hour life and maximum output of 200 lumens
Ultra clear impact-resistant optical lens and computer designed metal reflector
Military grade 550 parachute cord tactical lanyard
Ability to tailstand for use as a candle light
Dimension: diameter 21.5mm, length 76mm
Weight: 44g
Included accessoried: Lanyard, spare waterproof O-ring

Runtime:
Maximum output 200 lumens, for about 1 hours
Minimum output 5 lumens, for about 80 hours
Strobe output of 200 lumens for about 2 hours


Judging from the Amazon reviews, the Fenix PD20 is more popular and is rated higher. However, I would recommend a look at the 4sevens Quark X AA, which is brighter than both of them and runs on 2 AA cells. Admittedly it won't run as long, but that's the price you pay for more power. Another thing is that most manufacturers will rate the power of their lights by lumens at the emitter(the light that is supposed to be emitted based on current), while 4sevens rate their lights by lumens out the front(the light that actually makes it out the glass lens). That usually means that other lights aren't as bright as they claim to be.

 

[TX180SX]

Sweet I'm actually debating between these two models. I love my 4sevens mini123 but i want a clicky, and i've narrowed it to these two. I've got a Nitecore and a Fenix in my bag but they are AA powered and i want a CR123. http://light-reviews.com/ is a decent site that's informative. It has pictures of beamshots to help compare.

My leaning so far is toward the ex11.2 just because I think it looks better. I think the beam profile and brightness will be more than enough with either, and I do camping/biking/walking/and pretty much use em all the time. construction is top notch with both companies from the examples i have.

One thing i will also point out is that I like a low "moonbeam" mode, the Fenix PD20 has a 9 lumen rating while the Nitecore EX11.2 has 5 lumens. I'm splitting hairs i know. Comes with the territory.

 

[Noctis3880]

One thing i will also point out is that I like a low "moonbeam" mode, the Fenix PD20 has a 9 lumen rating while the Nitecore EX11.2 has 5 lumens. I'm splitting hairs i know. Comes with the territory.

Moonlight mode is usually about half a lumen. And I find even low output to be adequate, as even with a 2 lumen OTF low mode, I still had to shield the beam somewhat to avoid waking other people in the house. It's usually better to have a weaker low output beam, as mine will last 23 hours on 2 AAA batteries.

 

[clich]

I have a fenix pd20 and I gotta say its the biggest little light there is. Heres an example at 30 yards. And for a light the size of my thumb it's a freaking spotlight

Before

After at 30 yards. Yeh its that bright

 

[Smiley51]

I have a fenix pd20 and I gotta say its the biggest little light there is. Heres an example at 30 yards. And for a light the size of my thumb it's a freaking spotlight

Before

After at 30 yards. Yeh its that bright

your electrical meter is next to your front door....is that code where you live???

 

[clich]

i guess so. the house as built two years ago

 

[vic2367]

Fenix PD20 , excellent little light