Northwoods Norfolk Comparison and Review

Joined
May 26, 2011
Messages
630
Just thought I would share a quick comparison/review of the two different Northwoods Norfolk models, shown in ebony below.

IMG_2200.jpeg


On the above left is the whittler model, while on the right is the original Northwoods Norfolk. Note the differences in bolsters. The whittler's are plain, while the pen configuration's are slanted, ringed, and pinched.

IMG_9601.jpeg


Here is where you need to make your decision. Main blade length. As shown above, the Norfolk Pen has a much longer main blade. The whittler's main blade has an actual cutting edge of only 1 and 3/4 inches. So, if you like to use your pocket knife on food, especially apply slicing, the pen style might be best for you. However, I do not use my pocket knife on food unless there is no other option (and so far in my life, there have always been other options) so I am just fine with the whittler.

IMG_6585.jpeg


Thickness comparison. Pen on left. Whittler on right. Hardly noticeable. The whittler is slightly thicker, but I feel it is a benefit as it makes for an improved grip.

IMG_8456.jpeg


My Norfolk family snapshot. The mammoth ivory whittler in the center has been my only EDC since I received it five weeks ago. And I don't see it changing anytime soon. As much as I like the Norfolk pen, the long slender wharncliffe felt a little too delicate to me. I worry about it snapping if I were to accidentally torque it. The smaller, stouter blade of the whittler feels more robust to me, while still being thin and a superb slicer. These knives are the sharpest I have received from the Great Eastern Cutlery factory. All have original factory edge that I have yet to sharpen.

I also like the small sheepsfoot blade on the whittler. It's a clam-shell slayer. All around excellent knives.
 
Thanks for the comparison. I have one of the original Norfolk's in Elephant Ivory and didn't realize their was such a difference in the main blade length between it and the Whittler. Great collection you have. :thumbup:
 
Nice and informative comparison. I hadn't noticed some of the differences. I definitely like more the way the whittler looks, but I don't have a use for the extra small blade, specially when it is at the cost of a shorter main blade. I guess that I'll stick with the Norfolk. Either way, they're both very nice knives and I like to carry my Norfolk often.
 
where can I buy knives like this? im based in Ireland so things get tricky!

The Northwoods Norfolk or Northwoods Norfolk Whittler are sold exclusively by KnivesShipFree. See Derek's signature (okbohn) in the post just above yours for a link to their website. Best of luck!
 
Yes - thanks for the comparison. All three are beauts!:D
I have both, and really like both, but I like the main blade in the original a bit better than the whittler. I like the look of the whittler better (love the rounded bolsters). Both are great knives and you couldn't lose with either. Derrick designs a heckuva knife.
 
I have both, and really like both, but I like the main blade in the original a bit better than the whittler. I like the look of the whittler better (love the rounded bolsters). Both are great knives and you couldn't lose with either. Derrick designs a heckuva knife.
Yeah, I have both as well and have decided that I like the long blade on the original. I like the pull on the whittler better ( original is a little soft for my liking). One thing that I have found on the whittler is that the microscopic clip point is basically useless (wish it was a coping blade). Oh well both are in the rotaion. Steven
 
Wow... Looking at the two of them in this light, I'm really amazed that they would put such a short main blade on the whittler. I understand the concern, of fitting the main blade in between the two smaller blades toward the secondary joint, but plenty of cutlers have been fitting a blade in that spot for generations. No reason to equip the whittler (especially such a high-dollar and supposedly high-quality knife) with such a stumpy little main blade. Big turn-off for me. No, thanks.

The pen configuration, on the other hand, is quite appealing. :thumbup:
 
Back
Top