Oilstone?

Joined
Nov 9, 2019
Messages
64
I have several water stones strangely though the one I almost always grab is my King 1000/6000. Just works. I don’t have a water stone less than 1k grit. I do have several cheap knockoff who knows what grit stones I use if heavy grinding is in order

However I don’t find that fun so I usually just bust out the belt sander for that.

I’m about to order my first Diamond plates. I don’t really need them it’s more of an I want them. I’m going to order an Atoma 140 then a 600 and 1200. I’m gonna get the 140 first to flatten stones. Or for some reason I come across an expensive knife that needs fixed and I don’t want to use the belt sander. Not sure if I’m going to order the 600 or 1200 first.

However I’m really tempted to just get the Atoma 140 then dive into oilstones. I’ve never really used oilstones. I’ve been using water stones for 30.

With that said where should I start with oilstones? I was tempted to buy a Norton India stone as I’ve read about the history. But I’m afraid I’ll be like this was a waste as I’m use to mid to high grade water stones.

On a side note just to do it I recently sharpened a kitchen knife on a red brick! Just to say I’ve done it. I’ll probably do it again for the heck of it. I understand “functional sharpness” as my grandfather use to call it.

So should I start with a Norton India or something of higher quality. Im a complete oilstone nube. All I know is their are “soft” and “hard” oilstones. They don’t go by grit as much.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
 
Investigate “Dan’s Whetstones”. Lots of info on the website. Absolutely the best oilstones. He basically owns the quarry rights to the best of Arkansas’ source.
 
I have many water, oil and diamond plates. The 1200 diamond plate get more use than any. Oilstones are fun, but some steels are just too hard to fool with si I just go straight to the diamond plate. Careful though. Very light pressure or you’ll cut too aggressively.
 
You might enjoy some of the BYXCO bench stones. They can be used with oil or water according to preference (though once you use oil it's basically always gonna' have oil in it unless you go to great lengths to remove it.)
 
ah you mean real oilstones?

i just use oil on all my stones no matter what: rubies, spyderco ceramics, ruixin waterstones, natural stones.

All i need is 1 drop of oil for the sharpening session, and 1 drop of oil for cleaning the stone. I wipe everything away with 1 sheet of toilet paper. And only during the cleaning my right hand fingers get minimally oily. All in all not messy at all. No sink or bowel needed. Just 1 sheet of toilet paper and a trash can. Done. Very neat, and clean procedure. Apart from being environment friendly. All metal particles and abrasives particles (if any) land in the toilet paper, with the blackened oil.

I used to do water and soapy water sharpening on those stones. Not anymore. With all my experience, i know what to appreciate and why. Also, with oil, clogging of the stone pores is much less of an issue (it's still an issue with ruixin waterstones).

hope you enjoy sharpening with oil on stones as much as i do!
 
ah you mean real oilstones?

i just use oil on all my stones no matter what: rubies, spyderco ceramics, ruixin waterstones, natural stones.

All i need is 1 drop of oil for the sharpening session, and 1 drop of oil for cleaning the stone. I wipe everything away with 1 sheet of toilet paper. And only during the cleaning my right hand fingers get minimally oily. All in all not messy at all. No sink or bowel needed. Just 1 sheet of toilet paper and a trash can. Done. Very neat, and clean procedure. Apart from being environment friendly. All metal particles and abrasives particles (if any) land in the toilet paper, with the blackened oil.

I used to do water and soapy water sharpening on those stones. Not anymore. With all my experience, i know what to appreciate and why. Also, with oil,Wha clogging of the stone pores is much less of an issue (it's still an issue with ruixin waterstones).

hope you enjoy sharpening with oil on stones as much as i do!
What kind of oil do you favor?
 
What kind of oil do you favor?
anything light which smells good haha . because i had the stuff lying around : i mixed "leather oil" (good smell, transparent yellowish color, B&E Bense&Eicke geman brand, for horse saddles) with a spray can of industrial\professional bore cooling oil (transparent rosé color, good smell). total 500ml of mixture, color transparent rosé. viscous consistency is similar to sunflower seeds oil, i.e. not as light as mineral oil. and the rosé color (and scent) helps with identification on the stone, table, toilet paper. looks gorgeous on the degussit ruby!

I'd use mineral oil but 500ml leather oil is actually more cost effective.

basically i use the cheapest oil (as long as it is harmless and doesn't stinky stink stink) similar to mineral oil.

if i ever run out of the 500ml mixture, I'd buy the B&E leather oil again from my local shop.

especially for grinding on ceramics i use oil. for deburring, i prefer to use the ceramics dry. one could imagine that the oil film layer between stone and knife apex is thicker than the micro burr size. so for micro deburring it's better to omit the oil layer imho.

anyway, i do touchups only (incl burr formation) and never need to go lower than 204M.
 
Last edited:
All i need is 1 drop of oil for the sharpening session, and 1 drop of oil for cleaning the stone. I wipe everything away with 1 sheet of toilet paper. And only during the cleaning my right hand fingers get minimally oily. All in all not messy at all. No sink or bowel needed. Just 1 sheet of toilet paper and a trash can. Done. Very neat, and clean procedure. Apart from being environment friendly. All metal particles and abrasives particles (if any) land in the toilet paper, with the blackened oil.
Sorry, but having these 2 words in one post just made me laugh.... Yes, I know you meant bowl, but this was an epic Freudian slip... :D
 
What kind of oil do you favor?
There is one oil you may want to look at, water soluble massage oil, it is cheap, no smell and cleans up really easily. And i find the right viscosity. :thumbsup:
 
Back
Top