Old Blade Etching

Joined
Jan 18, 2011
Messages
704
As I was browsing through the Old Knives thread and looking a a couple of older knives I have, I noticed that a lot of the old knives have a deep etching on the main blade. I don't know if they are all etched, the old Humason and Beckleys look like the H&B might have been stamped. What ever happened the this practice? Instead of a large, intricate and very shallow etch, how about a simple deep etch. Instead of GEC putting the large Northfield UN-X-LD trade mark etch how about a simple Northfield trade mark like the old Remington's had. I might be alone in liking this but I wish this would come back around.

Ben
 
I prefer a plain blade, but I'd certainly prefer your version over what we got now.
 
GEC used a stamped logo on a few knives:
GEC_36_12270_1_F.jpg


I'm not too hot on the idea of having the trademark stamped, as opposed to etched, into the blade, unless it's something very simple and understated like Case's timeless "XX." Unlike a shallow (and easily removed) acid etch, the stamp is there for the life of the blade, which might be a bit irksome on a user, especially if the logo style isn't to your liking.

I actually like the wispy little etches GEC uses on some of their knives; e.g., those denoting special handle materials like " Snakewood" or "Primitive Bone," or the simple ovals denoting things like factory test runs. OTOH, some of the "Northfield" logo etches are so large that they barely fit within the confines of the blade profile, and that clunky "Titioute" etch is just plain dog-ugly. How about replacing that one with a nice subtle script?


Speaking of the old Golden Age knives, as an aside, I'd love to see GEC finish their blades like the original Remington and NYKC, etc knives: all blades glazed (satin) on both sides like the current Tidioutes except for the mark side of the master, which would be high polished and (tastefully) etched. And by high-polished, I don't mean that hit-and-miss "Northfield" treatment they're currently using, which looks decent occasionally, but more often than not is full of fine scratches. I mean a real flat mirror "black polish" finish like the old crocus jobs. If they'd put all their polishing efforts into just that one surface per knife, maybe they'd get better results. IMO, if you're going to produce a premium mirror finish, either do it right or don't bother. Remington managed it beautifully in the '20s and '30s, and they were cranking out tens of thousands of knives per day.
 
The blade "etch" on my Ben Hogan isn't really an etch at all, but seems to be some kind of
modified paint. It pretty much dissolved the first time I cut a lemon and an onion to force a
patina--a little Semichrome took care of the rest of it in a few minutes. Fine with me: the
knife is a user and I don't like stamps/logos/etches anyway.
 
Carrerra,

I didn't buy a GEC for a while for the sole reason of disliking blade etches. When I found out they polished right off it was game one :)

Kevin

Its a personal thing though so its good to know either way :)
 
Back
Top