Old School Muskrat Reborn!

waynorth

Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Nov 19, 2005
Messages
32,445
Over the years I've been watching that upstart company across town from the Historic (1903) Knife Factory in Titusville, PA, and I've enjoyed seeing some evolutionary changes that are mostly for the good!
Being a collector and lover of antique pocket knives, the details that made those old knives, and continue to keep them darn near objectively beautiful have filled my brain cells with images to which I compare all others.
So it is always with hope that I view new releases from all currently operating cutleries.
The hope is that the designers and makers in said cutlery plants will understand all the details that made the antique knives so great.
Maybe it was the fact that knives were more crucial to every day life 100 and more years ago, that the knives got so much attention to detail. Or maybe it was the competition of 100 or more cutleries vying for the consumer dollar!
Either way a Golden Age of Cutlery was created back then.
Of course Wars and Depression took their toll on the industry, and it did a lot of stumbling in recent years, providing flashes of greatness, but too much mediocrity in my opinion.
So it's always gratifying to see nice examples of modern-made but old-style knives show up in the market.
This is one nice example.

OldSchoolMusk4_zps8507ca22.jpg

OldSchoolMusk3_zpsced8dc88.jpg

OldSchoolMusk2_zpsc04bb40d.jpg
OldSchoolMusk1_zps13d35ce4.jpg


The appearance is great, incorporating some of the "upscale" features old timers would have expected on a premium knife. Slanted and detailed bolsters, and a nice shield, a graceful easy to use handle pattern, and some elegance to the blade shapes as well as them being task-specific. This is after all, a knife designed to take the skins of smaller animals.
I haven't used the knife yet, and wonder if I will! I have a raft of EDCs right now, and have grown to appreciate the carbon steel that GEC uses. I am carrying my "boiled" Barlow, and a 100 plus year old Sheffield knife I suspect of having some Ashkenazi history!
I have sharpened and used both, and find them remarkably similar in performance!

One stand out feature for me, is the Bone handle details, both jigging and dying.
When you look at old Remington, New York Knife, Schrade Cut Co, Empire and other, knives, it is amazing what you eventually notice. The jigging is often very distinctive, and often very beautiful. Sometimes wear only serves to enhance the jigging and bring it to life. Many examples from more recent years have proven to be poor sketches of what the "good old stuff" looked like and continues to look like!!
GEC's jigging is evolving. The "jigs" or cuts have changed shape over the last few years, and this has improved the overall appearance.
Recently, I've been told the colors of old handles are difficult to duplicate because the chemicals that produced those colors are very toxic (that is they were toxic while wet/active) - solvents that went straight to the brain and liver if contacted or breathed - sheesh! But nonetheless, this budding cutlery has contrived to safely make very pleasing bone colors that harken back to the "Golden Days"!
Needless to say, I really like this knife! I like its single backspring, which keeps it light and slim. I like how its serpentine shape makes it easy to grip securely.
Heck it makes me want to go out and catch a Muskrat!
Maybe that pesky city 'Coon that keeps trying to get into my roof will do!!
I'm ready for him!!
 
Last edited:
Before I started reading I took a gander at your pics. The thing that caught my eye was the bone covers. Both the jigging and the color are outstanding.

I share your affection for the upstarts. Their patterns don't always appeal to me, nor do they always turn out a flawless product. What gets my attention is that when I hold my #73 or my Charlow I can tell that they were made by skilled craftsmen who take pride in the work they do.

- Christian
 
Looks great! Slanted bolsters and the nail nicks look great. The jigging and dyeing looks
better and better on all of GEC knives. I like this one a lot. Thanks for sharing Charlie..

Jason
 
Last week I personally emailed GEC asking them to replicate this color and jigging on other patterns. This is exactly what I look for when browsing for older knives. Nice one!
 
That's a beautiful knife Charlie, right up there with your Barlow and the 85. I think you're rubbing off on GEC :D

Very best regards

Robin
 
Just a great pattern, I used to carry a Muskrat 20 plus years ago---don't know the exact reason why I strayed.

As others have said, great color, jigging and layout---I want one.

Paul
 
i dont think making those blades any more perfect could be possible..absolutely spot on and nice jigging too
 
There is much to the dyeing and jigging I have to learn, but this doesn't mean that I do not for one second appreciate a good looking knife, and as Christian said, immediately, my eyes were to focus in on the work on the Bone. Muskrats aren't really for me, in saying this I love the look of that knife, Muskrat for me? - there was one that you showed some time ago that I would climb mountains for -but that's another brand and another story.
From my very limited experience, I see that GEC are paving the way, Especially for the American market who had these stunning cutler firms that are no longer, as much as I love some of my earlier Case knives, IMO GEC are at the top at this moment for quality, and value for the dollar, I hope they continue down this road.
 
That is GREAT!! I carried an Old Timer 77OT Improved Muskrat for 25+ yrs and have a SOFT spot for thr "RATZ" :D , I will need one of these also!! :p
Thanks Charlie for the introspective and Pics!!
 
Must resist...too many knives on the "want" list and too little cash in the bank...!

Somehow I have a feeling it will be futile though, as I discovered I really like the Muskrat after finding a GEC#66 in stag. That led to a Schatt "improved" with wharncliffe, which led to an AG Russell (in my pocket today) and now I'm back to GEC again.
 
Heck it makes me want to go out and catch a Muskrat!
Maybe that pesky city 'Coon that keeps trying to get into my roof will do!!
I'm ready for him!!

:D

waynorth said:


Beautiful bone, Charlie. Thanks for highlighting it. I also didn't realize the blades had matchstrike pulls until seeing these scans.

:thumbup:

~ P.
 
Single or double spring on these?

Looks great, but I want a Hawbaker version.
 
I remember a comment you made when Great Eastern was making the 2011 forum knife Charlie. " Bill gets it, he is one of us, a knife nut!" We are very fortunate to actually have a "nut" in charge of a knife manufacturer! So many other companies are run by just business men. They are good at making their shareholders profits but they don't have a clue about making a traditional knife.
This rat is a perfect example! Color, jigging, blade shape, frame shape, bolsters, shield, all of it just works and you don't learn that s#@* overnight! :cool:

Dave
 
Many knife companies are run by knife knuts.
Sal was a knife knut out buying Buck 110's before he started Spyderco.
And speaking of Buck...
The Benchmade folks are knife folks, too.
So are the Daniels family, who now own Queen.

Thing in common: small companies.
Small knife companies tend to be owned by knife knuts.
Corporately owned knife companies, are not always so fortunate, though I would list the Kai owned Kershaw as one in which the knife knuts run the company.
 
Just a lovely old...I mean....new knife, Charlie.

I get that feeling of complexity, of mystery, the fascination of the old world, that we so desire. The older I grow, the more wistfully aware i become of the goal of completeness. A well made knife is a little, pocket-able reminder of the tranquility born only of the satisfaction of fullness and completion.

Homage to Bromfield
 
When GEC first came on the scene, I wasn't really a fan. Nice knives, but it seemed like they were kinda big and clunky. It's great to see how they have evolved. They are making smaller patterns, and trying new and different things with jigging and scale materials. I love the look of that muskrat. They have certainly changed my opinion.

Fantastic looking knife!
 
Great Eastern has moved away from the "patterns on steroids" look, and eased up a bit on their stiff springs. The charlows are some of the nicest production knives I've ever seen. If you took the Case Bose annuals out of the equation, Great Eastern has consistently been putting out the best top quality knives lately. I've been eyeing up the Eureka jacks, these new muskrats etc. Everytime I get a little knife money together, they make another pattern I just have to have.
 
Back
Top