"Olde Fart" Buck Knife Consumer Test Report

Joined
Apr 19, 2005
Messages
5,533
Well,

When the Dymondwood 300 series knives were introduced being "Ye Olde Fart" I was cold to the dark wood and the 'NEW' escutcheon plate. Heck, I had just learned to spell escutcheon plate so I didn't want any changes.

I thought, "This new shield is gonna look lousy after a couple of years in the pocket, not like the old design which 'ages with class'. So I set out to run my own consumer test.

The idea here was to simulate pocket wear but at a quick pace. I took a hobby rock polisher poured in a little southern eating grits, two pennies, a dime, a big paper clip and a scrap of denim. I tumbled this along with a new Dymondwood 305 and then again a 80's era old style 305. I tumbled both for 120 hours.
Which being a little bored with the project after 10 days, I determined was equal to a pretty long time of normal pocket wear and tear. I took photos every 24 hours but in the interest of interest I only show start and finish.

Hear are the photos.

The setup for testing.


Photos of both knives for the record. Zero hours.




Photos of both knives after 120 hours.




Extreme close-ups of escutcheons after 120 hours


Well what do you think? Dang'd if the new shield didn't take the punishment with flying colors. And after looking at this early 80's old shield in closeup it isn't very pretty up real close. Better at a little distance.

Granted I could have thrown in half a dozen quarters and a couple of stainless steel screws and some blue paint may have come off. But, I bet my OFCT equals at least a year of a normal persons pocket carry. The bolster ends are finely but almost completely marked.

Now for the OF grousing, I still don't like dark dymondwood (grey is good) and I don't like the buffer marks on my polished rivets.

But, then again blue is my color........

300Bucks
 
Last edited:
300, You come up with the darnest things.But good test and good pictures.I eat my grits.DM
 
I'm trying hard to figure out how to respond with something meaningful to such a "great test"! Be patient - I'm thinking!!! Like David, I like my grits, especially at the Menger Hotel in San Antonio. I didn't buy one of the newer 300's with the new shield (I can't spell that other word). I don't mind change and would have probably considered buying one had a larger change also taken place with the shield and an upgraded steel in the series would have been offered as a choice. Great creative work 300, but let David and I know before the fact when you do another test so we can "cheer you on."!!!
 
An old friend of mine from Horse Cave, KY gave his son some sage advice when the boy turned 18. "Son, never trust a f...!" Do you charge dues to belong to your Club? Are there knives involved for members? Do members have to spell "escu... correctly? Are you the President? The Big F...?
 
Guys I'm going to eat biscuits and grits and go hang a gate or something because that hurricane is coming our way.Nice innovative work.You've tapped into your creative powers.DM
 
cool test...
ugh.. old fart or old men or other names dont apply to buck collectors!
we are simply friends that feel to young to act our age..
 
Cool test Craig .That Blue hung in there real good.
Thanks for shairing with us .:thumbup:
 
I still cant decide if I like the gray laminate. I know its pretty popular right now. I've been seeing it on alot of rifles. But I just not sure if I like it.
 
I still cant decide if I like the gray laminate. I know its pretty popular right now. I've been seeing it on alot of rifles. But I just not sure if I like it.

I didn't like mine at first, but it grows on you.:thumbup:
 
Good test there 300,
Makes me feel good about keeping my Vantage Pro in my change pocket.

I like the dark dymondwood-guess I'm too young to join the union:p
 
I was curious about all that myself. Not curious enough to go to the trouble of testing, but curious, none the less. I'm not big on the Diamondwood, either, but I did break down and buy a 346 Vantage Avid off that TV show that sells knives the other night. I'll have to admit the Diamondwood does kinda grow on you. I haven't carried a tactical since I retired, but this new one fits the pliars pocket on my Car-Hart shorts. I love it when I have a knife in every pocket, and they fit. The pockets I mean, not the shorts.

Jack
Rocky Mountain Chapter of the Old F*rt's Knife Club
 
Don't be messing with no grits at the Menger. Don't you know those ghosts there don't take kindly to people messin with their grits. :cool: After all they have to feed the ghosts from the Alamo there next door. :D


Cool test!!!!
 
You're absolutely right about the Alamo Folks. I just look at them as heros from the past and not ghosts. However, to help with any ghastly thoughts that might surface, I just think of Teddy Roosevelt recruiting Rough Riders in the bar while maybe eating grits - and I'm happy again. Just kidding. What kind of knife was Teddy carrying in those days?
 
An interesting test. Thanks for posting the results.
 
Back
Top