Out of all the "AA" LED flashlights, what one has the best...

Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Messages
456
Which one gives you the best battery life/brightness? I already have a Nite-Ize conversion for my Mini Mag, but I would figure there is something brighter with the same insane battery life that my Nite-Ize conversion does. I would probably prefere a piercing beem as opposed to a floodlight.

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated...

Thanks,
Cleary
 
I'm not really into lights, but there's a lot of buzz around the Fenix line. I'm getting the L1P myself. :cool:

I think it had 3 (?) hours of good light with the AA lithiums, then it kind of just fades. I can't compare brightness, I don't do lux :D .
 
Both the T2 and XO run 2x123a's so the L1P runs at 1/4 the power at 9/10 the output, but then the L1P's run time is quite a bit shorter.

You did say you wanted a AA light anyway right? or is 123a's an option now?
 
The Inovas are fine lights, but keep in mind that they use CR123A cells, and not AAs. The batteries are more expensive, and the lights are larger/heavier.

The Fenix line is definitely worth looking at. With an alkaline battery, the L1P has a typical discharge curve; bright at first, then dimming. It's "semi-regulated" with a DC-DC circuit, so the curve is better than basic direct-driven lights. With a lithium batter, you get a much flatter discharge curve, and one that lasts considerably longer. With a NiHM rechargable (check the FR link), the curve is also flatter with longer peak brightness, although shorter overall (but that's the point of having a rechargable, isn't it?...just charge it back up).

Check here for a couple runtime graphs (lighthound is also a fantastic dealer).

If you don't mind a longer light with 2 batteries, you can use a L2P, which has a true regulation with a perfectly flat discharge until the batteries can't support it anymore. The L2P makes a Minimag look like a worthless hunkajunk.

Either Fenix will give you a tight, bright spot, with a wide, but fairly dim spill. The Inova T2 will have a larger spot, but still tight with little spill, and will likely outshine the Fenix. However, there's the batteries, and I always lean towards lights that can use rechargables for months of free lumens.

Another option would be to find a Target that carries the Inova Radiant series. These are less-expensive plastic versions, and there's a slightly-larger-than Minimag 2AA version. Long battery life, still pretty bright, and inexpensive.
 
i dont think ya can beat the fenix as long as AA batts are required, they are pretty darned good lites imho.

the inova T1 and T2 are both good lites, priced ok too, but they are a bit larger than a SF E2L and not quite as bright although the SF is almost 2X as high. i have a T1 and a T3 and carry them some but my E2e w/a KL1 head goes everywhere with me.
 
I EDC the L1P, a fine light. I don't know of a better single AA light. Sure the inovas are better, but they're not AA, as has been mentioned. The new AAA L0P would be an even easier EDC with slight sacrifices in battery life and output. For more output and much longer battery life, the L2P is more than a match for the Inova T2, IMO. Slightly shorter, cheaper batteries, long enough battery life, there's nothing to lose unless you really anticipate needing the light for more than 2-3 hours at a stretch.
 
Modded MagLight for all out raw brightness (look up waynes sandwich shoppe) Or if you run a 4AA set up, the Streamlight ProPolymer Lux
 
FYI - there are two types of AA size lithium batteries , one is 1.5v the other is 3.6V.I have an LED with 3.6 lithium AA. In any case make sure you have the right batteries and don't make sustitutions unless the light manufacturer says it's OK.
 
Element from Sam's Club is AAA, very good IMO, especially at $13 each

Streamlight Jr. Luxeon2 AA, nice and bright. http://www.flashlightreviews.com/reviews/streamlight_jr_luxeon.htm

Streamlight Propolymer Luxeon 4AA. I don't yet have this one but it is probably just what you are looking for. It does not have very long runtimes but from what I've read has far-reaching effective throw. Looks like runtime with NiMH rechargeables is VERY good.
http://www.flashlightreviews.com/reviews/streamlight_propolyluxeon.htm
 
I don’t own a Fenix flashlight yet, but I’ll probably have to get one eventually. They look very cool and the ability to stand it on its switch end would come in handy. It also sounds like they’re really bright and have a good beam shape.

I’m still a fan of the Streamlight Jr. Luxeon though. The throw number given for it at flashlightreviews.com is kind of misleading because the light has such a large hotspot. The overall brightness isn’t bad and notice the runtime: just over three hours to 50% (on regular alkalines). I also have to admit that I’ve been extremely abusive to my poor Streamlight Jr. Luxeon and it’s held up very well.
 
I got the nite ize and it's not really what I expected. A regular bulb, though less efficient, is considerably brighter. The only thing is the night ize dont have the ditracting rings of darkness in the projected beam that the regular bulbs do. Is there anything else I can do to make it brighter? maybe a better reflector...
 
Sounds weird I know, but check out the Snap On tools website.
I got a great little led from them a couple of years ago that runs on one AA.(Approx $35)
The lens is a magnifier, so the beam gets larger the further away you get from an object, but it keeps the light tight and piercing. Has had really good battery life, but unfortunately I have no specs to share.
I believe they were based off of one of the Inova patents but not quite sure.

Anyway, it is water proof, and with a good metal casing, and is very compact, very easy to carry in your pocket.

Another that is absolutely Killer is the Coast LED Senser V. (approx.$40). It runs on 3 AAA. though. I grabbed one at Home Depot.
I am not kidding that the light burns with such intensity that you can actually feel the heat off of it. It has an aluminum frame, and comes with a nice belt sheath - it is water resistent, but not water proof. Slightly larger than the one from Snap on, so not really something for your pocket.

It replaced the snap on light as part of my edc. The only other light that I have seen that small with such intensity is a Surefire but I didn't want to spring the $$ or have to deal with grabbing Lithium batteries.
VERY Pleased with the coast, Very pleased.:)
 
Alright, first off, thanks to everyone for replying. All were great and helpful posts.

Secondly... BalefireX's link about the Mini-Mag upgrade ASTOUNDED ME. BalefireX, do you personally have on of these mods, and if you do, do you have the upgraded reflector as well? Looking at their lights, it still seems as if you have to mod your light to fit the upgraded reflector and bulb setup in there. Is that true, or am I just blind?
Here is the mod link for what I'm talking about...
http://home.mchsi.com/~lambda_lights/smjled.htm

Third, for those of you with the Fenix L2P and the Inova T2... if batteries didn't matter which one is still brighter with better battery life? And secondly, for the same people, if you were using the Energizer 2500Mah rechargeables (I have a ton of them, big discount from Best Buy for batteries... both 123s and the AAs), how would they perform in the Fenix?

After the whole thing, I'm REALLY REALLY interested in that MOD for the Mini-Mag... are there any better mods for the AA and AAA Mini-Mag's... also what about the Solitare, I looked at something over at Flashlightreviews, and it had a whole page of people doing it themselves. Would an upgraded Solitare, or the cahin light of that same link I gave be better (looking for the brightest, constant-on keychain light).

Thanks to all, and sorry about all the questions... I appreciate your answers... ... ...
Cleary
 
I upgraded four of my 2AA Mini Maglites with the $5 Nite Ize LED modules and one with this $24 TerraLux TLE-5 module:

http://www.led-replacement.com/tle-5.html

My primary use for the Nite Ize upgraded lights is indoors. The TerraLux TLE-5 employs a single Luxeon LED and is much, much brighter than the Nite Ize LEDs. It is better suited for outdoors use than it is for close-up, indoor use.

I'm well pleased with both modules, especially the TLE-5, because I get a lot more use from the upgraded Mini Maglites now and don't worry about running the batteries down quickly or breaking a bulb.

It was worth upgrading the Mini Maglites instead of replacing them completely, because I like their rugged construction and I already had an assortment of Mini Maglite accessories, e.g., holsters, pocket clip, etc.
 
I'm also confused on that site's other MODs for the Mini-Mag. Can anyone clear this up???

Can anyone explain the SMJLED, the Minipro Light Engine, and the Minipro Converter?

What is the simplest mod (like no circuitry and welding), but just cutting, fitting, and maybe boring, but that would have to be explained. I'm most interested in the SMJLED, but, I'm still confused...

Thanks,
Cleary
 
I would definitely go with the Fenix L1P. I dont own one personally but from all the hype I have been hearing I dont think you could go wrong. It runs on AA batteries and not the expensive 123A batteries and has a very good output along with a decent runtime.
 
Back
Top