Perfect size, perfect trio

silenthunterstudios

Slipjoint Addict
Joined
Feb 2, 2005
Messages
20,039
I've been trying to find the perfect size traditional knife for years. At first, I was torn between modern folders with 3" blades, 3.5" blades or 4" blades. For awhile, I carried one with an almost 4.5" blade! I was wondering why I leaned to one side! I also carried the smaller version of this design too. Over the years, I came to appreciate a fixed blade more than a modern folder, and the slicing capabilities of a slipjoint. Now, I carry a couple slipjoints on me, in varying sizes. My Damascus peanut from Carl, an ebony Tribal Spear and my Victorinox classic alox on my key ring. Other than that, I will usually have my black alox pioneer nearby for dirty jobs. I will sometimes substitute my Larock dogleg jack or Lanny's Clip and leave the Tribal Spear at home. Most of the time, it's the Pioneer, peanut and classic that get most of the grunt work. I guess the others are just there to look pretty. Like I said above, in lieu of that modern folder, of which I'm down to three and soon two and only those for aesthetic reasons, I have a smaller fixed blade. That fixed blade that I bring along, but rarely have on my belt outside of home, is my Scott Gossman Kephart. 3.5" CPM154 blade with micarta scales, it is a great knife. I get more use out of it than my Tribal or other similar sized knives.

My collection is pretty much around the same size as the Tribal, I have a few larger and a few smaller knives. Fixed blades, everything from huge choppers to small neck knives. But for knives that actually get used, I've found you can't beat a fixed blade, peanut, SAK combo. I work in an office that frowns on knives, even though we have a rule of 2.5" blade or less. When I get home, I use my knives for odd jobs. Last night my peanut did duty cutting electrical tape to fix my heater motor in my truck (need to get rid of these knives and buy a new truck). I really enjoy looking at slipjoints with a blade of around 3", like the Zulu/tribal, LC etc. I just can't fault what works for me.

These darn transplanted Texans have a big influence on people.

All that said, I have a custom shadow Zulu on order, a custom gunstock jack on order, a custom peanut on order and a few others down the road. Scouring the interwebz for a stag Tribal Spear, and have a buddy who wants to sell me his Gossman fixed blade trapper Bobby Plude design. I haven't found that enlightenment phase our pal Carl has ;)...
 
I don't know why you bother Dan. Even if you did somehow find the perfect knife, you're probably more likely to trade it away than you are to keep it...lol.
 
My "perfect" trio is a Buck 110 on my belt, and a 301 or 379 stockman paired with a 389 in my pocket.
 
My trifecta is
3 5/8" closed with 440C or similar blade steel.
pen blade
Sheepsfoot blade
Zulu or clip blade.

The closest I have come is my Queen Railsplitter. The D2 is good. It's really close except for the rough machining job they did on the cam surfaces of the blades. I've been working at the clip and sheepsfoot blade cams using a Sharpmaker stick. I'm making progress and the action is slowly beginning to smooth out. Aside from the action, it's pretty close to my perfect trio.
 
Dan, enjoyed reading through your musings. I could put together two or three "Knife Trio's" to suit my needs for EDC and Hunting/Outdoors use - my first shot at it includes my nostalgic favorites, all 1970's knives (the 301 Stockman and the 105 Pathfinder I bought new, back when...) I'll have to make myself a few more groups. This is also a public thank you to Wolfe for sending me the terrific Buck patch. Wolfe had seen one of my previous Buck group shots and decided to gift me with his Buck Patch - thank you Wolfe - it looks right at home with these Buck products! OH

Buck_Trio_-_1970_s_2_.JPG
 
I've been trying to find the perfect size traditional knife for years.

In your quest for "perfection," I wonder how many times you re-purchased a pattern or specific model you had previously, and then sold/gave away.

Overall, I prefer relatively smaller knives. The trio I keep coming back to is similar to yours: a folder, a fixed blade, and a bladed multitool. Currently, the slots are held by a GEC 15 spear+pen, a Mora 510, and a Victorinox Manager. Except for cutting up food on the go for myself or my family, I could honestly get by with just the Manager. The fixed sees the least use with my current lifestyle (it's more of a "just in case" type thing), so I can't really justify anything "nicer" at the moment. I would love to handle a Gossman, though, being a fellow Marylander as the man himself.
 
Where are you in MD? Scott has a Gosstoberfest every October, usually Columbus Day weekend. Also, you'd need to check with him, some people come far and wide to visit his shop.

As far as repurchasing patterns and specific models, I tend to do that way too much...
 
Mine is currently a Mora Clipper, a Case Medium Stockman in CV, and a Leatherman, either a Wave or a Juice S2.
 
Back
Top