Perrin as a Camp knife?

Joined
Jul 11, 2001
Messages
1,137
Ok I've been a big fan of the Fred Perrin Street Bowie for a while now and Have spent plenty of time playing with mine, using it for little things around the kitchen, SD Training and the like. The more I look at this thing the more I think it'd make a perfect camp blade. I'd assume the steel is good stuff so what I'm wondering is how much would you guys be willing to bet on this knife? Anyone willing to compare it to the trustworthyness of a Kabar say? Anyone beat the hell out of one yet? Any fun evaluation links you want to send me? I think mostly I'm just waiting for someone to come along and tell me I'm not gonna accidentally hurt my knife if I beat it up a little. Thanks
 
The Perrin kicks a$$ as a camp knife. The only way to possibly beat a Perrin as a camp knife would be perhaps a Moran! The flat ground blade cuts extremely well, the knife is light, and with that deep choil you'll decrease your chances of practicing wilderness first aid just a little bit more.

I beat the hell outta mine with no ill consequences- up to a point. I've pried like hell with the tip and it held up with no problem. Cut a couple of stories of old dirty, stinkin' a$$ sand filled carpet from our house when we bought it, and it held an edge for a VERY long time. Matter of fact, it was still in one piece and going strong when one of the "worlds toughest knives" had a broken tip and was duller than a butterknife. (not to name names or anything)

the undoing of my own Perrin was being piss stupid an' cocky enough to use a rock to beat it through a thick piece of firewood when I couldn't find a baton of any sort. I evidently managed to crack the spine of the blade when doin' that, cuz a couple of weeks later I was up on a ladder using it an' accidentally dropped it on the ground. the blade broke off just about two inches above where I'd struck it with a rock. I cried like a baby, but I guess I learned a valuable lesson- don't beat on yer Perrin with a rock....(gee, come to think of it, that sounds like common sense)

Somehow I doubt that woulda happened with the Kabar, but I still wouldn't hold it against the knife. the Perrin is PLENTY rugged for any sane grown up kinda uses you could come up with. whether or not the knife can take a psychotic beating and remain in one piece is almost one of those "big thick prybar Vs. small thin scalpel" debates anyways.

My Perrin was without a doubt the most versatile fixed blade I'd ever owned. Usually I think "versatile" is an ugly word, but in the case of the Perrin, that knife doesn't only achieve most tasks, but excels at them. It was an awesome EDC, Camp/canoe/trail/utility/knock around the yard knife. The more you carry it, the more it'll endear itself to ya'.
 
I'm in agreement with everything my esteemed colleague RWS has stated. I haven't beat up my Perrin too badly, but it has few rivals in my collection as a daily carry/use fixed blade.

Shhhhhh..., secretly I have wanted to avoid breaking it because of the promise Fred Perrin made that he would magically appear and french kiss anyone who managed to break one. So, did you enjoy the kiss RWS? :eek:
 
Perrin is a great knife! :)

It is my only fixed-blade Spyderco, so I can't really speak for Moran, but I am really impressed with the Perrin. Flat ground blade is a great slicer and the deep finger choil gives the degree of control none of my other fixed blades allow. Not even close...

I did some prying, but when that normally quiet voice in my head found a megaphone and started yelling "STOP!" I ceased to lean on the poor knife. It held up well. No breaking, no bending, no cracking. :)

Certainly it is not a "sophisticated sharpened pry bar." I think of it more like an all-around multi-purpose scary-sharp scalpel.

But if you really want a blade for camping you can wedge in some tree trunk and jump on it to pry it loose, consider getting a kukri... ;) great fun, and zero risk of breakage. For anything else, Perrin will work a-OK! :)
 
I love my Perrin. As I recall, Monsieur Perrin's promise was in response to a question about the strength of the thin tang - he stated (through Nemo) that if anyone snapped the tang while using the knife he would magically appear and french-kiss them for 2 minutes. I'm not sure whether it's the strength of the tang or the threat of his visit, but I've heard nary a report of anyone breaking the tang of this knife!
 
Originally posted by Nobody


Shhhhhh..., secretly I have wanted to avoid breaking it because of the promise Fred Perrin made that he would magically appear and french kiss anyone who managed to break one. So, did you enjoy the kiss RWS? :eek: [/B]

Alas, I awaited many a moonlit night in anticipation, but Fred Perrin never appeared.

Well....I thought I heard something one night, but between the wife and the pitbull I suppose he might have been scared off...
 
Back
Top