personal "Test Knife"

Joined
Feb 22, 2005
Messages
1,004
I have been a member of the ABS for two years and was hoping to test next year for JS. Lately I have been having some trouble with my wrist and have decided to quit forging for a while, maybe permanently. Being kind of mad and having just finished up a knife, late in the day and raining I saw the last blade I forged setting on my bench and decided to give it the ABS test. As close as I could anyway.

I realized that it wasn't really typical of a test knife, but it is likely the only one I'll have for a good while and I wanted to know if it would pass. There are a lot of comments about the ABS test and the knives being tested being made especially for the test. This one was not. It was made for hunting and I figured it might have problems with the bending part of the test. I didn't follow the ABS routine exactly, but it was close. First I put the fine handle you see on it because it fit so well in the pipe I was going to bend the knife with. Here is where I deviated. This blade is a 1084 drop point hunter 5.5 inches long and it's 1/4 in thick. I knew it was going to be rough going on the 2X4 so I decided to bend it first. That way if it failed I would not have beat myself up cutting the board for nothing. I clamped the blade in my vise, stuck a pipe on it and gave it a bend past 90 degrees. No problem. I bent it back straight and then, in honor of EF, bent it past 90 degrees in the other direction and then back to straight. No problem. I hung up a piece of 1 inch rope and Charlie gave it a chop. No problem cutting the rope. I then went to work on the 2X4. Cut it in two twice and the knife will still shave hair. I then stuck it back in the vise and gave it one more 90 degree bend just so it would be bent when I took the pictures. The knife came through with out cracking or chipping and is still hair shaving sharp. I know that prior to testing for real many more knives will have to be made and I hope to be able to do it one day, but for now, I feel better knowing that the ability is there even if I might have run out of time.

343252308.jpg
 
Very cool Harry! :thumbup: :cool:

Sorry to hear of the trouble with your wrists. :(

I have about two dozen extra file handles in the tool box, I had never thought of using them as a test handle... what a great idea!

I hope you can get the issues with your wrists figured out... you would be a fine addition to the ABS list of rated smiths!!! :)

(just FYI, most Ms have you dull the edge prior to bending, JUST IN CASE the blade breaks, so you don't have razor sharp shrapnel flying around)
 
ditto the above remarks. and its a shame that thats your last blade and its been compromised in ABS fashion.:(
 
Harry, I'm sorry to hear about your wrist troubles. Hopefully, with time and TLC, it will improve to the point that you can return to forging. If nothing else, you should at least make yourself one last hand forged knife as a user/memento.

I have a knife that Charlie made. Will he continue to hand forge, or are you guys going to move to more modern means???
 
Harry,

It looks like the knife surpassed the ABS standard the way you bent it so much. I believe that most ABS test knives are longer than a 5 1/2" blade.
I hope that you wrist heals up.

Jim Treacy
 
(just FYI, most Ms have you dull the edge prior to bending, JUST IN CASE the blade breaks, so you don't have razor sharp shrapnel flying around)

I don't have a handy MS anywhere around so I just stood behing Charlie. I bent it first knowing what could happen and pointed it in a safe direction. The last time I bent it I was pretty sure it was going to bend ok but stood behind Charlie again anyway.

I'm not giving up yet on the forging I just need to quit for a while and see how things work out. I really like forging and hope to be able to pick it back up one day. I never have wanted a power hammer before, but that might help some with the rough forging and let me finish up with a hammer. I'll just have to see.

Edgy we have always made most of our knives using the stock removal method. Charlie will forge one every now and then but I was the one that did most of the forged knives we made.
 
Harry I would start looking a 25 or 50 little hammer or a small press like you said you could finish them up by hand and keep on making knives. good luck
 
Harry,
I enjoyed reading about your test knife. You make a fine knife!
Good luck on your wrists. I hope you heal up w/ some rest.
David
 
Back
Top