Phil Wilson Bow River in K294 Full Review and test

Ankerson

Knife and Computer Geek
Joined
Nov 2, 2002
Messages
21,094
I ran my full standard battery of testing on this knife, rope cutting, cardboard and wood so this will be a full review of my test results and findings.

The knife is a Phil Wilson Custom Bow River in Bohler K294 Microclean, K294 is Bohlers 3rd Generation vers of A11.

K294 Specs:

Carbon - 2.45%
Chromium - 5.20%
Manganese - .50%
Molybdenum - 1.3%
Silicon - .90%
Vanadium - 9.70%


Bow River Specs:

K294 @ 64 HRC
Blade length - 4 3/4"
OAL - 9 1/8"
Blade Type - FFG Trailing Point with Distal Taper
Handle Material - Black Micarta with Red Spacer
Edge Angle - 24 degrees inclusive
Edge Finish - Semi polished sharpened on Sil Carbide and stropped with a Sil Carbide loaded strop.
Thickness behind the edge - .010"


The Bow River is a Highly optimised Design that has been proven in the field over years of real world use by hunters and guides, It's a very clean design.

DSC_3344.JPG


DSC_3346.JPG



Now on with the testing.



1st off was the rope cutting, I cut 5/8" Manila rope making 1800 slicing cuts checking for downforce every 20 cuts until 20 LBS of downforce was reached, it would still slice printer paper after the rope.


DSC_3356.JPG


DSC_3359.JPG


DSC_3361.JPG



Cardboard Cutting, The knife was sharpened using the EP and 400 grit Congress Sil Carbide stone then the bur was removed and stropped on a Sil Carbide loaded strop. The knife was still sharp enough to slice newpaper after cutting the cardboard.

DSC_3355.JPG


DSC_3353.JPG


DSC_3354.JPG



Wood Slicing, I sliced wood taking thick and thin slices, the knife wasn't shapened after the cardboard and it performed excellent whittling wood with ease, would still slice newsprint after the wood.

DSC_3365.JPG


DSC_3364.JPG



Conclusion:

The knife performed outstanding with no issues with the edge at all. It's very light weight and well balanced so it feels like cutting with air and handles like a dream with no hot spots noticed. K294 steel is the steel when one needs the absolute maximum in edge holding. I wouldn't want to try and sharpen K294 on just some old oil stone, it's extremely high wear resistance would justify Sil Carbide or Diamonds for sharpening. It's very fine grained and gets incredibly sharp and is extremely aggressive cutting with the edge used in the testing.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the review!

That is a great looking knife and that steel at that high hardness ought to cut like a banshee. And it apparently does!
 
Beautiful knife and awesome results. How does this compare with your S110V Phil Wilson in terms of aggressiveness of the edge and edge retention?
 
Beautiful knife and awesome results. How does this compare with your S110V Phil Wilson in terms of aggressiveness of the edge and edge retention?

It's more aggressive than S110V and K294 beat S110V in edge retention by 17%.

K294 is now my standard for edge retention. :)
 
Last edited:
Great stuff -- not surprised at all that this steel with a Phil Wilson HT set a new standard for edge retention in your tests. :thumbup:
 
Great stuff -- not surprised at all that this steel with a Phil Wilson HT set a new standard for edge retention in your tests. :thumbup:

It was like cutting rope with a hacksaw. :D

It's really a shame that steels like this aren't offered by some production company in a limited edition, it's one of those custom knife only steels.

It's so wear resistant I doubt any production company would want to work with it, but who knows.
 
Jim,

What does a knife like that from Phil Wilson cost, and what is the wait time like? If this violates forum rules, I apologize in advance, I am just curious about the cost of such high performance cutlery.

Bill
 
Jim, Phil hit another one out of the park with that one. As far as I know he is pretty much setting the bar for others who seek extremely high performance cutlery. To be honest I'm not sure how much higher performance or exotic I'd want to go. Most other steels that have the carbides and performance to give greater wear resistance will have serious tradeoffs elsewhere in their attributes. Looking at the charts on 15V it looks to be substantially less tough. If you have a higher wear but need to thicken the edge and trade off some geometry than it may not even out cut where you are currently at.

It's an amazing knife from an amazing craftsman.

Joe
 
Jim,

What does a knife like that from Phil Wilson cost, and what is the wait time like? If this violates forum rules, I apologize in advance, I am just curious about the cost of such high performance cutlery.

Bill

That's something you would have to contact Phil Wilson directly about or go to his website, he has some prices on there.

Jim, Phil hit another one out of the park with that one. As far as I know he is pretty much setting the bar for others who seek extremely high performance cutlery. To be honest I'm not sure how much higher performance or exotic I'd want to go. Most other steels that have the carbides and performance to give greater wear resistance will have serious tradeoffs elsewhere in their attributes. Looking at the charts on 15V it looks to be substantially less tough. If you have a higher wear but need to thicken the edge and trade off some geometry than it may not even out cut where you are currently at.

It's an amazing knife from an amazing craftsman.

Joe


There seems to be trade offs as you said above this level of performance and I am not sure if they would be worth it or if we would really see a noticable increase in performance without issues.

Awesome. 17% over s110v,that's insane

Yeah and I am feeling every single bit of it too. :D
 
It's more aggressive than S110V and K294 beat S110V in edge retention by 17%.

K294 is now my standard for edge retention. :)
That's fighting talk. I don't believe you. Send it to me, and I'll confirm that for you, and send it back promptly. I promise. :D

Wow. I just might have to try this steel now, thanks Jim!!!
 
Back
Top