Picking a backpack has never been so complicated..

Joined
Feb 27, 2011
Messages
1,020
Good grief...even picking a backpack these days is a chore in research! Blech. Too many brands, not enough reviews. Mostly I've had some looks at Maxpedition and Northface.. I miss my old one. Can't remember the brandname though.. I've also looked at Voodoo...lot's o' pockets.
 
Last edited:
I always tell people to take a good hard look at Osprey. They are extremely comfortable, durable, and reasonably priced. The designs are extremely well thought out.
 
Ospreys are very nice, but to me Gregory makes the best/most comfortable packs....also not bad in price!
 
Ospreys are very nice, but to me Gregory makes the best/most comfortable packs....also not bad in price!

I agree they are very nice and super comfortable, but I sold off my Z30 when I got my Kestrel 32. The thing with packs is they are very personal and someone really should make an attempt to try on as many as they can before they purchase.

To the OP try to find an REI near you and go try on just a ton of packs the folks there are super nice and will help you in anyway they can.
 
Depends on your use these days as well, as a lot of them are made specifically to fill certain roles while not really being that great as a do-it-all pack. I've got about 7 different packs now, and they all work well for what I'm using them for.
 
Uses run the gamut. I work as a professional woodsman (often clearing brush, stumps, widow makers, fallen trees, trees), pest removal, I often go hiking with my wife and dogs, I also guide others on more complicated hikes, and EDC. I also tend to hunt/trap and fish as often as I can -- pack comes into play here as well. So, it pretty much runs the gamut. I never carry heavier than a medium load out (knee). Typically a pack for me holds extra clothing, bottled water, snacks, dog treats, laptop, book or two, notepad/pen, first-aid kit, etc. I prefer external pockets as well as internal organization pockets. I've been looking quite a bit at maxpedition and voodoo (lot's of pockets, and seem to be heavy-duty), the problem is lack of comprehensive review. :-) Also somewhat limited financially. Load out often does not change.

A little more to help. When working in brush/tree removal I typically tend to work with a double-bit axe, chainsaw, and a machete. The machete tends to ride on the backpack. The chainsaw and axe I always carry in hand. I tend to hang the pack while I work, so as to avoid snagging the fabric, or putting myself off balance.
 
Last edited:
For the stuff you're talking about, (the hiking, guiding, and hunting, especially,) I would want something with an internal frame and padded hip belt. It's a lot more comfortable when carrying anything more than a light load. I don't think Voodoo or Maxpedition make anything like that, but here're a few other options. Prices on these range from �$100 to over 300. (Kifaru and Mystery Ranch are expensive!) From what you're carrying, it sounds like �30L* should be a good amount of storage space.
The MR's, Eberlestocks, and the Kifaru should be the toughest, but you'll have to decide whether that toughness is worth the weight and cost.

Mystery Ranch:
http://www.mysteryranch.com/adventure/900-2500-cu-in
http://www.mysteryranch.com/military/assault-patrol-packs/3-day-assault-pack

Kifaru:
http://store.kifaru.net/x-ray-1800ci295-liters-p50.aspx

Eberlestock: These're listed in order of capacity, from smallest to largest. Look at the ones in the 30L/1800 c.u. range. (Again, an estimate.) If you want something that's tactical or overbuilt, Eberlestock will be a lot cheaper than Kifaru and MR, (not made in the US,) while still having the durability, quality, and general "tactical" look. I would go with the X4, (though you might prefer the X3 for its built in rifle "scabbard," which could be useful for hunting,) or maybe the Halftrack if I needed more space.
http://www.eberlestock.com/hunting.htm
http://www.eberlestock.com/Tactical Master.htm

Gregory:
http://www.gregorypacks.com/products/mens/technical/256/z-30

Osprey:
http://www.ospreypacks.com/en/group/mens/stratos_series
http://www.ospreypacks.com/en/group/mens/kestrel_series_1
http://www.ospreypacks.com/en/group/mens_1/manta_series_hydration_packs

If I had to choose something from the above list, it would be the Gregory Z30, with the Osprey Manta 28 being a close second.

*This is just an estimate. It would be best if you could see the pack in a store before buying to make sure it doesn't have too much or too little storage... or order from an online store with a good return policy. Also, if you know the capacity of the pack you currently use, that'd be helpful in narrowing down your choices.
 
Last edited:
The thing with packs is they are very personal and someone really should make an attempt to try on as many as they can before they purchase.

To the OP try to find an REI near you and go try on just a ton of packs the folks there are super nice and will help you in anyway they can.
Seconded.
 
Camelbak trizip. Uses teh Mystery Ranch suspension system and overall design at half the cost.
 
Camelbak trizip. Uses teh Mystery Ranch suspension system and overall design at half the cost.

The Camelbak Linchpin also uses the Futura harness and is a bit smaller maybe another one to check out. Also Tactical Taylor are awesome made in the USA packs at a reasonable price. Also check out Spec Ops Brand THE Pack last I looked it was on sale for about 100 bucks which is great for a made in the USA lifetime warranty pack.
 
Mystery ranch looks quite nice.. Osprey as well. I've tried on dozens and dozens in the last couple weeks...nothing quite fits right. Hmmm...maybe it's me? Maybe I should cut back on the weightlifting? Yup...padding on the straps is definitely a nice feature.
 
I just go with what's in my price range on Craigslist. After all, humans survived much worse conditions than today, with no backpacks at all. I just look for adequate size, a frame, padding on the harness. A water bladder is nice, but it's not essential.
 
I will support Maxpedition products for the rest of my life.
Great variety and of the 5 that I've owned, every single one has held up to years of use and abuse.
Stitching is flawless and I can barely see any hotspots or serious wear whatsoever.
The zippers hold up, straps are comfortable, and I just throw them in the washer whenever they get nasty.
Well priced too.
 
I second the Camelbak Linchpin. By far my favorite pack right now. Super comfy even with substantial weight, built like a tank, well thought out design and is very cool looking. If you need something bigger check out Mystery Ranch. Pricey but of all the packs I've owned they are by far the most comfortable (as stated above the Linchpin uses the Mystery Ranch Futura Harness)
 
Back
Top