Polishing blade a bad idea?

Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
980
I found a 153uh at a pawn shop for $25. It's all there, but the blade is scratched from use and not very good sharpening.
Is it worth $25, as new one on ebay are going for around 50 to 70 new, or as new.
I am wanting it for my collection but I would have to polish the blade to remove scratches, but I think that would hurt any value left.
 
Generally, if a knife is rare, or even uncommon, restoration does hurt the value. But considering the model you have, the 153UH Golden Spike, it was made for thirty years with up to a thousand a week being produced, and it is not all that rare or uncommon. If you want to improve the looks of the knife for display as a "type", then by all means polish it. You can always make it a classic pattern user if/when you obtain one in mint or near mint condition. The price you paid is in line with the market value for a 153UH in good used condition (as you described the condition of the knife), and you can hardly hurt the value much by restoring or using it, and may well increase it's value to YOU!

Either way, the 153UH was one of Schrade's most popular knives for many years, and I'm sure you'll see why, no matter which you choose! Congrats on a nice knife!

Codger
 
That is a delicate subject, Mountainwind.

In general, most "collector" pieces that have been used are thought to lose value if you alter them from the "as used" condition. Especially with carbon blades, where people like to polish out the patina on the blades. On older knives, this patina has gathered from possibly decades of use and/or storage.

For pieces that are commonly still available, it may not be such a bad thing to polish and clean up the piece. If you have no other plans to acquire a mint example of a 153UH, then my opinion is do what you wish. I don't think the knife is that old, that polishing it would affect value at this point.

The belief I have also heard from a collector standpoint is, polish/clean up the outside of the knife (ie, handle, bolsters, guard, butt, etc.), but leave the blades untouched. I guess the belief is that the handles are nice, but the blade tells the story.

Myself, each knife is treated differently. I practice as a baseline what I would call "stabilizing" the knife. That is, stopping any further deterioration of the knife, such as corrosion of the metal parts. All parts are carefully cleaned for rust and Verdigris. Any knives that will be stored get treated with a product such as Rust-Free.

I don't collect knives for their monetary value. I am trying to preserve a piece of history, and have something to pass on to my son to show him true craftsmanship.

Don't know if that answered your question...

Glenn
 
Yes, it did help. Thanks. I too am wanting something to pass down, although I will need a grandson as I only have a daughter, and I would not leave something like this in her hands, cause it would wind up parted and sold.
 
Back
Top