propane vs. charcoal

Joined
Feb 7, 2006
Messages
1,327
i want some advice on pros and cons between propane forges and charcoal forges. i have a small propane forge but i am not sure if it will work for tempering. any suggestions?
im a noob at this and dont have a clue
 
Coal is an ideal heat source for blade forging. The nice thing about it is being able to keep the heat restricted to a small area. Plus it's got the whole romanticism thing going for it.

BUT! In today's world, propane is really hard to beat. It's quick, easy, clean, easy to obtain, gets hot enough for all blade-making tasks, whether it be just forging or forge welding.

Not to be a condescending semantics prick, but I think you're talking about austenitizing when you said "if it will work for tempering"

That's the stage of heating the blade in order to quench it and make it hard.

If you want to use your forge for thermal cycles on steel, to stress relieve and refine grain, then yes it will work, it will also work for austenitizing.

Ideally you would use a digitally controlled salt bath or heat-treating furnace, but a forge will certainly work.

The tempering can be done in the house-hold oven, just make sure to get the blade good and clean before putting it in there.

If you are REALLY green to heat-treating, then do some searching here and with Google. Doing a lot of reading will save you a great deal of failed efforts.
 
Great suggestion Nick

Thanks god I found this forrum that warm and sweet as home:rolleyes: :thumbup: :thumbup: :)
 
thanks nick, i was curious as to which would be best for me and i think that the propane might be the right choice. i appreciate your time. i checked out your site, that mka bowie is mouthwatering. absolutely gorgeous!:thumbup:
thanks
mike
 
I started out with coal and now use propane. When I come home from work at 7:00 PM I can be forging a blade by 7:10 and have it finished by 9:00. If I was using coal the bed would not be really be ready for at least 90 minutes. The other reason is the only coal sources I had were either 35 miles north or 30 miles south. And then the pieces were too big so I had to spend ALOT of time smashing it up to much smaller pieces. I want to spend the time during heating resting my arm and mentally thinking out the next hammer cycle, not busting coal lumps.

With propane when I am done I shut the forge off and leave the blower going for 10 minutes. Coal on the other hand has to burn out or be extinquished after forging. So if you have a good,cheap and close supply of coal and lots of time available then it is a great option.
 
Back
Top