I am curious which would work best for hiking in the wilderness:
Shoulder rig, thigh rig, or a belt rig? If it helps, I am 6' 2.5", 180lbs.
The first two appeal to me from the appearance perspective, my thinking being that if I am going to be carrying in the open, to make it look cool. Thigh rig definitely looks cool.
But, since it's a revolver, I probably need to think about the custom route?
If backpacking with a pack, I wear a Simply Rugged holster for my .44 SPL Bulldog...it lays flat enough that the hip belt goes right over it and it's not uncomfortable. Of course it's not a speed-draw setup
I've recent received a great holster from
Lobo Gunleather; it's for a S&W 686 Plus. For custom, his prices are excellent and his holsters are very functional just like Simply Rugged.
If you're looking for open carry and don't care too much, I'll share my evolution on tactical holsters. Two deployments (Iraq and Afghanistan) and I'll tell you that thigh holsters are great for short term stuff, but not wearing long term or doing a lot of hiking/walking. I don't care for shoulder holsters and wore a Bianchi for a while in Iraq...they're just not very secure and flop around or get hung up on stuff, even with belt tie-downs. The hunting/chest rigs are a real good option. My experience was really a chest-mounted holster on an IOTV (body armor). It may interfere with your chest strap on a pack, but it's a convenient place. My only issue is that it's great for hiking and traveling (what I did by vehicle/helo a lot), but it's a little bit of a pain once you're off the trail or at your destination and need to set up camp or just relax.
Best holster I've found is a low-mounted belt holster. Blade-Tech's WRS (Weapon Retention System) holster. It sits low on your pants belt, and a pack's waist belt will ride just above it yet the pistol is still accessible. I like it on the pants belt vice a thigh rig as it is much more stable and has a better center of gravity. Tim Wegner designed a great retention mechanism that I prefer to Safariland's holsters. If I'm packing an auto-loader for the outdoors (open carry) this is what I use and can't say enough about them. I actually prefer leather, but this is a good, tough and simple system. G-Code is another holster system I’ve used…it doesn’t have the retention mechanism, however you can get the low-ride setup that is very functional for me.
Another option is The Wilderness Safepacker. It's more of a concealed holster, but works very well with a backpack. Additionally, it looks more like a camera case than holster if you want to avoid any controversial looks.
ROCK6