question about crkt edgie

Joined
Jul 11, 2008
Messages
62
hey guys im thinkin bout getting a new knife to beat the snot out of that requires little edge mantinence.ive been looking at the edgie from crkt for my budget ($40) cutting cardboard, rope, plastic zip ties, what-have-you, will be the main uses. if anyone could let me know whether or not i should spend the money that would be great.

thanks for any help

JLee
 
I got to handle one a while ago, so I'm no expert, but, the ergonomics are really good, very comfortable. The blade steel is nothing to brag about (420J2 at the time) but since it resharpens itself every time you close it, the edge is pretty good.

I thought it would make an ideal beater.
 
I got one for opening packages around the house. The blade seems a little soft, probably to help the self-sharpener along. Other than that it's been a nice little beater, I very much like that blade shape for everyday use. Be aware that this is a non-locking design.
 
I have one. Got it for around $10 delivered on ebay. I was prepared to hate it. But I like it quite a bit.

It's a decent size, approx 4" closed, 7" opened, 1/2" thick, not including the pocketclip. No lock, it's a slipjoint. With an oval hole allowing for one hand opening. Stainless steel liners, molded plastic scales with nice checkering. All screws are secure, the pivot without excess slop. The blade is a sheepsfoot shape, with a straight cutting edge, of 420J2. The grind is unusual and asymmetrical, hollow sabre grind on one side with no secondary edge bevel, and sabre grind on the other, with a wide secondary bevel. Upon closing the knife, the latter side of the blade contacts a sprung abrasive-embedded metal strip, presumably diamond. The result is the blade gets a quick, toothy sharpening swipe with each open and closing on one side of the blade.

The result of sharpening only one side of the blade produces a toothy burr on the opposite side. My instinct is to take out the stones and sharpen the blade properly. However, I've resisted, allowing the knife to perform as designed. And the performance has turned out satisfactory. Breaking down cardboard boxes goes surprisingly well. This knife isn't a push cutter. But it's a very nice slicer, as the toothy edge would suggest. Comfortable and secure in the hand. I'd think the burr would lead to problems, but it seems to hold up ok and seems integral to the way it's supposed to perform.

I'd say this would be a good knife for folks who don't particularly know or care about sharpening knives. The steel is soft, the burr more durable than expected. I suppose a dull Edgie could be restored to usability by simply opening and closing a few times. Opening one handed may not be for all, as the backspring offers more resistance than most one handed openers provide. I found the edges of the hole a bit sharp, but not enough to cut my skin. Pocket clip works well, rides somewhat high, right handed tip down only. No rivets, the knife could presumable be taken apart.

What would I improve? I'd like to see a bit nicer steel used. The 420J2 hasn't really disappointed me, but I'd like to see something a little bit harder. The blade, at .092", could stand to be a thinner, more efficient slicer. A half stop would be nice an just about any slipjoint. Particularly on a knife like this featuring one hand opening, and presumably, one hand closing. I suppose some folks would like a lock. I'm perfectly satisfied with slipjoints. There's no lanyard hole, but I don't think I miss one on this knife.

This is a novel knife that offers some unusual characteristics I very much like, pocket clip, one hand opening, slipjoint. And one that is growing on me, the self sharpening ability.
 
well for under $15 bucks i cant not get it. and thanks shecky for all the details. really appreciate all the help guys

JLee
 
Ok, I picked one up for $0.99+ $5 for shipping. It isn't a Kershaw. But for the price, I didn't really expect one. And it is actually surprisingly comfortable. While non-locking, the backspring is robust, and it has a good snap to it. I also have to say that the blade shape is more appealing in person than it looked in the pictures. As the other guy said, it has a "toothy" edge. It slices through paper well, though you can feel the small serrations from the sharpener as you cut. It also does a number on cardboard. The burrs he descibed are there on my blade as well, so I am assuming that it is an artifact of the process of self-sharpening. And the opening hole needs to be ground down a bit to remove the sharp edge inside. It was definately worth the $6. I think it is much more comfortable than a boxcutter, which is what it is going to be used as. All things considered, it is a decent beater for everyday tasks. I would actually like to see something with the same shape and heft with a regular blade made from real steel and a lock like a Buck knife or something similar. It wouldn't even need the sharpener gimmick. That would make a dandy knife indeed.

-Mb
 
We have one at the shop for breaking down boxes, etc. and I can't say (after a year) that I'm too thrilled with it. In frustration I ended up removing the sharpening bar, re-profiling the blade to a double-bevel grind and renaming it the Wedgie. It's held up well since, but I still can't stand it.
 
i'd one as a gift with an other knife, and ... i hate this knife !
i hate it because of the chisel grind, the inexistant security (care for your finger!), the opening hole, the blade quality, the "sharpening system" ...
i were looking for which use it could be do ... i didn't find ...
 
Back
Top