Randall vs. Dozier

S

ssanderso

Joined
Sep 23, 2004
Messages
7
Hi everybody!
I am in the process of buying a knife. Not just any knife though, a really good knife. I have researched and found these two names to be very respected. I am wondering which of these knives would be a better buy. The only thing I wouldn't like about the Randall is the long wait to get my knife. But I really like all the customizations that are available for them. Your thoughts and opinions are appreciated.

Scott
 
Hmmm,
Not to rip on you but thats a bit like asking, "whats better a machete or a skinning knife?"

So whatcha wanna do with yer knife there?
 
as cutting tools, Dozier by far... as trading pieces, collector value and name recognition, Randall by far...
 
My Randalls cut quite nicely thanks you very much... so do my Doziers :)

I've got a few Randalls that are strictly colllection pieces, but the few that I use are good, strong working knives. Doziers are more corrosion resistant and are a good choice if you don't want to worry about rust, but I find that keeping a keen edge on O-1 easier that on D-2. YMMV.
 
I think the Mutt has it. It's an apples to oranges comparison. Your intended use is the deciding factor.
 
As far a function, a Randall skinner or utility will perform as well as a Dozier. Ignoring the collectivle value, there is a distinct difference between these two companies. In general, Randall's premier product is a forged carbon steel blade constructed and handled in a style that has been classic for about 60 years. In general, Dozier's premier product is a stock removal semi-stainless blade constructed and handled in a manner that is more modern in both construction and style. Randall has a leather sheath; Dozier kydex. Randall's shop is in its second and third generation. Dozier's in its first. Randall is more expensive than Dozier and has a wider product line. Dozier has a smaller shop.
 
Dozier also has his Retro Line of classic style knives that are handled with natural classic materials and sheathed in leather. Personally, in an apples to apples comparison, I'd take one of these Retro Doziers ahead of a Randall. Doziers heat treatment of the D2 and Dozier grind on the blade would swing the tide toward the knife from Arkansas for me.
 
I love Dozier's knives too. I think I commented on this on the knife forum. But I didn't mention that some knives have what I term 'character'. I have always appreciated a knife that ages. One that gets some staining on the blade, and some marks of use, like the old Case Congress I've had since I was 16, or some of the Old Timers I've sharpened for buddies of mine where the high carbon blades show the signs of use and sweat and whatever else has touched them over the years. I like steel that ages. Randall has that going for them. A Randall user knife that has been taken care of is a beautiful sight to see once the steel of the blade takes on this aging and character from years of carrying it. There is something personal and nostalgic about taking time to clean off the blade and having to take care of it like an old trusted friend, or an old shotgun passed down from your dad or grandfather. Something to think about for sure.
 
For a using knife that you are going to carry all day, everyday, a Dozier is damn near impossible to beat. Sharp, hold an edge, excellent]/i] sheaths, etc etc.

Dont get me wrong now, Randall Knives are great knives, and will definitely retain collectors value- and gain value quicker than just about any dozier. If you are interested in Randalls, there are a few sites online that have them on hand.
www.agrussell.com is one place off hand. They will also place special orders for you as well. Check out the site. Also check out www.nordicknives.com.

My .02
 
I have dozens of Randalls like a lot of collectors, and wouldn't use any of them.... chunky handles generally that don't typically feel great in the hand, heavy sheaths, not the best steel, etc. Oh yeah, there is a cost consideration too.

Doziers by comparison are so-so collectibles, but outstanding users. I have 18 of Bob's knives and like all of them as possible users. Bob also makes the best sheath in the biz IMHO, especially his horizontal sheaths... very light and highly functional. Some of Bob's models seem small until you get them in hand.

TR
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top