RD-9 VS Junglas

Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Messages
6,583
Looking at several large knives this morning and making comparisons The new ESEE goes for 128 without a sheath and is 1095 steel. The BK-9 Goes for 75.00 and is 1095 steel. The Ontario RTAK ll is 1095 and runa in the same price range. However the RD-9 is 5160 steel and runs about 115.00.

Looking for opinions of these knives and the performance of the steels.
 
Yeah man, i own both the RTAK II, and the ESEE JUNGLAS. I have not had the time to test the Junglas, but the RTAK II has nice edge retention, and is easy to resharpen. i was enduro chop through log after log (not batoning with the grain) against the grain. i did notice dulling along primary edge after fifty or so swings. the blade is just thick enough to make the jump from machette to knife. the blade has an exelent spring temper, though it seems to bend quite easy when prying. but this does allow it to be lightweight and perform its designed job. the blade is very well balanced, making the primary cutting edge at the base of the knife. it high saber grind is perfect for chopping through the forest...but makes the blade stick pretty well if you are hacking into wood (against the grain) this is one knife that i wouldnt mind having with me despite its size and weight if i were to be camping in the woods. it is very light and feels like it would be good to choke up on and do technical small cutting tasks. so It does perform as expected.:thumbup:

the only real issue that i have with this knife is that the handle is too bulky. the canvas micarta scales arent tapered as much as the Junglas, and are a bit fatter. the main issue is with the grind. it would seem that in comparison to the Junglas, its grind is not as deep where the handle dips in. holding it reminds me of the RAMBO III knife designed by Hibben. its does not effect the performance, but unless you have rather large hands, or are expecting its size, it can be a little bit awkward at first...:grumpy:

all in all, it works, its tough, and it will hold its ground. its grind and overall percision quality is no where near that of the ESEE, but it performs great. for its price, around 100 dollars its worth it. i do know that Ontario runs a bit more along the lines of kabar and other knife companies that focus on production and quality performance...not necessarily perfect edge grinds.

_
 
Last edited:
horn dog did a nice review on the junglas and a busse bwm(?). its somewhere in the esee forum.

the junglas has a great edge from the factory, and what little i've been able to do with it, seems pretty awesome. my right hand is damaged, so most of what i've done is off-hand... one-handed batonning half-dried osage orange, chopping it, using as a drawknife... still shaving sharp.

if you decide on the junglas get the sheath! excellent kydex with a jump-proof molle backing, lets you wear it comfortably on the belt, or strap it to your gear. easily worth the 50 or so extra bucks.
 
heck yeah man. its very nice quality. the only thing that i have to say is if you go with the rtak2 then make sure to watch the "nutnfancy" reveiw! it shows you a quick fix for the sheaths zero retention plastic insert. it worked for me!:D
 
Back
Top