Reason for hollow grind on razor ?

Joined
Aug 26, 2005
Messages
4,106
I presumed the hollow grind on a straight razor was to fascilitate shaving .
Lately I have been Seeing that a knife with a different grind can shave almost as well .

So what gives ? Is it for multiple reasons ?
 
IMO, the reason for the hollow grind on any blade is to facilitate easy sharpening. Less metal to remove. Thats why they grind a hollw edge on a chisel. That way when you're sharpening you've got an order of magnitude less metal to remove. Makes it a few minute job.

It could also be because of the edge geometry for slicers, but IMO, this isn't the case for razors. They work much like a chisel don't they?
 
It could also be because of the edge geometry for slicers, but IMO, this isn't the case for razors. They work much like a chisel don't they?Quote Andy.

Chisel ? Andy are you saying I have a tough beard ? :grumpy: :grumpy: :D
 
Also make sharpening the razors really easy. Just lay it flat on the stone, and you got it! (plus stropping and all the other little things :) )

Chris
 
Hey, at least I didn't comment about you're wife's beard.......LOL.
 
Thanks DGG . They have some neat terminology there . Also Stropping on the ball of the thumb? I wonder what thats about ? They didn,t explain it that well .
 
Slicing? Think about it, when the straight razor blade is shaving away hair, it is really a slicing motion of the blade going through each hair. Using a chisle on wood is basically slicing, which is why it has to be so sharp to work properly.
 
IMO, when slicing there is a lateral move of the blade whereas with a chisel, or a razor, it is movement of the cutting edge straight into the object being cut. But then, what the hell do I know. Sarge?????
 
Slice does instill pictures of lateral movement . Chopping ? Don,t even use that term and my neck in the same sentence . L:O:L

Could we settle on " Cut " ?

No Andy you can,t use batonning . L:O:L
 
Chisels and razors are good examples of a true "push cut", in which the blade functions as a very sharp wedge to part the material. In a slicing cut you get the wedge effect coupled with a sawing action, a good reason some folks like a "toothier" edge on their slicers.

Already some good observations on why straight razors are hollow ground, but I'd like to add that many early razors, and some still in use today, are flat ground, not hollow ground. I own a couple (both were made in Sheffield) and they shave just fine. They take a slightly different approach when honing/stropping, in that you have to raise the spine up slightly when honing and use a slackened strop technique, something you'd never, ever, do to a hollow ground razor. Still, I'm convinced that tinkering around with those old flat ground straight razors was good for my education. If you can learn how to sharpen them properly for shaving, you can apply the same techniques to just about any good knife. 'Course, to find those techniques, you gots to do research, lots and lots of research. But heck, that's half the fun ain't it? What better kind of treasure hunt than one in which the treasure is knowledge?

Sarge
 
Thanks Sarge.

Sometimes I buy the wife's opinion of my opinions.....

Doh~!
 
Back
Top