Recommendation for EDC Fallkniven?

B

bort2.0

Gold Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2021
Messages
631
Ok, one more call for help here... I'm stuck in analysis paralysis again.

I'd like to get a Fallkniven, and need something that will be appropriate for EDC. Stuff around the house, "need a knife..." things, and construction projects around the house.

Can't be too long, because Id prefer to conceal carry it, not a sheath dangling down my leg.

The PXL is appealing for that, but not sure I want a folder.

Considering:
F1 or TK2 (too big?)
Taiga (smaller model)
R2 scout
TK5 (or TK6)

Any suggestions on how to get in on Fallkniven 3G fixed blade goodness, but still reasonable to CONCEAL carry?

Leaning TK5/6... but just can't make up my @#$_!@ mind! :)

THANKS!
 
Last edited:
The F1 is the knife that put Fällkniven on the map, and for good reason. I have quite a few of their knives and the F1 is still my favourite by a fair margin.

I do not think it is too large for concealed carry, especially if you get an appropriate aftermarket sheath for it.
 
If you are not heavy cutting, get the WM1, do not know if it comes in 3G, but it is small , maybe too thin, but carries light and you have it all the time without bulk. I just checked, found one called the TH1 or the TH2 ( Taiga Hunter), larger than the WM1 but smaller than the F1. They and the WM1 also come in what they called Laminated cobalt steel, which I believe is different than 3G.
 
Last edited:
The Fallkniven WM1 currently comes in Laminated CoS steel only. The R2 Scout comes in Elmax steel, but it's a much thicker blade, hence the name Scout.
 
The TH1 & TH2 are really nice plus you get 4 mm more blade at less weight (especially with the TH2). Now of course, you have the KKLz, even lighter with 85 mm blade. That was my choice and I don't regret it. It's an excellent EDC (in the "can do it all and asks for more" department). The WM1 is a sweet little knife, 77 grams but only 70 mm blade. Sadly all these are LamCos steel. If you need your 3G, go for the TK5 or TK6 : size is similar so you can probably even pocket carry them.
 
I go with Pitiless Bronze just above, get an F1. I really like the Zytel sheath,
but the leather one isn't half bad.
Meantime, the knife is a classic. Blade of clad, laminated steel, Thermorun handle,
full tang, and the rear of the tang extends out from the rear of the handle -
and right there you have a very useful impact device as well. The shape,
size, balance, weight, and manufacturing integrity all work together to
provide us with this bargain for a buck twenty or so.

Then, of course, if you want to go with the 3G version - it's even better.
Well, it's your wallet
 
Thank you all for the great advice! I agree that I've always been visually drawn to the F1, just concerned (perhaps unreasonably so?) that it might be too larger to carry.

Also, I'm not stuck on 3G, but do think it would be a really nice thing to have. Maybe just looking for something beyond VG-10... which I also understand is a quite nice steel in many ways.

A few remaining questions:
* What's the difference in size between the F1 and TK2? Hard to find a side-by-side... pretty similar, but maybe the TK2 gets narrower from handle to tip a little quicker?
* If I went for one of the Desert Ironwood versions of the TK... do those hold up pretty well to non-abusive EDC wear and tear? Or better to get Thermorun and call it a day?

Again, I'm really trying to talk myself out of the fancy F1 with the micarta handle... but maybe should start with a cheaper F1 and see how it fits me.

And also, resolved to the fact that I'm going to end up with a handful of Fallkniven's after this is all said and done. So maybe it's all about where to start, haha!

Thanks again!
 
You are trying to buy one knife for all your needs. Not going to happen. Most of us on this forum have bunch of knives. Get one. See how it works for you. What works for me may not work for you.

Its a adventure getting different blades. I don't have a lot of money. But of over 25 30 years. Bunch of knives and Bows and Arrows. :)
at
Do not worry about the steel so much. HO yea. My Esee 4 Is one of my best blades. I have plenty more that cost a lot more.

Rich K.
 
The WM1 comes in all three steel types, the one I have is in 3G, they are great little light weight knives. I'd like to pick one up in COS steel as well.
 
Unless you are set on a Fallkniven, take a look at Enzo (Brisa) blades. Made in Finland, great variety styles and steels. I commonly carry a Enzo Birk 75 in D2 with curly birch scales. 3 inch blade, thumbstud/linerlock comes razor sharp. I've numerous puukko and other Nordic knives, but the Enzo birk 75 is my favorite carry (in opposite pocket from my SAK Tinker). Enzo makes lots of fixed blade styles.



Other suggestion would be a Roselli Carpenter in UHC steel (only if you have a diamond hone). Steel is amazing, good working size and blade shape - I don't care for the sheath, but lots of those around, just find one you like).



You won't need to hone either for a LONG, LONG time.
As they say on "Farce in Fire" - they will cut ! :)
Rich
 
Last edited:
Thanks everyone!

Tentative plan is to get an F1 and TK6, and sort it out from there.

Yes, I'm trying to do everything with one knife, and I know that's trouble. But I also know that's just how I approach things. I don't need a collection, and I don't need a ton of variety. Just a trusty workhorse knife that I can keep with me for opening stuff, cutting stuff, breaking stuff down, etc ... and whatever other good/bad ideas I get about using it. I doubt I'll do any bushcrafting, like I've seen in the Fallkniven review videos... And I'm not a hunter.

One thing seems for sure though, these knives are TOUGH and will take whatever I throw at it. Seems like I've been way too gentle with my knives...? :)
 
d762nato said:
The WM1 comes in all three steel types, the one I have is in 3G, they are great little light weight knives. I'd like to pick one up in COS steel as well.
Click to expand...
The WM1 currently is being produced only in CoS. Some knife sites may still have some in VG10.
 
Last edited:
herisson said:
The TH1 & TH2 are really nice plus you get 4 mm more blade at less weight (especially with the TH2). Now of course, you have the KKLz, even lighter with 85 mm blade. That was my choice and I don't regret it. It's an excellent EDC (in the "can do it all and asks for more" department). The WM1 is a sweet little knife, 77 grams but only 70 mm blade. Sadly all these are LamCos steel. If you need your 3G, go for the TK5 or TK6 : size is similar so you can probably even pocket carry them.
Click to expand...

herisson herisson , you mentioned how it is sad they come in LamCos steel, can you say why it is a bad thing? I appreciate it, and I do not know a lot about it. Too hard to sharpen in the field? The only thing I have heard about the F1 is the initial or factory edge may be a little thin and may chip out until you use it a little and have to resharpen it to get a slightly thicker working edge.
 
Last edited:
your needs are casual...like mine. get a thin blade that slices well...a knife is supposed to cut. i have owned fallkniven in 3g, but not any more.
i don't even consider a blade, for casual use, that is thicker than 1/8" (0.125"). you don't need a prybar.
my most recent fixed blade is a fiddleback forge hiking buddy...3.2" blade, 0.125" blade thickness, 7.2" overall length for easy concealment, scout carry.
...and i would be much happier with 3/32" (0.094") as it will cut and slice so much easier than a thick blade.
those Fallkniven models of 0.180" and such are NOT in line with your casual needs. Seriously!
 
Love my Kolt. Disappears into a pocket easily. I have the TK2 as well, great for a slightly longer blade but it rattles in the sheath like crazy. I intend to make a leather one some day. A4F15D4B-97C7-47BD-8F2B-9A55EFE22282.jpeg
 
cbach8tw said:
herisson herisson , you mentioned how it is sad they come in LamCos steel, can you say why it is a bad thing? I appreciate it, and I do not know a lot about it. Too hard to sharpen in the field? The only thing I have heard about the F1 is the initial or factory edge may be a little thin and may chip out until you use it a little and have to resharpen it to get a slightly thicker working edge.
Click to expand...
"Sadly" was only because I had the feeling bort was very set on 3G. Fallkniven's LamCos steel is great. I had no chipping or any other issue with my Kolt. I didn't even have to sharpen it yet (yes, I'm very easy on my knives...). It's a perfect EDC. Only gripe, the blade is way too thick for my uses. I prefer a thin blade.
 
IMG-1106.png
 
That beautiful Scout (ABOVE) has a blade thickness of 0.189"......
nice for the woods; MUCH too thick for casual home use.
My "scout carry" fixed blades are 0.125" max...(several) and roughly 7.25" overall length.
My excellent $300 CLIPPED folder by Three Rivers Manufacturing is 0.090" and is great for my household jobs.
FOR YOUR SAKE, DON'T GET CARRIED AWAY BY A KNIFE DESIGNED FOR WOODS WORK.
FALLKNIVENS ARE FINE KNIVES...DESIGNED BY AND FOR "hunters and outdoorsmen,"JUST NOT WHAT YOU WANT OR NEED.
DON
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top