Recommendation? Replacement for Benchmade AFOII

Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
11
Hello first time poster. Apologies for the long post, I don't like to ask for recommendations without giving plenty of information. I've carried a knife basically as long as I can remember, picking from whatever looked cool in the walmart case when I wore one out. After getting a real job, I decided to go with something a little bit nicer and got myself a Benchmade Griptillian.

I had great luck with it and carried it daily for many years, cutting tasks anywhere from package opening, branch cutting and a feeling of self defense, up to poor treatment like kindling splitting and small screw turning. My only complaint was the "plastic" handle, it just never felt solid or rugged although it always performed.
A couple years ago auto knives became unrestricted where I lived, so I saved up and got myself an AFOII, hoping for many of the attributes of the Griptillian but more metal, longer blade and automatic, just because I can now.

Honestly, it was only just ok. I had high expectations from all the reviews I read and after spending that much $$$. It was sharp enough, I liked the size and weight. The aluminum handle dented within the first week just from dropping it onto tile, and the paint came off quickly, making it look like a cheap worn out knife after a couple months of just carrying it in my pocket.

All that long winded crap aside, I put the AFO in with some of my tools to bring home from camping, and never unpacked it. Just don't really care enough for it one way or another to be bothered. So now I'm trying to fill the void in my pocket and not just jump on another Benchmade.

My initial thought was going to an Adamas or something similar, but the cost and previous disappointment have me looking here, reading reviews and looking for the opinions of the experts that have actually used and carried some of the many options out there. I lean towards satin finished drop points, no serrations in the 3.5-4" ballpark. Assisted, auto, no big preference as long as the knife is tough. And yes, I know tough is subjective and doesn't typically apply to folders, but I can't really EDC a fixed blade.

Is the Adamas actually worth the money? Any recommendations on something else that checks the boxes? No real knife stores here so I'm half flying blind, and half trying to hunt down good suggestions to put my hands on where available.

Thanks!
 
Welcome to the forums. I've owned some BM but currently down to one atm. The Rift. I have no experience with the Adamas.

I'm still a Cold Steel (CS) fan. Some folks have cooled on CS since they were sold to a big corporation a year or two ago but I still think they make a good knife for the money. They also have the patented Tri-ad lock from Demko which I love.

A couple of options for you ..
https://www.knifecenter.com/item/CS...aus-10a-stonewashed-blade-fde-griv-ex-handles
https://www.knifecenter.com/item/CS...ing-knife-s35vn-satin-blade-black-g10-handles
https://www.knifecenter.com/item/CS...s35vn-black-dlc-plain-blade-black-g10-handles
 
I'm not a Benchmade fan, their qc can be spotty.

For something heavy duty as mentioned Cold Steel is an option.

I think a Spyderco Shaman would be perfect. A Zero Tolerance 0095 if you can find one is a good bet.

The anodizing on aluminum always gets dinged up quickly. Just have to live with it.
 
Thanks for the replies, I'll look into cold steel and the other suggestions a bit more. Honestly, when I saw cold steel in some of the "10 best" lists I mentally tuned the brand out. I always associated it with the old frost cutlery and the like you would find at fairs and flea markets.
 
Last edited:
+1 on the Spyderco Shaman, one of my top 5 favorite edc's.

Too many good options to possibly list.. BM can be hit or miss sometimes, but I've always had good luck with them.

The Adamas is one of my top BM's. But honestly, I've never been a fan of BM auto's. I much prefer a button as opposed to the axis lock bar for deployment..

But I have a manual Cruwear Adamas and and it's a great user..
 
I would say that Benchmade's Claymore auto is fantastic, with my specific example arriving as a perfectly functioning example, and it's the same with every example I've been able to examine at the Ace Hardware stores near me that carry Benchmade knives. It fires hard, the CPM D2 blade came screaming sharp, and I like that it has a deep carry pocket clip. Button lock right where your thumb would fall before you push the lock button to deploy the knife, all just work. The only criticism I'd leverage against it is that the Claymore's handle design isn't as hand-filling as say, a fullsize Adamas as it's a bit slimmer. Still comfortable to hold, however. Speaking of the Adamas, I have multiple color variants of that knife, to include the auto version all with those bombproof CRUWEAR blades, and that's another knife I'd highly recommend. These new Benchmades are really well made, it's a shame that previous years of spotty QC have made people leery of them, because the knives they're putting out now are excellent.
 
Thanks for the replies, I'll look into cold steel and the other suggestions a bit more. Honestly, when I saw cold steel in some of the "10 best" lists I mentally tuned the brand out. I always associated it with the old frost cutlery and the like you would find at fairs and flea markets.

I understand. Back when CS was with Lynn Thompson, the videos of blaring rock and people stabbing things were a turn off. But, then I bought a few of those knives and I like them. My advice, skip the marketing and concentrate on the knife.

Another under rated knife imo is the Spartan Blades Astor in CTS XHP steel. It can be found for under $100 from reputable, online knife retailers. I have one in green G10 and it is part of my usual knife rotation too.

I don't carry autos so I can't speak to those.
 
Strange, it only shows one thread in my watched list. It errored out when posting so I had to hit the back button.
So, seeing that it double posted only a couple minutes apart wouldn't it be safe to assume it's an accidental double post? Or do you really think I posted the question and didn't get a response within 3 minutes so I posted it again?
 
I don’t assume or try to determine your motivation in posting. I found it to be repetitive no matter the reason.

The point is moot now because it appears that the first post has been deleted.
 
Thanks everyone that made recommendations. I'm learning towards a Cold Steel right now due to price range and a reputation for being really solid. I really like the looks of the ZT 0095, I will have to keep watching for a used one though.
 
I’ve had a Benchmade AFOII and also found it to be lackluster. I recently was in the market for a medium sized auto, and picked up a Benchmade CLA and a ProTech TR-3 Magnacut. Both of them completely blow the AFOII out of the water! Thin, snappy, tough, comfortable…they both do it all!

If you want another medium sized auto, take a look at the CLA or TR-3.

Skip Cold Steel…they make decent knives, but their customer service is completely lacking, in my experience.
 
.
Welcome to the forums. I've owned some BM but currently down to one atm. The Rift. I have no experience with the Adamas.

I'm still a Cold Steel (CS) fan. Some folks have cooled on CS since they were sold to a big corporation a year or two ago but I still think they make a good knife for the money. They also have the patented Tri-ad lock from Demko which I love.

A couple of options for you ..
https://www.knifecenter.com/item/CS...aus-10a-stonewashed-blade-fde-griv-ex-handles
https://www.knifecenter.com/item/CS...ing-knife-s35vn-satin-blade-black-g10-handles
https://www.knifecenter.com/item/CS...s35vn-black-dlc-plain-blade-black-g10-handles

+1 Cold steel. My favorites are the Ultimate hunter and the Recon 1.They are basically insidstructable or as absolutely close to it as you can get in a folder. I think it will give tou the confidence inspiring bank vault feel you are looking for.

I have a BM Contego and a Crooked River. I freaking love them both!! Sold or traded my other models
 
Welcome to the forums!

First things first, use the right tool for the job or at least get a little closer. While a fixed blade is definitely stronger, you still shouldn't turn screws with it and such. You might benefit from looking at Swiss Army Knives, pliers-based multi-tools, etc. Even smaller ones can be very handy. I usually carry one in addition to a dedicated knife.

I don't care for aluminum handles, both for how they feel and how they wear. I'm also not a fan of BM.

You've already got a couple of recommendations for the Spyderco Shaman. Overall, Spyderco is a great brand and makes some good, tough folders. If nothing else, take the time and have some fun looking over their catalog. If you decide you want something more in line with the Benchmade form factor, check out the Ritter RSK from Hogue.
 
Welcome to the forums!

First things first, use the right tool for the job or at least get a little closer. While a fixed blade is definitely stronger, you still shouldn't turn screws with it and such. You might benefit from looking at Swiss Army Knives, pliers-based multi-tools, etc. Even smaller ones can be very handy. I usually carry one in addition to a dedicated knife.
Definitely! I actually picked up a Leatherman Wave for just that reason, less wear and tear on the knife. And since it has a small finer blade, I can get away with a bigger folder more capable of chopping and bigger tasks.
 
I hated the PM2 for a long time. The compression lock wasn’t for me at all. Even though It seems to be one of the most popular knives. I got another one on trade and decided to carry it for a while. It took a week or so but I finally realized why it is so popular. It makes a great edc knife.

I have owned several Benchmade Adamas. They are great knives. It is a lot of knife to edc. Tank of a knife though!

Let me suggest a Civivi Praxis. It is one of the best budget knives available. 9cr isn’t fancy blade steel. For $40 you can’t beat that Civivi quality!
 
I hated the PM2 for a long time. The compression lock wasn’t for me at all. Even though It seems to be one of the most popular knives. I got another one on trade and decided to carry it for a while. It took a week or so but I finally realized why it is so popular. It makes a great edc knife...

Let me suggest a Civivi Praxis. It is one of the best budget knives available. 9cr isn’t fancy blade steel. For $40 you can’t beat that Civivi quality!

Yeah, I've come around on the compression lock via the Sage 5. It's a neat way of closing a knife, even if I still find myself instinctively reaching for the liner/frame lock on occasion. Coincidentally, the button lock on my Smock looks like an adapted compression lock too.

Civivi is a solid choice under $100. Fit, finish, and action are all on par with more expensive stuff. While 9Cr18Mov isn't fancy, it is a good budget steel on its own. What is fancy is the heat treatment it gets from WE in the Civivi and Sencut knives. That bumps it up from good to great on the budget end. I'd take it over any of the Chinese D2 or even Spyderco's VG-10. (Spyderco's VG-10 is solidly okay and good enough for my EDC needs.)
 
Last edited:
Lots of great suggestions thanks! The sub $100 knife market really looks to have improved over the years. I don't mind spending more, but I hate feeling like something expensive was expensive just for the name.
I'm pretty narrowed down to either a Cold Steel 4 Max Scout or Civivi Praxis. They both are on the larger side, have a solid drop point and sound like they are good "bang for the buck" values.
 
Back
Top