Review of a Garud ang khola?

Joined
Nov 30, 1999
Messages
2,913
Any body got one of these? How do you like it? Is it for show only or will it take heavy use? This is high on my next to buy list and I would like to hear from any one who has one. I USE all my knives. I don't display them for show only. So if this is pretty much a show item and not up to frequent and heavy use, I would not want to get it. Some people might say to get a villager to pound on, but I like the carved handle design on this knife. I read somewhere on another thread that the Hannumans, which are similar, are not really the best for heavy use. Any insights into this dillema is appreciated.
 
HI uses three different types of tang.

The standard type is a full length rat tail which extends out the back of the handle, though a buttplate and diamond shaped keeper, and is then peened to secure it in addition to the laha poured to fill the gaps between tang and wood or horn. This is generally preferred as the tang is solidly held, but insulates the hand from the worst of vibration.

The second type is the partial rat-tail. As above except it does not extend through the end of the butt and is not as firmly secured.
This is considered by HI to be a "weak" tang although it is the most commonly used type for working khuks in villages and on farms. To quote Uncle Bill, the attitude is: "... a blade is forever. A handle isn't." This is the type used for the Hanuman, Garud, Snow Leopard, and other carved handles.

The third type and most or least desireable depending on your point of view, is the pana butta, or "riveted through" aka the chiruwa. The handle is of sandwich construction, and the exposed tang has wood slabs riveted on either side. Transfers the impact vibration of a chop to the hand, unlike first two types.

The second or partial tang you asked about, is somewhat weaker if only laha is used to secure it. But only weaker in comparison to the other two styles. A brass pin up near the bolster, drilled through handle and tang would permanently secure things or heating and pulling the tang and handle apart, scraping off the laha, and resetting in a good western epoxy. Your call. If I wanted a partial tang and carved handle I'd drill out and enlarge the tang hole in the handle, replace the laha with lots of good epoxy and then put a brass pin in.

A carved handle on a khuk is just something else entirely. The presence of spirit is of a whole different magnitude.

 
:
I like the "old style" Hanuman Much better than the new one. I think the kamis went way overboard in making the new one so dayumed big. I don't believe anyone could tear up that khukuri. If the kamis were to make the Hanuman on the same scale as the YCS it would be a Real Nice using khukuri imo!!!! The Hanuman handle is very comfortable.

Uncle Bill still talks abut a guy in the eastern part of the USA that bought a Hanuman several years ago for daily use, against Uncle Bill's advice. And IIRC it has seen some Heavy[/] Use
Uncle Bill hasn't had to replace that khukuri yet!!!!
smile.gif


Just how long ago was that Bro?


------------------
>>>>---¥vsa---->®

Each person's work is always a portrait of himself.

---- Samuel Butler.

Khukuri FAQ
Himalayan Imports Website
 
I can't remember but the knife has been going strong for some time. This fellow carries the knife in his hand and leaves the scabbard and all the little tools in the house. The Hanuman is another unfriendly carry rig.

------------------
Blessings from the computer shack in Reno.

Uncle Bill
Himalayan Imports Website
Khukuri FAQ
Himalayan Imports Archives (18,000+ posts)

[This message has been edited by Bill Martino (edited 12-19-2000).]
 
Thanks for the info guys. I think I will go ahead and get one as soon as I get the cash, which should be after Christmas. Will I have to order it or do you have one around Uncle Bill? A couple more questions. I was looking at the photo of it on the web site and it looked like there was one rivet through the top part of the handle. Is that present on every one, or on that one in particular? I noticed the Hanumans did not have that. It would seem to me that it would make a difference. If they don't have it, can somebody out there do it for me? I don't want to take the chance or messing up that fine carving through inexperience.
 
Thanks, I will be sending you payment in advance soon. If any come in with a rivet, that is the type I would prefer. I can't wait, this is something I've been wanting for quite some time.
 
Back
Top