Review of Colonial 3" Handmade Lockback

Joined
Jun 17, 2001
Messages
43
In this industry of pocket knives and fine cutlery there have been many problems that they face in this post 9-11 world. Ever since that day in September our government and its agencies have caused the public to view pocket knives as “weapons”. With increased security in our transportation systems and current terrorist threats viewed by law enforcement; our trusted heirlooms and old friends that helped us in our daily lives are now becoming seen as the enemy. Schrade cutlery themselves attribute their demise to the publics current views on pocket knives and the over all flood of imported knock offs and look alikes, our knife companies and their generations of craftsmen are not daunted by the worlds current views and continue to challenge the problem with many innovative ads featuring positive and pro-pocket knife attitudes. Those marketing strategies and the continued advancement in radical design and better steels are helping these companies survive in a very competitive industry.

The Colonial knife company who has been around since the early 1900’s is one of those companies who continue to survive in spite of the odds stacked against them. For while the company dropped off the map and had seemed to go bankrupt but much to my surprise they have come back and are better than ever in producing cutlery with the time honored quality our fathers and grandfathers carried in their pockets and passed on to their sons.

With quality brands made by Colonial such as Ranger, Old Cutler and Anvil Colonial continue to produce these and a new line of cutlery called simply “Hand Crafted”. With a quality that is defiantly superb like that of other companies like Boker, Case and Schrade Colonial is out to make a name for themselves.

The first knife that I have the honor of reviewing is their three inch lockback with cocobolo wood handles. The knife features the traditional nickel-silver bolster, brass pins and liners; it also uses a new 440 stainless in replace of its carbon blades of the past. Fit and finish of this knife is quite good with only a few small gaps in the liners by the butt of the handle. The smooth wood handles and countersunk shield give the knife a very comfortable feel in your hand when using it, the knife when your grip it comes to the end of your ring finger giving you a decent grip on a small pocket knife such as this.

The knife itself is very well built and the only thing that I am not happy with is the tension of the spring that holds the locking bar tight. It doesn’t require too much or too little to force to unlock the knife and the lock is quite secure. But when the knife is in the close position the blade is not held very strongly and I believe it could be just a little bit better. I have been using lockback style locks for many years and most of them snap with authority and have little or no play at all when the blade is closed and I know that this doesn’t take away from the quality of the lock, just simply some slack in the spring retention. Nothing to be worried about but rather a personal thought on the cosmetics of locking mechanism.

I have had this knife for almost a week now and the 440 steel blade is holding up quite well and I haven’t had to touch up the blade as of yet. At my job (Grocery store Asst. Manager) I cut a lot of cardboard, tape, plastic strapping and other stuff of the like that you come in to contact with working in this type of a job. The blade came shaving sharp and it still continues to cut like the devil and shows now sign as of yet of slowing down, cutting cardboard especially comes with little resistant at all.

All in all this handcrafted lockback is fantastic and it holds true to the classic designs that artisans and knife makers have been making for centuries. This knife is sure to be at home in your pocket and should provide anyone with years of faithful service. I believe heavily in buying American made products when ever I can and want to support our men and women in this country that make it as great as it is. Colonial is right on with their quality with this knife and I hope that they continue to turn out more quality cutlery in the future.

For contact of Colonial Cutlery:

http://colonialcutlery.com
colonialcutlery@aol.com

For a free pocket knife like this one go to the website go to Contact us, fill out the necessary information, your free knife will be shipped out within 24 hours.
 
Thanks for taking the time to add a review. Can you provide an internet link or model number for the specific knife you're discussing?

Their website doesn't have info yet on the "Hand Crafted" series, but I'm enthusiastic.

I was attracted to the Rancher Series Barlow. Very handsome outline.

Best Wishes,
Bob
 
you have to go to thier knife page and download the pdf file, I am not at my house but when I get a chance I will post a pic on this thread. Thanks for reading.
 
David, thanks for your nice review. You didn't miss anything.

I've owned Colonial anvils, rangers and old cutlers.. nothing wrong with them at the price point they sold for. I'm hopeful of a happy future for Colonial.

Phil
 
I found the pdf file. Nice-looking knives, and I ~love~ cocobolo. One discrepancy, the pdf file says the HandCrafted knives are 420 stainless. Maybe they upgraded the materials for '05; the pdf file is last year's products.

One criticism of the knives, based entirely on the photos. The "Handcrafted" logo printed on the blade face distracts from the overall beauty of the knife. I'd rather knife companies not do that...

Here's a pic I lifted from the pdf file. Same knife?
Colonial.jpg


-Bob
 
Thanks for the knife review, DavidBinVT.

It was written much better than most articles in some knife magazines.

I might reconsider ordering a Colonial.


James
 
I agree it was well thought out and written. And it sounds like a much better knife than I was expecting as a freebie. Perhaps they really are serious about trying to capture the market segment left by Schrade's demise. If so, putting a quality example of their knives in the hands of dyed-in-the-wool Schradeophiles is the best way I know of doing it. IF they are one of the companies who value my business enough to be upfront about U.S. origin of parts and assembly.
 
Thank you for the review, I appreciate that you even gave the knife a test drive for us. Looks like we'll have to keep a eye on Colonial's new stuff, might be on to something good.
 
Thanks guys, I appreciate the feedback and I am glad you like what you see (thanks for posting the pic). The knife I recieved did not in fact have "handcrafted" on the blade. And yes indeed it does say 440 :) Oh and sorry for the typos and mistakes, I re-read it later and thought whooops I should have looked it over better before posting. Part of me really wishes some Magazine would pick me up as a product reviewer. I love to write reviews and all my friends say that I write them real well.

What gets me is Colonial has been around as long as most of these other companies and yet they are still so wildly unfarmiliar with the public. Lack of advertising perhaps? I am making it my person mission in my area to get the schrade, case and buck users to try Colonial. I have been conversing with Steve (the CO) at the company and he has been more than helpfull i helping me get the materials I need to help promote his company.
 
And yes indeed it does say 440
Good!
The knife I recieved did not in fact have "handcrafted" on the blade.
That's good too. I wasn't picking only on Colonial; a lot of knives have blade printing. To me it just looks cheap. My Case Sodbusted is another example.

Best Wishes,
Bob
 
I ordered an L-304B jigged bone lockback from the Colonial Handcrafted series and did a review of my own. Yeah, I stole David's format (and a good one it is David ;) ) and I posted it here:

http://home.comcast.net/~lrvickery1/colonial/Codger_review.htm

I hope this meets with the forum rules. I am a die-hard Schradophile and do not want to do anything to disrupt the Schrade forum rules. Anyone who has a problem with the method of my posting this, just let me know and I will do whatever is needed.

Codger
 
Hey, does Larry know you are using his website? How do I do that???

Excellent, Codger. Well written as David's review was. Uhhhnmmm.. I'm sitting here as I type this with a 3OT on the desk. Seems much the same knife. That is not a knock on the product.

Just some questions: Cost? Did you order it from the website? How long did it take to recieve it? How would you rate it compared to a Case?

I guess we have kinda adopted Colonial here. I certainly don't have any objections.

I do like the looks of the trapper in the advertising photo.

Phil
 
OK,OK,
I received a 305T from Colonial. I wasn't sure if it was OK to post about the knife here, but here goes....

It was received just as Codger said...awesome packaging. VERY nice linen or linen-look box, and secure for shipping or traveling.The trapper I received was a good looking production piece in great packaging.

As a collector, I would rate the fit about average on mine:

1. Some gaps between liners and backsprings, just enough to see light in a couple of places.
2. The shield was not installed straight...at a slight angle.
3. The spey blade was touching the outside liner, resulting in a slight blade rub...Soooo...I tweaked the blade and tapped the pin....no more blade rub.
4. Walk and Talk was excellent.

Purely as a user, it was quite an acceptable piece.

Finish was GREAT:
1. Excellent jigging, very nice scales.
2. Excellent blade finish....I wish others were this smooth and scratch free.
3. Grinds were superb....quite high for a traditional knife, and thinned out, making it a great slicer.
4. Knife was plenty sharp, with just a bit of burr on the main blade. 20 strokes on cardboard had her shaving sharp.

Used the knife around the house this last week....the 440 blades (stamped, as Codger mentioned, on the back of the tang) have held an edge quite well, and they've handled every chore (paper, thread, fruit) in fine fashion.

I think this is a very well done knife, with just a bit of room for improvement in the area of overall fit. A good deal, in my opinion, at this price point. Probably a street price around $40.00 or there abouts.

Bill

P.S.
If this should be moved to reviews....please do so.
I guess I was just tying in on a previous thread. No disrepect (Is that still a word when used properly?) meant to Schrade....living or otherwise.
 
textoothpk said:
Hey, does Larry know you are using his website? How do I do that???

Excellent, Codger. Well written as David's review was. Uhhhnmmm.. I'm sitting here as I type this with a 3OT on the desk. Seems much the same knife. That is not a knock on the product.

Just some questions: Cost? Did you order it from the website? How long did it take to recieve it? How would you rate it compared to a Case?

I guess we have kinda adopted Colonial here. I certainly don't have any objections.

I do like the looks of the trapper in the advertising photo.

Phil
Larry? Larry who? :D

I honestly do not have a 3OT to compare side by side. I will do so for the first schm...friend to send me one. Actually Phil, I have now done a photo comparison, and there are some marked visual design diferences. More so than you might see between other traditional patterns from popular makers. The 3OT is a four pin affair, and the 304 is a three pin. The actual shape of the rear of the handle of the 304 is more of a saddlehorn than the 3OT which is a different shape, and both the top and bottom lines of the 304 are more radiused. The blade differs a bit too. The nail nick on the 304, while positioned nearly the same, appears to be more generous. Some may like this and some may not. There is also a marked difference in the bolster shape. The 3OT is much more square looking, with a near vertical front face as compared to the longer, radiused 304. Enough diferences that I would never mistake one for the other. But you are right that dimensionally the two are the same, and if I were to do a comparison with a schrade and the 304, the 3OT would be the closest.

The MSRP on that particular knife, L-304B, is $69.99. I still like to buy my knives at 1982 prices, but we do live in the real world, so it is reasonable. The same type knife in cocobolo is $55.99.

I e-mailed for their pricelist and ad slicks, then followed directions on the included order form. This may have been an acomodation because there is not a dealer anywhere near me. I think the dealers are listed on the website.

I believe it was a week to ten days from go to get.

I was not sure of the proper way to review this knife here either El Lobo. That is why I posted it offsite, and just gave the link to the review and scan here. BTW, I obtained permission from one of the company principals to use the scan of their ad slick, so it is not pirated ;)

I think my example might be a tad bit above a comparable production Case. I guess another friend would have to send me one of those for me to do a side by side. I cannot see how it could be improved beyond what I spoke of in the review. I would think that a tiny bit more meticulous detailing would add appreciably to the visual and user enjoyment, but the knife overall suits me fine. I have seen a lot worse detail deviations on much more expensive knives.

Codger

P.S.: I do want to thank Larry for hosting the review on his dime! He did owe me for all the Schrades I caused...er...helped him buy in the last month or two :footinmou
 
Back
Top