Review of the H&B Forge Polled Axe

Joined
Jun 3, 2010
Messages
1,516
Review of the H&B Forge Polled Axe.

Sometimes I like to carry a tomahawk, polled axe, small forest axe or hatchet into the woods. A larger axe can do more but I can only carry so much kit and often my needs don't justify the extra weight. Here is a description of the polled axe from H&B's site.

Official site:

http://www.hbforge.com/

Medium Camp Axe
Like the boys hawk, this medium camp also has a 3.5 inch wide blade. The blade length is about 5.5 inch.

It uses our large, 19 inch tomahawk handle but the length is shortened to about 17 inches.

DETAILS:

The head weighs about 1 lb.
The overall weight with the 17 inch handle is about 1.5 lbs.
Our medium fancy camp sheath will fit this axe.

Description of the process and materials:

Workmanship on our hand forged tomahawks and other products is done completely by owner, Jarrod Barber, and is guaranteed for life. We use type 1095 steel in our hawk and axe bits, which runs down the center of the blade. tThat is wrapped with type 1018 steel. This is the same hand forging process used hundreds of years ago, ensuring the best -and most authentic- quality. All leather work is done by local Amish craftsmen. Our products are 100% American made!

The axe came with a working edge but the bevel was a bit uneven and needed work to get shaving sharp. Rarely do I find an edge that conforms to my person preference. Convexed the bevel a bit using 400 to 2000 grit sandpaper on a mouse pad. This isn't to say the tool didn't work just fine received.



The hammer end. Not much can be said beyond the flat area is large enough to work with. I prefer a hammer back to a spike.



The profile seems robust. Much like my Shawnee hawk which is commonly thrown in competitions. I really don't expect this axe to break. Speaking of breaking extra handles can be purchased from H&B for 5 dollars. I have a few extras for my Shawnee Throwing Tomahawk. They're made from Hickory and feel rather solid.



Sheaths can be purchased seperately. These hand made sheaths are thick and heavy. IMHO they're a good value .





It's a reasonably ok chopper and splits fairly well. I do think a purpose made axe like my Wetterlings does a better job at wood prep. This polled axe really shares much of the same profile as a hawk. That said it did a good enough job at enough things for me to feel it excelled as an overall tool and felt lighter but didn't compare it on my scale to the others. On a side note this review is open to future revision as for me it takes extensive use before a comprehensive review is possible. This is more of an initial impression review based on multiple outings plus some messing around with the tool.

Conclusion.

For the money this is a very good 100% made in the USA deal!

Here is a video of my review. Thanks for looking.

[video=youtube;P0HHnsQd150]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0HHnsQd150[/video]
 
I just picked up this same exact model today - I was about to purchase a Cold Steel after using my cousin's CS hawk during this past weekend's backpacking trip and I stopped in a store today and saw these for about $25 more (but with better steel, and a shorter handle). I know very little about axes/tomahawks - I thought any decent hawk was over $100 but so far, I'm impressed with this one. I don't have much in the way of wood, but it chopped a couple of pressure treated 2x4s in my garage and I'm taking it out tomorrow for some trail-testing.

I may end up drilling a hole through the handle towards the bottom and put a lanyard loop on it (or wrap it in leather for a slightly improved grip).

Thanks for the review - it sounds like I got a good little hawk.
 
I've had a Shawnee hawk since The Patriot came out. A year or two ago I got the large camp ax but eventually decided it was heavier than I wanted to carry. I gave it to my nephew for his 15th birthday and got myself the medi ax. I've not used it a lot yet but it seems about perfect for what I want. H and B have been nice folks to do business with too.
 
I've had a Shawnee hawk since The Patriot came out. A year or two ago I got the large camp ax but eventually decided it was heavier than I wanted to carry. I gave it to my nephew for his 15th birthday and got myself the medi ax. I've not used it a lot yet but it seems about perfect for what I want. H and B have been nice folks to do business with too.

Yea they are real nice people. Your nephew is lucky.

I just picked up this same exact model today - I was about to purchase a Cold Steel after using my cousin's CS hawk during this past weekend's backpacking trip and I stopped in a store today and saw these for about $25 more (but with better steel, and a shorter handle). I know very little about axes/tomahawks - I thought any decent hawk was over $100 but so far, I'm impressed with this one. I don't have much in the way of wood, but it chopped a couple of pressure treated 2x4s in my garage and I'm taking it out tomorrow for some trail-testing.

I may end up drilling a hole through the handle towards the bottom and put a lanyard loop on it (or wrap it in leather for a slightly improved grip).

Thanks for the review - it sounds like I got a good little hawk.

Cold steel isn't as bad as I might have sounded in my video. The dropped forged steel is ok and their heat treat acceptable based what I have seen and from owning one however for the price of a few drinks at a bar more the USA made hawk is IMHO better. I think you picked right.
 
Cold steel isn't as bad as I might have sounded in my video. The dropped forged steel is ok and their heat treat acceptable based what I have seen and from owning one however for the price of a few drinks at a bar more the USA made hawk is IMHO better. I think you picked right.

Haha - I hadn't even watched your video when I posted that - I thought the exact same thing when I was buying. No issues with Cold Steel, but when I can get a hand-crafted tool with way higher quality materials and way better fit/finish for only a few bucks more it's definitely worth it.
 
Any chance of an update after using your polled axe for roughly a year and a half now? I've really been wanting to try out this exact model. Thank you!
 
Back
Top