Riddick knives practical or not?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 1, 2019
Messages
9
Okay I'm sure this topic has been discussed before but are the Riddick knives practical. I have heard people say it's incredibly practical, however I've heard others say that they are not. So I'm just curious about your opinions.
 
These things?

KOjuGuJ.jpg


Well...

I don't see them being used in the kitchen, although I guess they could be made to work similar to a Ulu, if you felt like making things difficult.

As for using them to encourage other people to change their minds about a particular course of action? That discussion probably belongs in Practical/Tactical. But I've seen plenty of threads in there go off into the weeds, and get lost. There are just too many unpredictable (and rapidly moving) parts.

One of the few points that people seem to be able to agree on is that training is the most important thing. If you've spent a few hundred hours developing the necessary muscle memory, then you stand as good a chance as anybody of making it through a scenario.

Now. If you want, we can also take a few steps back, and ask "if I want to choose a dedicated self-defense knife (or bladed weapon of some kind), how do the Riddick knives compare to other choices?"

Personally, I figure there's a reason that historical knives and swords have the pointy bit sticking out the front. I would go with something like a Sgian Dubh (because my family is originally Scottish), but that's just a personal preference. There does seem to be some evidence that being able to stab or cut the other guy from farther away is a good idea, so I would say these are not that practical.
 
Well i guess you could use them to cut a choking child free from a seatbelt at Chick Fil A, but beyond being an Uber Karambit, I don't see much for them other than they look cool.

I mean, the DO look cool.
 
In the context of skinning a brontosaurus, yes, they're incredibly practical. You just hook in at the top of the neck and zipline down the length of the animal to open it from head to toe.

Outside of field dressing a long extinct dinosaur I don't see them being all that useful.
 
Any force not aligned perfectly in the plane of this knife will initiate a rotation, and because the edge is so far from the grip, it will work as a lever that multiplies the rotating force on the grip. I don't think this a practical knife.
 
Any force not aligned perfectly in the plane of this knife will initiate a rotation, and because the edge is so far from the grip, it will work as a lever that multiplies the rotating force on the grip. I don't think this a practical knife.

Ouch. Yeah, I didn't even begin to think about the ergonomics: jacked-up wrists for everybody!
 
They look like they might be good for making that little hole in the top of those 2.5 gallon water jugs...while standing over a kiddie pool.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top