Riveted vs screw-together Manix 2 LW?

CoolBreeze135

CoolBreeze135

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2014
Messages
414
I had a Manix 2 LW years ago and sold/traded it. I’ve really been missing it lately and am hoping to add one back to my EDC rotation in the near future.

I like to keep a pretty minimal inventory of folding knives, so I will probably only get just one of the variants and keep it as a user. I’m looking to snag one on the secondary market and I have the luxury of shopping around. Which brings me to my point: I’m seeing a mix of the older, riveted models and the newer, screw-together ones. I understand that the ability to take the knife apart for cleaning can be an advantage and I’m always a fan of being able to fix/maintain things yourself. But are there any real advantages in construction, use, and durability of one over the other?

I know that I found a few comments saying that the switch to screw-together construction was a huge improvement. I’m not disagreeing, but I also didn’t see much of an explanation.

So what are the pros/cons of the rivets vs screws in the Manix 2 LW? Is there something beyond the ability to clean it that I have missed? Figured it would be a good thing to think about before I acquired one.
 
While everyone of my older Manix 2 LWs (with pinned construction) are working flawlessly, I’d buy the newer screwed versions if I was in your position. Cleaning, modifying, adjustment options ,And the ability to add aftermarket scales(huge for me personally) are a major plus.
 
The only advantage to screw construction is the ability to f___ up your knife without a drill. Screw assembly speeds up manufacturing, it is not done to make it easier for end users to take apart. But people are people, so they think threaded fasteners mean they're supposed to take it apart.
 
yablanowitz said:
The only advantage to screw construction is the ability to f___ up your knife without a drill. Screw assembly speeds up manufacturing, it is not done to make it easier for end users to take apart. But people are people, so they think threaded fasteners mean they're supposed to take it apart.
Click to expand...
That's rubbish. Some people want to be able to make modifications or clean their knife in case of mishaps. Yes, it also allows some people to "f up their knife" but I would buy the Manix with a screwed together construction. I won't buy a riveted one.
 
CoolBreeze135 said:
I had a Manix 2 LW years ago and sold/traded it. I’ve really been missing it lately and am hoping to add one back to my EDC rotation in the near future.

I like to keep a pretty minimal inventory of folding knives, so I will probably only get just one of the variants and keep it as a user. I’m looking to snag one on the secondary market and I have the luxury of shopping around. Which brings me to my point: I’m seeing a mix of the older, riveted models and the newer, screw-together ones. I understand that the ability to take the knife apart for cleaning can be an advantage and I’m always a fan of being able to fix/maintain things yourself. But are there any real advantages in construction, use, and durability of one over the other?

I know that I found a few comments saying that the switch to screw-together construction was a huge improvement. I’m not disagreeing, but I also didn’t see much of an explanation.

So what are the pros/cons of the rivets vs screws in the Manix 2 LW? Is there something beyond the ability to clean it that I have missed? Figured it would be a good thing to think about before I acquired one.
Click to expand...
I’d buy the pinned version. Screws can come out, I had that happen with a Spyderco Lum and a CRK Ti-lock. Never had that problem with pins. Never needed to take apart a pinned knife and wished it was screwed. Never had a pinned knife that needed an adjustment, but my new screwed Spyderco Starmate needed a pivot and handle screw adjustment and loktite to keep the blade from moving over and rubbing. I was at a flea market and bought my 12yo girl a first generation Endura, that had been abused, tip and integral pocket clip were long gone, but the knife was still tight and locked up strong. Still is after ~30 years of use.
 
Last edited:
Well, looks like about 50/50 right now. Haha. I suppose that doesn’t settle the debate for me!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top