Saw usage in OH SAKs

[Orozcov]

While using the wood saw in my old-style Victorinox Fireman, I was wondering if the "hump" present in the one-hand opening models makes it difficult to have a firm and comfortable grip while using the saw.

I don't see a problem with a "static grip" (I mean, not actually using the saw), but maybe the protruding hump becomes a problem when applying force on actual usage.

How do you use the saw in your OH SAKs? do you place your index on the hump or next to it?

I´m pondering the acquisition of a Vic new Soldier as a back-up to the Fireman (one for hiking around, the other one to the BOB), but your feedback on this issue might change my idea (or not).

Best regards.


Jaime Orozco.

 

[chipped]

I haven't used my OHT's saw extensively, but I had no problem. I kinda put the hump between my index and middle finger. I figure if you're really sawing enough on a regular basis than it'd be a problem you need a real saw or dedicated folding saw.

I like mine plenty, but it's a bit heavy for EDC with no clip. I like the serration pattern.

I'd say get the Farmer and a dedicated one-handed knife.

 

[Harayasu]

I have a new Soldier and although I haven't used the saw for longer times, I didn't like that hump when using the saw for even a short time, although the saw itself works very well. With that hump, it just doesn't feel very comfortable for me. Perhaps you could back up your Fireman with an Outrider?

 

[Orozcov]

Thanks for your feedback guys, it seems the opinions are 1 - 1 up to now.

Just to clarify: I don't do extensive sawing and I know that a real saw outperforms any SAK, I just want to know if the wood saw on the one-hand openers is akward to use due the blade hump. I also find myself in environments where a fixed blade, axe or saw are not suitable, easy to carry or even allowed, while a SAK (even a "big" one) is more likely to be at hand.

I assume that the Victorinox designers tried to make the one handers as ergonomically correct as possible, but anyway there's nothing better than feedback coming from actual users.

Regards.


Jaime Orozco.

 

[cdf]

I have a GAK and a new Soldier , I find the saw to be very comfortabe .

Chris