Scotch... a story of exploration

Joined
Feb 1, 2009
Messages
604
I am a big scotch fan. Up until now I have only explored the single malts. So far I would have to say that my favorite everyday sipper is the 16 year old Lagavulin, with an 18 year old Talisker coming in close second.

I got a sweet new job recently with great pay, so I decided to treat myself to a more expensive bottle. I wandered around the liquor store, but couldn't find the top shelf selections I was looking for. I must have walked around the store 5 times, thinking where the hell is the good stuff?!?

I made my way to the front and proceeded to ask for assistance. After a 10 minute wait, a man emerged from the back and took me through a door in the back storage area.

We were now in the back conference room which was in fact quite large, where a high end scotch tasting was just winding down. There they were... All kinds of single malt Scotches ranging in Price from $200 - $11,000!! I was dumbfounded. I couldn't believe how much money worth of alcohol was surrounding me.


I made my way to a seat, and was given a menu so to speak, of what was available for tasting. On that list, were some of the finest scotches, cognacs, armagnacs, and brandies.

Every sip had a small tasting fee attached to it. I ended up spending about $200 on tastes. I tried some pretty rare vintages that evening. Some that were so rare in fact, that they were sold in 45ml, labeled test tubes. I wanted to buy a few of those, as they were so damned delicious, but I found it hard to justify spending $100 on 45ml (1.5oz). Much of the higher end stuff was in fact tasted with an eye dropper! Its amazing how many different tastes you can have before you get hammered if you only have a tiny bit of each. The most we'd get for any one taste was a few mils (just enough for 2 or 3 small sips, at most, though often less)

After some time, I stumbled across one that seemed to glow in a way that just called to me. Perhaps it was the color, perhaps it was the lighting... whatever it was, there was definitely something magnetic about this particular bottle.

"It was crafted in 1965, and bottled in 2005".

There were quite a few aged samples, some as old as 65 years! But this one... There was something un-nameable about this particular bottle of amber coloured liquid. It was made 18 years before I was born! (I was born in 1983, am now 26)

"The price-tag comes in at a reasonable $280 (CAD)"

As he was pouring it, I could smell the aroma filling the room. The taste, wow, just freakin wow! I have never tasted such a complex scotch before. There were so many layers it was incredible. All very distinct, yet all working harmoniously together creating the final flavour profile. There was a really nice heat in the mouth as the scotch made its way around my taste buds. There is a saying on one of the Islay Malts, (I think its the Lagavulin): "'Time' say the islanders 'takes out the fire, but leaves in the warmth'"

I didnt really get it until now.

Here are the Tasters notes from the Bottle:

Clan Denny:
Great Single Grain
-- OLD --​

The initial nose is herbal, fragrant and cleansing before revealing notes of pine needles and cedar wood. The full, rounded body leads to a palate which is surprisingly fresh and attractively spiced; bursting with red fruit compote and cream, yet also reminiscent of a stroll through a whisky warehouse! The finish is simply smooth, short and sweet.

That about says it : )

By the time I decided on a bottle and paid for it, I was still only half drunk. Fortunately I was also only half an hour walk from home... so I decided to hit up the walk in Humidor, which housed countless brands of cigars from all over the world. The Guy who seemed to be running the thing told me to pick any one I want, and he will give it to me for half price. So I took the Cohiba Siglo VI, and we ventured outside into the back area where there is a nice table and chairs set up like a lounge. It was made specifically for the smoking of cigars.

I was about to open my bottle of newly acquired Clan Denny, when the guy suggested I try some more samples. For $100 he said he could assemble 8 premium samples at 1/4 oz each. They were all phenomenal, but well beyond my pricerange. After those were good and done, I switched to a 25 year old Talisker to finish off the night.

What an evening. That was the most amazing tasting I have ever been too.

I know this is not a knife post, but there seems to be a lot of people who appreciate liquor in here, so I figured I would share my experience :D

(Just a quick question for all you JW Blue drinkers: I have never tried a blended scotch, not due to any particular aversion, but because all the tastings I have been to have been about Single Malts. How would you rate it along-side the single malts in that pricerange?)

So I hope you enjoyed my story, as I sure did :) That Clan Denny is going down just right ;)
 
Last edited:
I, for one, really enjoyed your story and I thank you for sharing it. Can I ask where are you from? Toronto maybe?
 
I liked that story a lot - I enjoy scotch but can rarely justify any of the good stuff. An 18 or 20 year old single malt is a treat to me - can't imagine how nice that stuff must have been :eek:
 
I enjoyed your story alot. My friend and i have been into single malts for about 5 years now... We have kind of settled on Bowmore. I wish I could find a place like you described. It sounds fantastic. Thanks for sharing.
 
What a great story. Sounds like you found a fantastic scotch. As for JWB, It's a good blend but I prefer the Chivas 21 Royal Salute.
 
Thanks for the read. I love a good Scotch and Lagavulin is one of my favorites. I tried finding that Scotch Clan Denny that you mentioned but have had a bit of trouble. Could you PM me the name of the liquor store you got it from?

May have found it here: http://www.wineandwhisky.co.uk/whisky/info_WHI02240.html


Also this must be some liquor store as I doubt the ones around me have such an area to do that kind of tasting. I wish I could do a tasting of some of the finer scotches as I am left to just buy and try right now.
 
I was not really a fan of Scotch until earlier this year when I went to dinner with a partner and a client in London. The clinet ordered some Bowmore 21, and that was a lot better than the other scotches I had tried in the past.

On the way home I found a Scotch speacialty shop in the duty free area in Heathrow, so tasted a few different single malts and brougt home a Lagavulin. I have been back to the UK a few times since then, and always bring back a different bottle. Thankfully, many of the duty frees (at least in the UK) have some out for tasting, so I can find something l like.

Last weekend I was in Nova Scotia visiting my family, and stopped in the NSLC (liquor commission) and was shocked at the selection of Scotches they have compared to the one in the State store here in PA. I only had a small bag since it was a short trip, but next time (hopefully September) I go back I will be taking a larger suitcase so I can get a couple of bottles to bring back.
 
Thanks for the read. I love a good Scotch and Lagavulin is one of my favorites. I tried finding that Scotch Clan Denny that you mentioned but have had a bit of trouble. Could you PM me the name of the liquor store you got it from?

May have found it here: http://www.wineandwhisky.co.uk/whisky/info_WHI02240.html


Also this must be some liquor store as I doubt the ones around me have such an area to do that kind of tasting. I wish I could do a tasting of some of the finer scotches as I am left to just buy and try right now.

96 pounds! :eek: thats only $180 canadian!!! Damn, I ended up paying $280 for the 40 year old. Well, thats Canadian Liquor Taxes for ya. :thumbdn:

I bought it at a standard BC (government) liquor store.
 
Sounds like a great liquor store :) .

ummm Scotch. Wiki Scotch

I must confess that most if not all my favorites come from the Speyside region, all ventures to try others (more specifically Islay region malts) have resulted in disaterous bottles that tasted like fermeted malt and gym socks, first bottle i ever dumped out instead of finishing.

I found the wiki article to actually be informative, I think it's a good read for wiskey drinkers who profess to love scotch.
 
Sounds like a great liquor store :) .

ummm Scotch. Wiki Scotch

I must confess that most if not all my favorites come from the Speyside region, all ventures to try others (more specifically Islay region malts) have resulted in disaterous bottles that tasted like fermeted malt and gym socks, first bottle i ever dumped out instead of finishing.

I found the wiki article to actually be informative, I think it's a good read for wiskey drinkers who profess to love scotch.

I like Speysides as well. I am not as big of fan of Highlands. LUCKILY my father loves scotch as well and his taste is the opposite of mine. So when I buy something and i dont like it....he most assuradly will. So we somewhat trade scotches from time to time and he has friends who do "passarounds" of flasks so we all get to try new things. Its a great practice and I have bought alot of Tequila and Scotch I would have never thought too this way.
 
So it turns out that the 1963 is only $180 at the liquor store I bought the 1965 at... for a moment I felt like I got overcharged.

What factors could cause the 1965 to be near $100 more than one that is 2 years older?

Thanks :)
 
Last edited:
Great story, I love single malts and tend to move from one taste to another just for the experience. The blended Scotch is for nites when it just doesn't matter or for friends who don't know or care about the differences.
 
Then how does one justify spending near $250CAD for a bottle of JW Blue? Clearly there are lots of people who enjoy it and I am wondering if it is worth its price-tag compared to a single malt at the same price?

I have heard that a single malt is harder to get a good flavour out of due to being dependent on one batch which is why it is the more expensive of the two; whereas a blend is easier to get a good flavour because you have more room to play with it. With that reasoning, a $250 blend should be better (by whose standards I wonder ;)) that a $250 single malt. I think I'll just have to buy a bottle and see for myself.

For those that like it, why? For those that dont, why? For those that haven't tried it, want to?

:)
 
Last edited:
Thank you for the great story! As a scotch lover, I have been blessed by my Hog brethren and tasted some fine single malts, as well as a few sophisticated blends. I won't comment on JWB versus an equally-priced single malt except to say that my enjoyment of the JWB undoubtedly was influenced by the company I was keeping! ;)
 
Ballantine's has a few higher end blends. A single malt can have a much more unique and distinctive flavor than a blend, especially since it is not competing with all the other whisky it is mixed with.
 
Back
Top