• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.

  • Today marks the 24th anniversary of 9/11. I pray that this nation does not forget the loss of lives from this horrible event. Yesterday conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was murdered, and I worry about what is to come. Please love one another and your family in these trying times - Spark

Scrape on knee proves fatal!

Joined
Jun 24, 2008
Messages
2,433
I've posted this in the hope that it may help others.

A Baytown man has died from illness caused by exposure to a rare pathogen often referred to as flesh-eating bacteria.

Thomas Jesse Shurley, 52, died Tuesday night of multiple organ failure following a three-week battle against the infection. He had suffered a scrape on his knee while fishing in Galveston Bay on July 26, family members said. The bacteria, most often encountered in seawater, rapidly spread throughout his body, and even the amputation of his leg could not stop it.

“It's really a shock to the entire family,” said his daughter, Shaunte Angelo. “He was young and full of life. We never saw this coming.”

The incident occurred when Shurley was fishing alone close to shore in a small jon boat. The boat tipped over and he scraped his left knee while righting it. Shurley felt sick the next day but thought little of it. By Tuesday evening, his knee was so swollen and he felt so bad that friends took him to Baytown Methodist Hospital, fearing he had broken it.

“The doctors ran some tests and figured out what it was,” Angelo said. “They asked him if he wanted to lose his leg or his life. Of course, he chose his leg.”

The next day Shurley was taken by Life Flight to St. Luke's Episcopal Hospital in the Texas Medical Center. He was placed on a ventilator and never regained full consciousness, his daughter said. Infected tissue was surgically removed, and later most of his leg. But there was little hope once the infection spread through his blood and most of his organs, she said.

He was taken off life support at 6:30 p.m. Tuesday and died about five hours later.

“If he had gone to the hospital Monday morning, the day after he hurt his knee, he might have been fine,” Angelo said. “But who would have thought to do that for a scrape?”

The medical name for Shurley's illness is necrotizing fasciitis. It is caused by several kinds of bacteria, the most common of which is Streptococcus pyogenes, the same thing that causes strep throat and impetigo. Another bacterium sometimes involved — as in Shurley's case — is Vibrio vulnificus.

Such infections, often mild, can become life-threatening for people with underlying medical conditions such as diabetes or hepatitis. Shurley suffered from hepatitis C, Angelo said.

Shurley was a sales manager at Gyro Chemical and Equipment Company in Deer Park, which specializes in industrial cleaning supplies.
 
Wow as a child I lived played and got scraped up on a regular basis on that coast and area (many, many moons ago) just lucky I guess.
 
I've taken care of about a dozen cases of necrotizing fasciitis - luckily all but one have survived (the one death was 99 years old, and decided she didn't want aggressive surgery, was placed on a morphine drip and died 3 days later). Most are treated by very aggressive surgical debridement, broad-spectrum antibiotics, and most have required a couple days in the ICU.
 
Saw a girl jump in a fountain in San Jose CA.

The next morning they had to give her the paddles twice and she lost a pound of flesh.

She lived though.
 
F.E.B. is one of the reasons I am glad to live in the mountains and not on the coast anymore...so far it hasn't adapted to the colder waters of the streams we go swimming in.
 
Perhaps someone will explain the point to you......

Though you may not understand it!

Well, it was a freak occurrence, was very unfortunate, but it could have happened to anyone, under the right/wrong circumstance. :( Are you saying he should have never gone fishing in that area, or am I missing your point? He went to the doctor as soon as possible. So when you say to Ray that he missed the point, what was it? Is it to be careful, or to not fish in that area, or to stay inside where it is safe?
 
This serves to point out that we are mortal and that with all the medical knowledge we have gained in the last two hundred years, there are still things that doctors can't fix that can cause hideous deaths. That can be even more disheartening if you're the kind of person that lives in condition white.
 
so why do you not take care of even a minor break of the skin allowing pathogens to enter?
as a Fisherman/Hunter/ Traveler I keep a 1/8oz. bottle of 10% Iodine in my pocket for just that reason.
Immediate Care!
 
We will all die. There's nothing wrong with death.

Perhaps someone will explain the point to you......

Though you may not understand it!

Well, it was a freak occurrence, was very unfortunate, but it could have happened to anyone, under the right/wrong circumstance. :( Are you saying he should have never gone fishing in that area, or am I missing your point? He went to the doctor as soon as possible. So when you say to Ray that he missed the point, what was it? Is it to be careful, or to not fish in that area, or to stay inside where it is safe?

Wilderness & Survival Skills All aspects of survival skills, technique, environment and gear are open for discussion. Learn, teach and share...

Given this Section Title and Objective (above) and the fact that I began my post with the following statement:

I've posted this in the hope that it may help others.

I believe that Rays post is entirely inappropriate and frankly idiotic, as this is about survival skills, not that "We will all die. There's nothing wrong with death."

It beggars belief that an adult would make such a statement, on this Forum!

And yes, you too have missed the point, which was my original statement:

I've posted this in the hope that it may help others.
 
Darwin test ..you first..We are All Born to Die but you fight as much as you can not to go easily
 
F.E.B. is one of the reasons I am glad to live in the mountains and not on the coast anymore...so far it hasn't adapted to the colder waters of the streams we go swimming in.

naw up here we just have giardia, cryptosporidium, hand food and mouth disease, and all those other cow borne pathogens... oh, and starving mountain lions and overpopulated wolves that will eat anything that looks like it is made of flesh. I'm about to hop in the shower and comb myself from head to toe looking for any festering cuts, weird looking rashes, bites or ticks. Fact of the matter is there's a certain level of hygiene you need to meet before and after spending time outdoors, and alot of things can be caught early and save you alot of pain.
 
This actually isn't a rare occurance for this area... My sister is a nurse at UTMB Galveston and has taken care of several such cases, almost all came from the Baytown/Galveston Bay area . I just stay out of the water even at the beach here.
 
AeroNautiCal, I apologize to you. My comment was out of place and has nothing to do with your thread. I didn't sleep last night and I had my mind somewhere else when I wrote that.
 
This serves to point out that we are mortal and that with all the medical knowledge we have gained in the last two hundred years, there are still things that doctors can't fix that can cause hideous deaths. That can be even more disheartening if you're the kind of person that lives in condition white.
That's perfectly true I know personally at least three persons that got problems no doctor was able to diagnose. IOne of them even consulted with international level specialist without much result, he was asked to sign forms so his file and samples could be used for medical research.
Also had an aunt that went skeptic on a very mundane infection.

Fortunately all of them went through or had symptoms naturally decrease, yet it is always a surprise when you realize, despite many great achievements, how limited our modern medicine still is on certain subjects.
 
F.E.B. is serious. What's even more serious, is that it doesn't take much of a break in the skin, to let it enter the body, if it is in the environment.
Mind you, who of us haven't had a scrape on the knee, cut on the hand, whatever, and not gone to see a doctor about it, and haven't gotten sick? My guess would be something like 80-90%. And we still live.
Though he, the man who died, did overlook a serious sign. He felt sick the next day.
If he had listened to the signs his body gave him, he might've survived.

I see it in my own family. The reluctance to go see a doctor, even if they do feel sick.
The belief that "things will get better on its own", while valid in some instances, is not always a good idea.
Education, i believe, is key. If he had known that seawater could harbor dangerous bacteria, i think he might've gone to see the doctor, atleast the next day.

Just my two cents.
 
Back
Top