I'll start by saying that I am no expert. I do have great success with the Sharpmaker and a strop though. I have also been through what you describe. When I hear someone say that they can't get their knife sharp, I immediately think 'they are not getting the very edge of the secondary bevel'.
I am not too familiar with the Edge Pro, but use the Sharpmaker regularly. I would suggest taking a couple of VERY slow passes like you normally would. This time though, look directly down, or parallel to the rod. You may see that you have the entire edge contacting the rod until you get to the tip of the blade. You may only be getting the corner of the rod with the tip. With the SM, when you get to the tip, you need to angle the handle away from the rod slightly to get the tip flat on the rod like you would the rest of the blade. If this doesn't work, I would say to either increase the angle you are sharpening when you get towards the tip, or maybe reprofile (dangerous) the tip a bit to get the angle consistent.
One thing to remember is that CRK sharpens by hand and there can be minor variations in the angle of the bevel.
I can't stress enough to get the very edge of the bevel. While I do not focus on drawing a burr, I believe that this is why drawing a burr is stressed. It is a surefire way to ensure that you have made it to the very edge.
I sharpen at 20 degrees on the SM and I find that it provides a super sharp edge that holds. It also does not mess with the CRK convex edge as I only get the very edge of the bevel.
Once you get it figured out, it really only takes just a few swipes every so often to keep the edge sharp. I can get mine shaving again in just a minute or two.