Sharpening Japanese Cutlery

Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
3,018
I just want to look before I leap in buying my wife a Hattori Santoku. How does one sharpen and maintain these types of knives? Reading on some forums, it seems like a sharpening steel should never touch these blades due to the very acute angle of the blade and the steel's hardness. Does this sound right? Also, when it comes time to actually sharpen the blade, does one need Japanese waterstones, or can you get away with more traditional stones (although I'm guessing my Arkansas won't get anywhere with a Rc 60 blade). Thanks again for the help.
 
Take this with a grain of salt:

I've got Shun's Elite Chef's knife and Santoku in clad SG-2 steel at Rc 64. Shun's web site claims a 16 degree bevel (32 inclusive), and I have no reason to doubt the claim. Finicky sharpener that I am, both knives now have my own fully blended convex bevel, starting flush with the main body of the blade, and ending with about 16 degrees at the edge. Both knives easily chop 3" fine hanging hairs and will continue to do so after light use. After heavier use on the cutterboard, they still easily shave arm hairs. For sharpening, there are really 2 tasks: establishing the bevel, and then maintaining the bevel.

The first is worlds more difficult because of the extremely shallow angles as you approach the blade body. My technique was to mask the blade 1/4" back from the edge with thin clear plastic packaging tape, taking care that there were no folds or creases. I used HF's belt sander with a 320x 3M mylar belt to establish multiple step bevels, then smoothed them into a continuous convex bevel with Norton's 1000 grit waterstone. At such shallow angles, it's easy to grind a swale or recurve with the sander. The waterstone helps with the control. An all waterstone job (Norton 220/1000/4000/8000) shouldn't be that much more work, and should give terrific control. Finish with a strop charged with 1/2 u diamond paste, and you should get some seriously sharp cutlery.

The beauty of this type of edge is that maintenance is a snap. A couple of passes on a worn 9 u belt, finishing with a strop, takes a lightly worn edge back to original shape. Waterstones and a manual strop should work nearly as well.

If a belt sander or waterstones aren't to your liking, I'd suggest diamond hones. On everything else you might try, my experience is too limited to offer an opinion.

Oh, BTW: I wouldn't let even a glass-smooth polished steel near my Shuns ... or your Hattori.
 
I agree except for the use of glass smooth steels on Japanese knives. I have both 15" Hand American models, steel and borosilicate. They don't damage the edge that I can tell using a 30 power loupe.

Buzz
 
Whatever you use you will want to tape the sides so you don't scratch the Damascus cladding if this is the HD. :eek:
Nice knife BTW...

Good luck!
 
My Hattori HD Santoku has yet to be sharpened. It retains an excellent edge. I've touched it up on a strop and the triangle sharpmaker, both work very well.
There's a kitchen section with lots of knowledgable folks at knifeforums. But really, a leather belt and some Fitz will keep it in tip top shape.
 
Wow, thanks for the help everyone. LedSled, I envy your sharpening skills, but I don't think I can afford the knife and all of the waterstones at once. You should open a sharpening business! Mr. Clean, your post made me feel more comfortable. What grade of paste do you use on the strop? How long have you had that knife?
 
A strop will work for quite a while, then eventually you will have to re-sharpen. It's no big deal, just keep the original angles.
I would also recommend against steeling very hard edges--the pressure can be immense and chipping becomes more likely.
Greg
 
Back
Top