Sharpening

[jeuban]

Hello, I have a sharpener question. I am a total newbie when it comes to sharpening knives. I want to get into maintaining my own blades. What kind/type of sharpening system will give me results without breaking the bank? I have found a few at:
http://www.amazon.com/Smiths-50008-8-Inch-Diamond-Tri-Hone/dp/B001I6JGL4/ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top
and
http://www.amazon.com/Spyderco-Tri-...384049722&sr=8-2&keywords=spyderco+sharpmaker
or another option?

I have a trusty Sog pocket knife that I love, but I was cutting a few boxes up with it and now it will not even cut paper. Which option is best for someone who has never sharpened before? Also I have seen where the spyderco does not re profile blades very well, so would the smiths be better? Or should I look at DMT?

 

[billygoat162]

I'm a fan of the Spyderco Sharpmaker. To reprofile blades or bring one back that is really dull, I just wrap the ceramic rods with 320 grit sandpaper. If they are really bad, I start out freehand on a whetstone or diamond sharpener. I think that being able to sharpen a knife freehand is a great skill that every serious knife owner should at least try to learn, but it's best to practice with cheap knives because you will probably mess up a few edges at first. The Sharpmaker is terrific for getting a razor edge with consistent angles. The ultra-fine rods that you can buy separately really give an edge a mirror finish.

 

[fetzer85]

Welcome to BF! I have 2 respectful suggestions for you:

First, we're only supposed to post links to websites if they are an authorized dealer here on BF, which Amazon is not. I know you're new here and didn't know, but now you do.

Second, visit the maintenance, tinkering & embellishment subforum and you'll find a TON of great reading about sharpening for beginners...I mean hours upon hours. :thumbup:

And again, welcome to BF, look forward to having you around.

 

[Portman30-06]

I would definitely go with the stones. Every knife owner should have a set and be able to successfully use them. However I personally would not go diamond to start. Smith's has a regular tri-hone that is 1/4 the price and is just as good. 2 Arkansas stones and 1 Aluminum oxide if I'm correct.