Hey Guys....
Yaaaa a 4" SJ.. Ok lets start a list of names started...

Get your pen and paper out Jerry..
As far as the pull the dot snaps go..
Yes they have a definate place in the sheathing world,,as does the G-clip ,J-clip, closed loop, H-loop, Tek-Lok and a multitude of other devices and ways of fastening sheaths to your body....
A static line on a nicely made sheath works well also,, but all of these have their place and time...
On a big knife like a BM-E, SH-E , even the NO-E I prefer to use a closed belt loop.. It gives a level of security that you can't get with anything else.. Simple, effective and not much to break,,not to mention Low profile and No bulk...
The body of the sheath is whats important.. Structural stability,design, fit, looks/style and function all should be incorporated into a good sheath..
The way it is attached is a Very personal thing..
Lots of people like and use the large TEKs.. I personally think they are one of the biggest improvements to manknind in the sheathing Biz,, but I don't personally use them. The added cost is prohibitive that being only one reason...
Will I put them on my clients sheaths...?
Sure I do...
I use clips on my personal blades that I have designed that I don't offer to the public,,because they are specialty clips that are untested in mass and I know their limitations.. This is what is comfortable to me, but maynot be to others...
I think the pull the dot straps are slick, under the right conditions and Definately with the right blade.. They work Very good for Highly decreet concealed carry,,but not for EDC.. I'll take a G-clip over them most any time...
I use the G-clip because it is a tried and true method and have had Very few break.. (Except when Owen gets ahold of them)

LOL I'm just gonna send Owen a sheet and let him make his own..
The point I'm trying to make is use what you Trust and feel comfortable with be it G-clips ,pull the dots or Tek.. All Great methods of fixing sheaths to your body!! Hey duct tape works as well but it hurts like hell to take off..
ttyle
Eric....