Sheaths: Leather vs. Cordura

Joined
Feb 5, 2005
Messages
857
Do you prefer a leather sheath or a Cordura (or some other artificial material) sheath?

Personally, I like the look of leather, and I've never managed to wear out a leather sheath, but I admit I don't work in a rough environment so none of my sheaths see a lot of wear and tear.
 
If choosing between those 2, I'll take leather. Cordura can fray and, hypothetically, the blade inside the sheath could make micro-cuts in the nylon, weakening the structure. Since leather is not multi-stranded like cordura, it's not subject to that weakness. Note that most all cordura sheaths made today have a kydex liner inside...

I do like leather for sheaths, but, if given a choice, I'll take a well-made kydex sheath. In a hard-use field knife, I think the ideal would be a form-fitted, kydex-lined leather sheath. it would be puncture resistant, have a solid shape and structure, not be as subject to heat warping as plain kydex (sitting around a campfire, anyone?), and not hold in moisture next to the blade, due to the kydex... that's my ultimate sheath :)
 
I prefer a good leather sheath over the other materials. Cordura sheaths I through away Kydex scratches the blades. I send my knives to Kenny Rowe for sheaths and never have a problum , it's te only way to go for me.
 
I'd put in the vote for leather, but I'm just a little biased :o The leather/kydex sandwich is a great way to get the stiffness of kydex with the look of leather. :)
 
Well done leather is great ,and will last a lifetime with proper maintenance . Nylon is cheap and good around wet envireoments . Dito kydex . Each has it's applications .

Chris
 
Hey Guys...

Different materials for different jobs...

Obviously I really like synthetics such as Concealex, and use it nearly Exclusively .. I have a couple really nice knives that are in leather, anything else wouldn't do them justice..

However I find for the majority of my knives Concealex fits the bill.All of my knives are work knives, the knives I take into the field all get used, so any scratching they may get is more likely to be from use, then being drawn in and out of the sheath.

Trout Tamer,, not sure what you mean here :

"not be as subject to heat warping as plain kydex (sitting around a campfire, anyone?), and not hold in moisture next to the blade, due to the kydex... that's my ultimate sheath"

I haven't had a sheath yet that I've taken care of, warp due to heat. Sitting around the campfire should make no difference to a kydex sheath. You'll feel the heat on your leg far before the kydex will start to warp..
If you don't I suggest, you more your lawn chair back a few feet..:)

Also not sure what you mean by moisture in kydex ?? :)

Each of the sheathing materials listed above have their place and time in the knife world. Not one will do each job 100% of the time. Each have their strengths and weaknesses, and all will fail at some point in time, or if pushed pasts it's optimal use. There is nothing yet to date that will fit the bill all of t6he time for every purpose.

The job the consumer has is to make an educated choice, or better yet, have multiple sheaths for different uses..Get some quality made stuff,, and I assure you,, you'll see and notice the difference in how each material works and has it's place, as an important part of your knife.

ttyle

Eric....
 
If I had to have something close to indestructible I'd go with kydex. Fortunately, I don't, so I prefer leather. I'm a big Kenny Rowe fan as well, and it looks like Dwayne (leatherman) does nice work, too.

Jack
 
Sitting around the campfire should make no difference to a kydex sheath. You'll feel the heat on your leg far before the kydex will start to warp..
Normark, that was the one major caveat I've had with kydex; it's good to know that shouldn't be a problem with kydex in the field. I know that it becomes moldable around 350*F, but my leg definitely would start to feel the heat well before that point... ;) Thanks for the info. Also, what I meant about kydex and moisture is that kydex won't soak up moisture as leather does, so in-sheath rusting is greatly reduced by the use of a kydex sheath.
 
Leather does look nice, but I think kydex and its variants are superior in every other respect (durability, protection, corrosion resistance, weight, retention, presentation, etc.). I have acquired or made kydex sheaths for all my knives, even the ones that came with nice leather.

--Bob Q
 
It's definitely a matter of personal choice and kydex is probably, by most standards, a superior sheath material. Just like G10 is superior to wood as a handle material. But, while I appreciate G10, I love buckeye burl. :D

Jack
 
I like cordura/kydex for my knives. Dries quicker when wet. Lighter. Tougher overall, IMO.
 
Back
Top