Sheffield Barlow, Clayton Barlow, or Ergonomic Barlow? What's the difference?

Joined
Oct 14, 1998
Messages
4,725
I am looking at Sheffield-made knives from afar so, Google has been a bit mixed.

I am familiar with the Barlow pattern generally but, what makes the Clayton and Ergonomic what they are? From questionable pictures, the Clayton sort of looks like the mid-point between a traditional Barlow and the Ergonomic Barlow.

What makes each pattern unique? Any specific recommendations about one being better or worse than another? Or put another way, if you were buying a user-grade slip-joint in a Barlow pattern, which would you get and why?

To focus things a little, I am looking to spend ~$100US~$150US for a Lambsfoot knife that has a ~9CM stainless blade. So far, Michael May from Sheffield seems to be the leading knifemaker in my quest but, I am not committed at this point. Communication with him has been a bit problematic via email but, I'm not too critical as he is a knifemaker and not a marketing specialist!

TIA,
Sid
 
Last edited:
https://michaelmayknives.com/product/clayton-barlow-pocket-knife-yorkshire-oak/

https://michaelmayknives.com/product/ergonomic-cherry/

9Zx8Z62.jpg
 
The defining characteristics of a barlow is the long bolster and teardrop shape handle. These might be fine pocket knives, but they don't look like barlow's to me.
 
Yep, part of my reason for asking in the first place. I am trying to understand the differences and I was hoping to have someone familiar with British knives join the discussion.
 
Barlow
0zOub3R.jpg

Barlow
UZ9pr29.jpg

Barlow
ZSyyWQU.jpg

Barlow
dXILAEx.jpg

Barlow
NcusdTM.jpg

Barlow
EzLCtEl.jpg

Not barlow....
9Zx8Z62.jpg

See the difference?
It has nothing to do with English knife makers other than that particular knife being made by somebody in England. Barlows have been made in many places by many different manufacturers.
This one...... never seen a swayback barlow, and the blade doesn't seem to fit the handle either....
Michael-May-Clayton-Yorkshire-Oak-2.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Yes, that last one does look a bit odd to me in general. It was the one that I think is the Clayton "Barlow".
 
Back
Top