Sirupati vs. GS

Svashtar

Svashtar

Joined
Dec 28, 2003
Messages
4,793
I'm having a hell of a time telling these two apart on the HI site. I'm obviously not experienced enough to tell the subtle differences between the two. Text says the Sirupati is about 3/8" across the spine while the GS is about a 16th more, but other than that they look pretty much the same.

Any input is appreciated.

Regards,

Svashtar
 
the GS has one deep wide fuller that runs the length of it. Lightens it a bit. The single fuller reminds me of those you see on Civil War Cavalry sabers. The GS has a simple line for the sword of Shiva.

The Siru has no fuller, and a fancier Sword of Shiva.
 
Got it! Thanks for the explanation. It's a nice blade, but the one that really makes my mouth water is the Ganga Ram. I just love those big fat ones! :)

Regards,

Svashtar
 
Originally posted by Svashtar
but the one that really makes my mouth water is the Ganga Ram. I just love those big fat ones! :)

Svashtar
Click to expand...

Svashtar the BGRS or 18" GR is one of the best all around khuks there is, bar none!!!! Personally I had rather carry my BGRS for general purpose work rather than my famous 18" AK.:D
 
I think the gelbu special is an improved sirupati.
It is definitely a weapon.
I will never lust for another khukuri with the same passion now that I have my Gelbu special 18".
The enclosed cho with the little lip allows one to use a two handed grip if one desires and the blade moves with a martial grace.
 
Originally posted by DannyinJapan
I will never lust for another khukuri with the same passion now that I have my Gelbu special 18".
Click to expand...

Bwhahahahaha!!!!! LMRRAOPIPAICGU!!!! Famous last words yet again, means we've seen 'em more than once before.:rolleyes: :p :D :D ;)
 
The Siru and the GS are (IMO) the best combo of weapon/tool in the HI line. The Siru is a little heavier and fancier, and makes a fine chopper. The GS chops great as well, is lighter in the hand. I prefer the GS personally, but there's nothing wrong with the Sirupati! I have a 25" model that is a great chopper. The 22" GS is a totally different animal though- swift and sleek, but still made short work of a 4" diameter tree.
 
Yvsa, I picked up a blem BabyGR over a year ago, 17.5" and about 2lbs. I do take it hiking a lot. It has the old convex edge and was made by Sher.

Swashtar, Mr Bad Example has voiced what is the general concensus concerning the Gelbu vs Sirupati. Now try comparing the Gelbu vs the Chitlangi...ouch, that's close! But the Gelbu's seem to run slighter lighter.

Stripey, what's in a name? I was a little hestitant to talk to MrBad Example, but Stripey 357 was easy to approach- go figure.

munk
 
Agree with Yvsa. Those BGRSs are great khuks.
As far as the Siru/GS/Chitlangi are concerned I'm looking at one of each made by Sher. All are 18" models. Of course the Chit(double fullers) fells different due to the handle shape. The other two feel almost identical. Sher didn't put the deepest fullers in this GS so it weighs the same as the Sirupati. The GS is a little bit wider spine to edge than the Siru. Both have the same bend in the blade. The cho is in the same spot. Hmmm, not sure if I've said anything here but hope it helps.:confused:
 
I have an 18" Gelbu Special by Bura, and it is one of the best examples of craftsmanship I have ever seen. It is certainly a thick blade at 3/8", but the fullers and the weight distribution make it much lighter than it looks. It is not 'light as a feather'...that's the honor reserved for my 18" Kobra (also by Bura), but it is definitely more of a weapon than a chopper. The wood handle is very comfortable, the buttcap and bolster are perfectly fitted, the cho is a nicely executed dove's eye style, and the swords of Shiva are straight. Slight ripples of the hammer's mark can be seen along the surface, making it that more personalized. The scabbard is also of high quality, with consistent leather grain, great stitching, and perfect scabbard-to-blade fit. Karda and cho are also excellent.

If it had steel fittings, and an old style bolster, it would be perfect but only from an aesthetic point of view. Otherwise, it is TRULY a 10/10...
 
LMRRAOPIPAICGU

ok,ok, maybe i might buy one more in like ten years or so.
You must tell me what your acronym stands for...
 
Originally posted by munk

Stripey, what's in a name? I was a little hestitant to talk to MrBad Example, but Stripey 357 was easy to approach- go figure.

munk
Click to expand...

You are certainly welcome to call me stripey, just don't call me late for dinner.
 
All the sirupatis I've held (4 or 5, of varying lengths) just felt "wrong" to me. My Chitlangi feels good.
 
Originally posted by DannyinJapan
LMRRAOPIPAICGU

ok,ok, maybe i might buy one more in like ten years or so.
You must tell me what your acronym stands for...
Click to expand...

Laughing My Royal Red Ass Off, Pissing In Pants And Can't Get Up.:D ;)

Royal Red because everyone thinks there are really ndn princesses.:rolleyes: :p ;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top