Snapped one sog dagger in half, trying to figure out which one

Joined
Jul 10, 2009
Messages
3,094
It was an older model, had it for a while and never really used it. Threw it a couple times into a tree round we use for axe/knife throwing, and heard a ping, blade was stuck in the tree round, handle on the ground.

Anyone know what model it is as I bought it quite some time ago.

broke.jpg
 
Desert Dagger.

Sorry.........it is no longer made.

I would say this knife was not made for throwing...................

Robbie Roberson.
 
Obviously, you threw it into a tree not found in the desert.

Should've checked first.

Guess they don't have pine out there..

I was just kind of shocked after I stuck it and it just snapped in half, barely even throwing it hard.
 
Well the Desert Dagger was never designed to be a throwing knife.

It was a dagger - mean, thin and slick enough to penetrate easily. I don't fault it for being thin and breaking easily. It will stab well but just don't throw it. Hope you learnt your lesson.

Guess they don't have pine out there..

I was just kind of shocked after I stuck it and it just snapped in half, barely even throwing it hard.
 
Well the Desert Dagger was never designed to be a throwing knife.

It was a dagger - mean, thin and slick enough to penetrate easily. I don't fault it for being thin and breaking easily. It will stab well but just don't throw it. Hope you learnt your lesson.

Yes, yes I did learn my lesson. Next time I find an old SOG knife, don't use it for anything.

A knife made for stabbing/penetrating should be able to be lightly thrown into soft wood more than once without snapping in half. I've thrown every fixed blade I own, some more than others. My Busses get thrown more than anything, but everything gets a throw or two. I've yet to have one break on the second throw until now. Sure throwing knives are hardened much softer than knives meant for cutting, but having thrown everything from kitchen knives, to axes, to battle mistresses, i've never had that happen before. I had the handle scales fly off an old frost bowie that I had since I was a kid, but the blade never broke. I threw one of those ozark trail 7 dollar folders from walmart over 100 times before the lock broke, the blade never broke.

I don't want to hear the argument that "it's not meant for throwing", any quality knife should be strong enough to handle impact in a soft target a couple times, steel shouldn't be hardened to glass fragility, especially a "stabbing/penetrating" knife.

Honestly, I wasn't posting to really complain about the knife, I couldn't care less about the knife, I was just curious what model it was so I could see what I paid for it years ago.
 
I personally think it should never have broken due to throwing it into a tree, stump or a concrete bridge abutment. The blade was defective as far as I concerned, but my opinion carries no weight what so ever.
 
What's with the crossguard? That thing was soldered in place, but now it looks like it broke loose.
 
I have a desert dagger, it throws nice for a handle heavy knife but I definitely wouldn't recommend throwing it. the blade is thin, since its designed for stabbing, and probably way too hard for a thrower. not really a useful knife but it sure looks cool.
 
Back
Top