I've noticed a lack of thunderous praise for SOG around here, too. But, there aren't a bunch of critics, either...
I've owned one SOG knife, the Autoclip, and liked it very much, except on 2 counts - the blade would dull very easily. It was easy to sharpen, and also similarly easy to dull...

My second gripe with this specific knife was the autoclip.... the tensioning was completely non-functional and the clip flopped freely... with that in mind, it also came to me used, so who knows what the previous owner had done with it. I greatly prefer a steel clip, anyways.
I think the lack of acclaim for SOG has been due to 2 or 3 major factors: first, they don't use high-tech steel, nor do they use much carbon steel. Therefore, in general, their knives would dull easily. Secondly, they haven't had a lot of modern designs, until fairly recently. Third, they don't seem to toot their own horn very loudly. Taken together, those 3 things seemed to have equalled a quiet, but successful, company.
Nowadays, though, SOG seems to be kickin' it up a notch. They've added a bunch of modern, tactical folders to their line-up, are using AUS-8 steel, and are getting their products out there and into the consumer market's consciousness. And, based on the reviews I've read and the knives I've seen, I think SOG is putting out some good products. I expect them to keep doin' just that

:thumbup: