SOG S1 with satin/chromed finish

Joined
Dec 18, 2009
Messages
7
Hi everybody. I've got a SOG S1 with "Vietnam 5th special forces" and the MACVSOG special forces logo and all but it has a blade which is NOT gun blued but high gloss satin finished or even chromed (?) Anybody of you guys know about this kinda special editions for the S1? There is a similar knife now posted on Ebay, nr 130357001910, you can look at the pics there. The seller and I are both wondering who knows more about these beauties...:confused:
 
I don't think SOG ever produced such an S1 Bowie. Most likely someone had their S1 Bowie chromed after the gun-blue finish came off.
 
is it an optical illusion? or has part of the top end of the guard been squared off and thus effectively shortened?
 
I do not think that is a SOG knife. I really think it is counterfeit.

First clue is the guard as GIRLYman pointed out. The top part of the SOG guards are more pointed and that one looks squared off.

Second is the finish. It seems to be a chrome coating instead of a polished finish. Check out the sharpened edge. It appears to be the same as the main part of the blade, indicating that it was coated after it was sharpened.

Third is the tip. All SOG Bowie knives have had both the top and bottom of the tip sharpened.

Finally the handle itself looks weird. We have not used a stacked black leather handle on any of our knives.

Also, the stamping of the logos look a little off. The SOG ones are very crisp and these look a little rounded.

Just my thoughts on this.
 
Well...that would be nasty. I don't have time now to post pics of my own actual SOG but it also can be seen on Ebay: nr 110443332957. Chris, could you please take a look and give your opinion? I can post pics myself tomorrow, let me know if you need any special details.
 
my 2 cents worth is that it could be a refurbished job on a not so minty knife.
or how would you explain the need to remachine the guard and because it had to be chrome plated, a re-handle.
 
Everyone has a correct take on this one. Some other comments.

1. Finish - we all know that the S1 Bowies came with a gun-blued or tigerstriped finish. nutz is spot on on this one. As he correctly mentioned, the gun-bluing wore off and the owner chromed it to cover up the flaws.

2. Guard - It is chipped, like GIRLYmann noted. My guess is that while touching up the knife with a machine he damaged it and now had to smoothen it out.

3. Tip - Like Chris mentioned, all SOG Bowies come with a "faceted tip" or a tip with a little on the top sharpened. The fact that this is missing indicates that the tip was chipped off and was sharpened to create a new tip.

4. Handle - This is not a black leather handle, but rather a normal S1 Bowie handle that has been treated and aged. If you notice carefully, the SOG S1 Bowies have WHITE washers. You can see that the white washers on this one has turned to a dark brown color - a sure sign that some tanning was done to the handle.

5. Logos - My guess is that they look rounded because the owner tried to sand off some rust or tarnish before chroming.

Nevertheless it still looks to be a presentable knife. You can tell from the sheath that is is quite an old production S1 Bowie too. The owner is honest enough to say that it has been chromed instead of passing it off as a Special Edition S1 Bowie as some people have tried to do. He mentioned that it has a factory edge, which is not true.

You can take a look at the pictures on our site for clearer pictures of the engravings, faceted tip and finish.

Hope this has cleared up some doubts. If you wish to buy this knife please know that what you are getting is NOT a special edition S1 Bowie and proceed with caution.


Cheers,
Mark ;)
SOG Knives Collectors
 
Mark, many thanks on your remarks. But: I was hoping to get more info on my own knife. I don't seem to be allowed to post pics of my own knife so it can be seen on Ebay, nr 110443332957. Would you please be so kind to take a look? Same for Chris@SOG. I would be very happy with your comments on this other, my own, chromed S1.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top