• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.

  • Today marks the 24th anniversary of 9/11. I pray that this nation does not forget the loss of lives from this horrible event. Yesterday conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was murdered, and I worry about what is to come. Please love one another and your family in these trying times - Spark

Some helpful technical specs and info on several different throwing knives

Joined
Jul 14, 2013
Messages
71
Being fairly new to (recreational/sport) knife throwing I have had to learn the $$ way what knives I would enjoy throwing, and/or be able to throw the best as I have been increasing in experience, skill, and of course always learning. Also there is the cost vs. quality aspect as well. This is a 'hugh and broad' variable for each person on what they want in a knife, and how much we're willing to spend for it/them. What I have learned is I pretty much like most knives out there, (some better than others) both custom and mass produced, but always learned about the "true specifications and dimensions" after I or friends received them.

Having been hit with an early rough temp wise extra cold winter here in MN, (other places I've hear as well) not being able to throw as much as I'd like, I decided do 'something' different. Using my 30+ years as a machinest, sheetmetal fab, engineering, and inspection experience in the manufacturing industry I worked in, I though I'd inspect, compile and document (some limited) data on as many throwing knives as I could get my hands on from my own collection and a couple friends.

I spent over a month collecting these specs/dims with properly calibrated digital 6" - 24" calipers, micrometers, scales, etc. Then about a week trying make an (appropriate?) spread sheet to give enough information to help others and me see what these knife specifications really are in the specific units I had available to me. No right or wrong on anything spec'd out, just the actual findings. You can draw you own conclusions. The only 'opinions' from me is in the last column of 'Misc Notes Info" where I stated what I thought based on my limited experience. Some data like "Material and Hardness" is taken from the published info by the manufacturers as I didn't have the proper equipment (other than a file test) to test the actual hardness here at my house.

This spreadsheet below is bigger than you see, but I couldn't save the original as an image, or paste it as a table because of it's size, so I eliminated some categories like "material finish", "handles or scales", etc.. Not crucial information, so you can find that out on your own if so interested. I also didn't list any retailers or prices per forum rules, and obviously on the mass produced items there are so many places and different prices, you can also find that out on your own.

Once again this information is what I found using modern mfg inspection equipment and techniques, and is not all inclusive. I found several ranges in specs on some models. Your own findings may vary from these. Hopefully some will find this helpful or at least informational for their own wants/needs on the knives specs listed on the spread sheet below. Otherwise just a fun project for me to have worked on. I plan to add to this list as I/and my friends pick up other knives in the future, but this is a good start.

Sorry about the size or clarity of the image, but after a dozen or so tries to save/post it in any other format, this was the best I could do. Re-sizing your computer/tablet viewing window larger seems to help see it better.

FWIW concerning my experience and 'current' lack of knife throwing expertise, I actually enjoy throwing all of these knives listed and find all have there good points and some not so good. But that also varies with each and every one of us and our skill/experience level. Enjoy!





"
 
This chart is great! It should be very helpful to folks wanting to check out something new. The only issue I take with it is on the John Bailey design mini bowkries which I find to be too thin at the pointy end and they seem to bend much more easily than everything else on the chart. You have them listed as very consistent and I believe it but they are also thin and light for their size. I have thrown most everything on your chart except the Bill Page and Flying Steel knives and find the bowkries to be the least durable of all the others. I haven't broken a point yet but in only a few hundred throws have straightened them all out two or three times so it is coming soon. If shortened a bit, which will probably happen without any help from me, I will reconfigure them so that the points are thicker. The shorter blade will throw point of balance to the rear a bit and help with no-spin.
 
Thanks Renaissance and WW...

WW, -Thanks for the input on the chart and that particular knife.. I was hoping to get some conversations going on each persons experiences with particular knives. I also figured my Column of "Misc Notes, Info" might get some reactions..

I think it will help straighten out my thoughts vs. someone else's on the spread sheet being more just the facts of what I found dimensionally on (X) number of units. Then my only opinion is like as follows:

"Inconsistent Specs (except...)" = over a certain quantity (measured/tested) the "Length/Matl Thickness/Weight" ea. shows a larger disparity (some or most specs) than other models.

"Consistent Specs" = over a certain quantity (measured/tested) the "Length/Matl Thickness/Weight" ea. shows the specs are in the middle range consistency compared to other models.

"Very Consistent Specs (except...)" = over a certain quantity (measured/tested) the "Length/Matl Thickness/Weight" ea. most all specs are the most consistent compared to other models.


Nothing judging the knifes individual throwing or handling preferences or performance really. And also I added the statements;

"No right or wrong on anything spec'd out, just the actual findings. You can draw you own conclusions." and " I found several ranges in specs on some models. Your own findings may vary from these. "

So just to correct and be clear.. I actually listed the Boker Bailey Mini Bo-Kri dims/ specs as "consistent", not "very consistent".. :) And I can personally state here that I do agree with your findings, and that I also 'feel' the Bailey Mini Bo-Kri 'design' is too thin and light for their over all size.. I also think of all the knives I own and or have thrown on that list, that they are not the most sturdy feeling. Subjective feelings and actual specs or facts can go hand in hand, or go in different directions... ;)

So yep, keep the discussions and opinions going.. This will hopefully help other folks decide what might be good for their needs or wants!

"
 
Last edited:
Back
Top