Spyderco Centofante III vs. Benchmade Griptilian?

T

txgolfer45

Joined
Aug 29, 2002
Messages
119
I'm considering these two knives in plain edge. Which would you get and why? The Benchmade 550 Griptilian costs more and has 440C steel and axis lock instead of they VG-10 and std Spyderco lock mechanism.

Thanks,
Scott
 
I can't speak for the Spyder, but get the Griptillian, just buy it from Cabela's. That way you get D2 Steel. Around $ 80 at their website.
 
I have a 550 Grip and I cannot recommend it enough. I love it and it is a more sturdy knife than the Centofante III. The Centofante has a really thin blade which is great for slicing things but it looks almost too thin to me. I like the fact that the Benchmade has an adjustable pivot and an Axis lock also. You just cannot get more knife for your dollars than a Griptilian. If it's going to be an every day carry I would stick with the 440C and not the Cabelas D2. 440C holds a razor sharp edge, is easy to sharpen, and is more corrosion resistant than most other blade steels.
 
I love both these knives, but the minigrip is almost impossible to beat. Get the minigrip. And if you can afford it, I recommend the Cabela's D2 minigrip.
 
This is a strange comparison; they're just not that similar. Now, choosing between a Spyderco D'Allara and a 'Tilian is another story...
 
Shmackey said:
This is a strange comparison; they're just not that similar. Now, choosing between a Spyderco D'Allara and a 'Tilian is another story...
Click to expand...

I tend to agree. The only downfall to the D'Allera is that it is so darn thick.
 
Actually, the new D'Allara drop-point is much thinner than the 1st gen (rescue style) D'Allara.
 
I can't speak to the Spyderco model mentioned. But I have a Cabala's D2 Griptillian and highly recomend it. Best folder I have ever owned. I have had a couple of them now and can't find anything I like better to EDC.:thumbup:
 
Centofante III.
For sure. I find that the handle on the grip is simply to coarse and extended use makes my hands ache. Also, It feels too small to get a really secure grip on.
The Centofante III just feels so nice. It slices and cuts so well. I can't wait for my new one to arrive.
 
I loved my Centofante III. It was an all-around great knife, but I can't speak to the Grip, so take that at face value.
 
A week from now when I get paid, I am going to get a Griptilian.

Take that as you will.
 
I have both.

The benchmade is thicker, perhaps a bit sturdier. I would carry it around the house or hunting.

The spyderco is thinner, but very nice. I would carry it at work or as a money clip.
 
I have both the Cabala's D2 Griptillian and the Centofante III. The Griptillian finds its way into my pocket most days.

Traderdell
 
A Centofante III is my edc. Due to it's thin blade it is a VERY good cutter. One of the best on the marked. Tip up it is also fast from the pocked in the hand. The handle in good in almost any grip. I do not know the Grip very well but do think most Benchmade edges are to thick if you are looking for hi-performance.

JD
 
True. Most Griptillians we get in need considerable edge work. But I never found that to be too big of a deal.
 
Never had a Grip, so I can't compare, but the Centofante III is a wonderful knife. It is easily worth its price tag and more. One of the best values in knives out there.

KInd of depends what you are looking for I suppose. I don't think a Centofante is what anyone would consider a "hard work" knife. The blade is quite thin. This also makes it an awesome slicer though.
 
I have both, but my Grip is D2.

Lock: Grip wins this one hands down. The axis lock rocks.

Steel: Both knive came very sharp, but the Spydie is easier to keep sharp.

Handles: Grip fills the hand more, Spydie carries in the pocket better.
 
I went with the Griptilian 550. Picked it up at a gun show this weekend. I have 3 Spyderco's (Endura, Delica, Native). This is my first Benchmade. It looks very well built. I was able to compare the Centofante III to the Griptilian side by side. Both are excellent knives. But, the Benchmade won out this time.

Scott
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top