I have a Wicked Edge, which I love, but I use it now mainly for reprofiling. That's because I got a Sharpmaker a few months ago. I love the fact that I can set the SM up quickly, and touch up my edges quickly. It is also pretty compact, so when I'm camping I can take it with me, whereas my Wicked Edge is more involved and bulkier. I actually purchased a set of stones in the last year or two, and have been learning to free hand sharpen, but then I got the SM and for me it is just so quick and easy to use . I definitely would like to keep pursuing my free hand skills, but for now the SM is what I use the most. The only thing I worry about with the SM, is that I'll drop the rods on my garage floor, which is where I sharpen. I understand they might be brittle, but I've not actually heard of anyone breaking the rods. I'm extremely happy with mine. Most of my knives are S30V, and I have no problem at all keeping those sharp with the SM.