SPYDEREDGED Serrations: Not at all created equal

Joined
Nov 20, 2004
Messages
4,827
It's been a while since I've seen a good talk on Spyderco's different serration patterns. And Yes they may look somewhat the same in the photos but you don't have to own and use very many of the different models to see that there are some profound differences.

For instance there is definitely a different style between Golden Colorado USA Earth serrations and the more spiky variant you get with the Japan made or Seki Japan made models. On Hawkbills I tend to like the more spiky serrations because they do tend to give you a much better piercing action than the Golden CO USA ones do.

Now some of my more favorite Spyderco serration were on the older kitchen models like the K-05 & K-04 models>> they are more of a wavy type serration that seems to work well with food. The serrations I have on my fully serrated CAtcherman model seem to be somewhere in between. So far the ones on that older fully serrated Catcherman model are my favorites for preparing food.

Some of the more interesting Spyderco serrations I remember were on the older original Golden Colorado made ATR model. The ATR was one knife that had some models produced in the USA plant and the others were Japan made. But the USA made ATR had some very interesting serrations.

It's important to know the variations of serrations for sharpening purposes if nothing else. But let's talk about Spyderco's great serration patterns? Which ones do you all like the best? You might also tell us what you find them to be avantageous for? Where in your opinions could they improve?
 
These are the only ones that I have currently. The Hawkbill is an aggressive cutter, the Ladybug doesn't seem to be significantly better than a good plain blade.

DSC_7547b.jpg
 
These are the only ones that I have currently. The Hawkbill is an aggressive cutter, the Ladybug doesn't seem to be significantly better than a good plain blade.

Hawkbills and Spyderedged serrations are truly meant for each other. When I first discovered just how efficient that Hawkbills cut with serrated edges I was just completely mind blown. One day back in 2004 when I was working in a wetlands area in north Missouri I was having a problem with cattails and reeds overtaking a levee I was maintaining. I had been using a fully serrated Endura model which was doing a relatively decent job on the cattails, reeds and vines I was struggling with. But instead I picked up a Spyderco Spyderhawk VG-10 SE blade by mistake.>> and let me tell you that was one of the best mistakes I ever made to my total delight. Ever since that day I always have a fully Serrated Spyderco Hawkbill as a companion blade with me at all times. Having a plain edged standard blade and a fully serrated Hawkbill as EDCs will get just about any job done that needs it.

Since then I've used a multitude of Spyderco's great Spyderedged serrated blades and I'm here to tell you all that there is no reason at all to shop anywhere else to get any knife with teeth. Spyderco has a serrated blade that will work on just about any cutting job you might have. Not to mention some of their past models that I wish would return. I'm currently trying to urge Spyderco to bring back the Temperance 1 model in H-1 fully serrated.
 
Old Catcherman serrations vs "new" Catcherman serrations.

That older AUS-8 Catcherman you just showed in your photo is the exact same one I have and I just love it. I use mine at least 3 to 4 times a week in the kitchen. Yes it's got a low profile wavy type of serration like none I've ever seen on any other Spyderco model that I've had.

The Green handled H-1 Catcherman you have below the older model is also a great blade. I bought it originally thinking that I was going to put it in the collection. But it's turned out to be one great user. I'm going to try to snag another H-1 Catcherman. I wish that Sal would have made that H-1 Catcherman available in full SE even if he were to have used the current serration pattern. The fully serrated Catcherman is a fabulous kitchen knife.

Great Photo Sithus:thumbup::cool:
 
I absolutely love the more shallow serrations. I carry a fs delica at work from time to time and love the way it cuts/holds its edge. My old #1 work knife is a ps millie with shallow serrations that cut like crazy(this reminds me that I need to send that millie to CO to have the detent fixed!). On the other hand though I have a fs 440v and s30v millie that both have super pointy/deep serrations and for me they are useless. The pointy ones just dont work for me. For example when cutting rope the points just dig into the rope and seem to get stuck. One of these days I'll see about grinding the points down to make the serrations more shallow.

The moral of the story is that I love spyderco's serrations if they are the shallow variety
 
I absolutely love the more shallow serrations. I carry a fs delica at work from time to time and love the way it cuts/holds its edge. My old #1 work knife is a ps millie with shallow serrations that cut like crazy(this reminds me that I need to send that millie to CO to have the detent fixed!). On the other hand though I have a fs 440v and s30v millie that both have super pointy/deep serrations and for me they are useless. The pointy ones just dont work for me. For example when cutting rope the points just dig into the rope and seem to get stuck. One of these days I'll see about grinding the points down to make the serrations more shallow

The moral of the story is that I love spyderco's serrations if they are the shallow variety

Yeah I know what you mean Brother because the ones on that older Catcherman model are sure low profile and sort of shallow now that you mention it. I also wish that they would do more with some of those wavy serration patterns like the ones that the made their kitchen knives with.

Also the serrations I had on my old Golden Colorado made Titanium ATR that was fully serrated were sort of shallow as well. They were very efficient cutters though because the guy I sold that knife to really loved it. Also with that type of serration like you have on the older fully serrated Catcherman were really easy to control during the cut>> not all serrated blades can make that statement.

It would be interesting to see what type of research and development that they have planned long term for their famous Spyderedge.
 
I love them all, I just wish we could see more SE, especially on the PM2 and FFG Delica/Endura. And it's a travesty that they are no longer offered on the Military.
 
I love them all, I just wish we could see more SE, especially on the PM2 and FFG Delica/Endura. And it's a travesty that they are no longer offered on the Military.

I do know the reality of "sales" being the driving force behind what makes it to the market. But like yourself that fully serrated Milltary model. the 440V full SE Mili I had. Oh how I would love a Military model in CTS-XHP. It has rapidly become one of my favorite blade
 
Back
Top